SteelCityCannon
Registered User
- Mar 25, 2017
- 730
- 1,388
Comparing a potential defenseman trade to a goalie trade is hilarious. Has goalie value ever been lower in hockey?
Rumor: David Jiricek available
- Thread starter Rock Paper Sissons
- Start date
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
That and said goalie had been agitating for a move up even longer, and was even more strident about it just before he was traded.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Seriously, I am completely f***ing done with folks constantly pulling this "helpful explanation" bullshit of how the trade market works and why it inevitably means that we have to continue losing somehow. We've been in the league for a quarter f***ing century now and a fair number of us were hockey fans for even longer than that. We've seen this shit unfold before. We're not a bunch of newbie rubes. Show a little g-ddamn respect already.
Aaaarrgghh
Registered User
- Jul 17, 2022
- 674
- 712
And Aaron Portzline reported what I just said. He also noted that he doesn't think it's as imminent as others seem to think. Listening to what Waddell himself has been saying, he sounds like a guy who is not in a hurry to trade Jiricek.
The 2025 class is also considered weak. Where would Jiricek have gone in a re-draft?
To your second, and actually interesting, point: no. Going into the season, I might have thought Calgary's pick had higher value than Montréal's. If CBJ thinks Calgary's pick will be top 10, then that's a different story. The original post said around pick 22, so that's what I responded. My point is that if Waddell trades Jiricek for pick 22 and unremarkable prospect, I don't believe that benefits the Blue Jackets and thus goes against Waddell's motivation for even listening to trade offers in the first place.
Juxtaposer
Outro: Divina Comedia
The structure of the Askarov trade sets a precedent for what it takes to get a former top pick who "wants a fresh start", but I don't see how Jiricek has the value Askarov did. Askarov is the best prospect in the world at his position, was on the cusp of NHL time (and has showed in his two games with the Sharks so far that he's absolutely NHL-ready), and was only even available because of the Saros extension. If Columbus came to me asking for Askarov in exchange for Jiricek, I'd hang up the phone.
truthbluth
Registered User
- Feb 2, 2011
- 7,589
- 7,025
It would be bad mother f***ing juju to win a trade against CBJ right now. Needs to be a fair trade or the hockey gods will be viscious and swift in retribution.
Aside from one (1) Columbus journalist, everyone else is saying they are rushing to make that trade or at the very least not taking their time. Jiricek has not explicitly requested a trade, but we can safely assume that it has been the case since he's on the block. You don't trade a big, talented RHD at 20 years old (21 today!) unless he asks for a trade. They are simply too rare of a commodity and need to just trade one out just for the sake of it.
I've said it many times, this isn't on management. Jiricek needs more time to tune up his game in the AHL. He's not NHL ready (yet) but he truly thinks he is. Whether it's bad advice from people around him (just like McGroarty) or misplaced self-confidence the issue remains the same. I personally don't like young players who think they are entitled to an NHL roster spot rather than work for one and I am pretty certain a lot of people feels that way too.
As for the comments about Jiricek taking "well" his demotion, I'm not entirely sure what else could have been said. I can't imagine the circus it would've created if they said he didn't take it well and privately asked for a trade—which seems a more likely outcome but we'll never know.
Again, as for the return, this is none of my business. It's been reported that Montreal was in on Jiricek but I doubt they are too serious about it. My bet is they are poking around without being too competitive with their offers. They already have two similar caliber big RHD prospects in Reinbacher and Mailloux. They don't necessarily need another one, especially not a the expense of another high-quality prospect elsewhere.
Last edited by a moderator:
Spring in Fialta
A malign star kept him
That's like every single bad franchise in the league goes through that. How many times do Canadian franchises get dunked on? What about Southern teams back in the day?
Get real, no one's out to get you.
KrisLetAngry
MrJukeBoy
Agreed. There is no way Montreal or any other team moves a 1st if it is slotted to be in the top 10 for a player disgruntled and hasn't been hitting where he should be.
I see where your coming from but does that really help out the Nucks now? Jiricek barely getting NHL time on CBJ
Canucks LB
My Favourite, Gone too soon, RIP Luc, We miss you
- Oct 12, 2008
- 78,910
- 33,836
Fair. Just feels more of a future move to me rather than a move to fix a current problem. But you Nucks fans would know better than me obv
SteelCityCannon
Registered User
- Mar 25, 2017
- 730
- 1,388
Disgruntled is a little strong, and he's exactly where a 20 year old defensemen should be.
gritdash60
Registered User
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Two. Both beat writers, one of whom is one of the best writers in the business (Portzline).
Yager for McGroarty or Dach for the 123th or whatever is probably what Columbus is looking at. Askarov doesn't matter
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
The bolded still happens. And don't even try to claim Canadian franchises get the same "you just don't understand hockey" treatment. The homer accusations are one thing and they do indeed happen everywhere (and, yes, it's more common of an accusation for more popular teams); the "this is obviously new to you" talking down attitude is very different.
And I didn't claim it's unique to the Jackets; I merely asserted that folks really ought to just cut that shit out. If they quit it with teams other than the Jackets that's even better.
Nucklehead Supreme
Registered User
- Jul 10, 2011
- 4,390
- 2,379
As long as they don't move WIllander for him, and if thats the case, I don't see what we have that Columbus wants and that can't be beaten by quite a few teams.
Also this hardly seems like the type of player we need now, given he can't even make a Jackets team that is bottom of the league.
Werenski, Severson and Provorov were the top 3. Gudbranson contractually at $4 mill was going to play. Left with beating out 2 of old Jack Johnson and Harris with his 140 odd nhl games and Christiansen with his 40 odd nhl games. Jiricek had like almost as many nhl games under his belt as Christiansen coming into the season.
Van seems to want someone who can play now. So that’s not a fit.
