Proposal: DeBrincat to New Jersey

[HugeInTheShire]

Another deal that makes no sense at all, NJ shouldn't be trading these kind of assets right now and Chicago shouldn't be interested in moving DeBrincat at all.
This is clearly another deal that has no chance of getting done midseason, revisit in the offseason

 

[GOilers88]

Doubtful, Eichel trade biggest piece was Peyton Krebs.

Most you could get from New Jersey is probably something like.

Debrincat for 1st(top 10 protected)+ Holtz + Johnsson.

Eichel needed disc fusion surgery in his neck and hasn't played all year.

Don't know why people keep pointing to Eichel trade as some sort of baseline for every trade involving a good young player.

 

[Kaners Bald Spot]

Eichel needed disc fusion surgery in his neck and hasn't played all year.

Don't know why people keep pointing to Eichel trade as some sort of baseline for every trade involving a good young player.

If Eichel was healthy, he'd have returned a hell of a lot more. And there would have been teams lining up to trade for him.

 

[GOilers88]

If Eichel was healthy, he'd have returned a hell of a lot more. And there would have been teams lining up to trade for him.

Absolutely. I've seen his trade.referenced a couple of times as a marker for other star players being traded and it makes no sense.

 

[Kaners Bald Spot]

Absolutely. I've seen his trade.referenced a couple of times as a marker for other star players being traded and it makes no sense.

If the Eichel deal has really set the market, then players like DeBrincat are untradeable.

But if the Hawks were going to trade DeBrincat to NJ, it would have to be something like Holtz/Mercer/ top 2 protected 1st as the basis for the deal. The Hawks need 3 high end talents coming back.

 

[GaryU]

25 is a terrible age

I'll take it.

 

[CupSeeker]

Doubtful, Eichel trade biggest piece was Peyton Krebs.

Most you could get from New Jersey is probably something like.

Debrincat for 1st(top 10 protected)+ Holtz + Johnsson.

Hawks do not do this. You are underrating Debrincat since Holtz has not proven anything yet.

 

[StreetHawk]

Value wise it’s a fine offer.

but from a practical POV makes no sense for Chicago. They acquired Seth Jones and extended him. So makes no sense to move DCat for prospects and picks.

 

[Perennial]

I'd pass if I were New Jersey...

 

[TGWL]

Already 24? Love that. Going downhill fast.

I guess I'm going to need a walker soon.

 

[Mrfenn92]

I guess I'm going to need a walker soon.

Your basically done. I’m 37. I’m lucky if I have a year.

 

[Stephen Gionta]

New Offer

To NJ:
Alex DeBrincat

To Chicago:
Ty Smith
Alexander Holtz
2023 1st round pick (Top 5 protected, slides to unprotected 2024 if in the top 5)

 

[CallMeShaft]

New Offer

To NJ:
Alex DeBrincat

To Chicago:
Ty Smith
Alexander Holtz
2023 1st round pick (Top 5 protected, slides to unprotected 2024 if in the top 5)

Probably a fair offer. I'd ask to change it from top 5 protected to top 2 protected, but overall it's fine.

 

[Ace Card Bedard]

To Chicago:
Ty Smith
Alexander Holtz
2023 1st round pick (Top 5 protected, slides to unprotected 2024 if in the top 5)

New Offer

To Chicago:
Ty Smith
Alexander Holtz
2023 1st round pick (Top 5 protected, slides to unprotected 2024 if in the top 5)

 

[Guttersniped]

He changed the original offer to the new one so people new to the thread wouldn’t keep responding to the old offer.

It used to have Kevin Bahl instead of Ty Smith.

And no way do the Devils do this trade.

 

[keppel146]

Why does NJ do this?

 

[Boxscore]

If the Hawks were silly enough to trade DeBrincat they would get more than that NJ package. Ty Smith, nice player. Holtz--meh, gotta see. He could very well be the next Alex Nylander or Eeli Tolvanen. You don't give up a 24 year old 40 goal scorer for that lol.

 

[NjdevilfanJim]

To Chicago:
Ty Smith
Alexander Holtz
2023 1st round pick (Top 5 protected, slides to unprotected 2024 if in the top 5)

Neither team does this....Devils not ready for this type of trade neither are the hawks

 

[benbenthelava]

Already 24? Love that. Going downhill fast.

24 is fine. Nobody likes you when you are 23

 

[TBF1972]

Agreed basically time to retire

can you please finance my pension? i am over due.

 

[TBF1972]

To Chicago:
Ty Smith
Alexander Holtz
2023 1st round pick (Top 5 protected, slides to unprotected 2024 if in the top 5)

the devils need more goal scorers, but not at the expense of a first round pick and holtz, who is the best goal scoring prospect.

 

[Mrfenn92]

can you please finance my pension? i am over due.

Shit man I’m 37. I’m on my deathbed

 

[TBF1972]

Shit man I’m 37. I’m on my deathbed

at 49 i died twice already.

 

[Mrfenn92]

at 49 i died twice already.

Your lucky

 

[Outl4w]

As a bolts fan, the hawks would be stupid to trade a 24 year old 30+goal on a good contract for something that may not even be a 30 goal a scorer. If anyone would be moved it would be toews or Kane if they requested it.