Connor Bedard Vs. Macklin Celebrini

Who will have the better career?


  • Total voters
    227

hohosaregood

Banned
Sep 1, 2011
33,314
14,066
i think where bedard's been struggling is that his shooting isn't actually that deceptive right now. he's incredibly skilled but his wrister is more about beating goalie by placement and quickness but kind of textbook.
 

Crow

Registered User
May 19, 2014
4,677
3,555
I think his wrister is perfectly fine but he is unable to create space to get it off by skating the puck and no one on the team ever sets the guy up with shit. I’d kill to have a player that is playing like granlund, walman or eklund on the hawks. Having 3 guys playing that well would blow my mind right now after watching this dumpster fire. San Jose has 25% more goals right now (hawks would have to increase their production 33% to match) with 6 players playing roughly at Bedards production level.
 
Last edited:

JoeThorntonsRooster

Don’t say eye test when you mean points
May 14, 2012
33,564
25,979
Fremont, CA
I think his wrister is perfectly fine but he is unable to create space to get it off by skating the puck and no one on the team ever sets the guy up with shit. I’d kill to have a player that is playing like granlund, walman or eklund on the hawks. Having 3 guys playing that well would blow my mind right now after watching this dumpster fire. San Jose has 25% more goals right now (hawks would have to increase their production 33% to match) with 6 players playing roughly at Bedards production level.
Bedard’s 2 most common defense teammates at 5v5 are Alex Vlasic and Seth Jones. It would blow my mind to have those two instead of Cody Ceci and Mario Ferraro, who are Celebrini’s most common defense teammates. So it cuts both ways, although I agree Celebrini has better support in general.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mattb124

Crow

Registered User
May 19, 2014
4,677
3,555
Bedard’s 2 most common defense teammates at 5v5 are Alex Vlasic and Seth Jones. It would blow my mind to have those two instead of Cody Ceci and Mario Ferraro, who are Celebrini’s most common defense teammates. So it cuts both ways, although I agree Celebrini has better support in general.
Both of those guys are good all around players and Alex is an excellent defender but neither one bring much offensively. Neither are capable PP1 QBs. They do put up half decent numbers due to having no one else but you are kidding yourself if you think they are helping Bedards production. Jones is actively hurting it. I’m hoping vlasic continues to progress offensively.
 

JoeThorntonsRooster

Don’t say eye test when you mean points
May 14, 2012
33,564
25,979
Fremont, CA
Both of those guys are good all around players and Alex is an excellent defender but neither one bring much offensively. Neither are capable PP1 QBs. They do put up half decent numbers due to having no one else but you are kidding yourself if you think they are helping Bedards production. Jones is actively hurting it. I’m hoping vlasic continues to progress offensively.
They don’t need to be legit PP1 QBs to help a lot more than Ceci and Ferraro. They’re able to play against top competition and hold their own both offensively and defensively. That’s a lot more than can be said for the Sharks pair who harm Celebrini’s production by getting caved in and failing to get the puck out or support the cycle when in the offensive zone.
 

Metroid

Слава Україні!!
Sep 6, 2006
5,570
6,011
Hellmouth
Funny story, early this year just to see if I could get my buddy who's stubborn to budge on a Bedard trade in a keeper leauge.. I offered him Makar, Marner, Otteinger, and my first... And he declined 😂

He's currently 1-7
I'm 5-3
(Ironically his only win came vs me last week but we both had the top two pts that week and I lost by 0.4pts so it was a fluke win) Funny shit tho.
 

Mattb124

Registered User
Apr 29, 2011
6,859
4,513
Bedard leads his team in scoring and he has no help. He has 4 more points than the next player on his team and only two other players have more than 10 points.

Celebrini missed some games so he’s 6th on his team in total scoring, but even by ppg he’s not leading the team . There’s 7 other players on the Sharks with more than 10 points.

Bedard is the more talented of the two and more likely be a star, although Celebrini is very much making his own case as well.
That analysis is really skewed in favor of Bedard. Celebrini is an 18-year-old coming off injury - which caused him to miss 12 games, almost half the season to date - who is still adapting to the best hockey league in the world. Despite the headwinds he is playing at an almost ppg clip (0.94) and making contributions in all 3 zones on what was the worst team in the league last year. That is damned impressive and more impactful than what Bedard put up in his first year in the league (.90) and what he has done season to date (0.73).

Bedard is undoubtedly the more gifted offensive player, but having watched both play this year I think Celebrini will end up being the better player due to his 200 ft game.
 

Phrasing

Registered User
Nov 16, 2007
4,945
3,287
That analysis is really skewed in favor of Bedard. Celebrini is an 18-year-old coming off injury - which caused him to miss 12 games, almost half the season to date - who is still adapting to the best hockey league in the world. Despite the headwinds he is playing at an almost ppg clip (0.94) and making contributions in all 3 zones on what was the worst team in the league last year. That is damned impressive and more impactful than what Bedard put up in his first year in the league (.90) and what he has done season to date (0.73).

Bedard is undoubtedly the more gifted offensive player, but having watched both play this year I think Celebrini will end up being the better player due to his 200 ft game.
I don’t have a problem in saying Celebrini is the more prototypical center and better all around game. He’s also younger and first year. But I also believe that he has much more help than Bedard has ever had and Bedard has carried much more of a load and demonstrated more productivity as a result.
 

elmaco

Registered Hockey Fan
Feb 1, 2017
2,468
1,562
That analysis is really skewed in favor of Bedard. Celebrini is an 18-year-old coming off injury - which caused him to miss 12 games, almost half the season to date - who is still adapting to the best hockey league in the world. Despite the headwinds he is playing at an almost ppg clip (0.94) and making contributions in all 3 zones on what was the worst team in the league last year. That is damned impressive and more impactful than what Bedard put up in his first year in the league (.90) and what he has done season to date (0.73).

Bedard is undoubtedly the more gifted offensive player, but having watched both play this year I think Celebrini will end up being the better player due to his 200 ft game.
Celebrini is more 'Barkov', Bedard more 'Matthews'.
 

Sasso09

Registered User
Jan 2, 2009
12,700
2,225
Chicago
Holy whiplash, what exactly do you think 2-way means then?
Monster is the operable word. try to keep up

Being responsible 2way doesn't make you great 2-way. Celebrini's defense is getting ridiculously over hyped at this point.

I actually wonder if part of why the Michkov fans hate Celebrini so much in these threads is related to the trauma of Ovechkin ultimately losing the Crosby-rivalry. Obviously Celebrini is no Crosby talent-wise, but being his stylistic heir might be unconsciously triggering some of the folks on here.
Swing and a miss.

Celebrini simple isn't on the level of Bedard or Michkov, that's what's going on here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeadLiceHatty

Sasso09

Registered User
Jan 2, 2009
12,700
2,225
Chicago
Bedard is fantastic when he has the puck with an absolutely ridiculous shot, he is lacking a bit in size and speed which impacts how effective he can be if his teammates cant help him utilize those assets more. Celebrini I haven't watched enough yet but he does seem bigger and faster which helps his overall game, too early to say who is better for me.
This just isn't true. Celebrini looks very small, he's 1 lb heavier than Bedard and.1 inch taller. There's no notable size difference. Celebrini is the quicker skater, that's true.
 

Luigi Lemieux

Registered User
Sep 26, 2003
22,321
11,070
This just isn't true. Celebrini looks very small, he's 1 lb heavier than Bedard and.1 inch taller. There's no notable size difference. Celebrini is the quicker skater, that's true.
He's over 2 inches taller, which is significant when you go from 5-10 to 6 ft. And that difference doubles when talking about wingspan.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: StrawHatEklund

On The Prowl

Registered User
Mar 13, 2024
251
431
This just isn't true. Celebrini looks very small, he's 1 lb heavier than Bedard and.1 inch taller. There's no notable size difference. Celebrini is the quicker skater, that's true.
I have only seen highlights of Celebrini and when he played for Canada at the WJC, so you may be right about the size. Even if they are both small it is of course useful to be faster, the NHL is filled with big, fast, and mean players looking to take your space away.
 

OverTheLine

Registered User
May 11, 2011
192
226
Swing and a miss.

Celebrini simple isn't on the level of Bedard or Michkov, that's what's going on here.
What, you don't think my tongue-in-cheek attempt at psychologizing strangers through the internet was accurate? I'm shocked!

I guess I just find it odd––suspicious, even––that the two biggest Michkov boosters are also coincidentally such Bedard-fans that they also show up here in this non-Michkov thread seemingly only for the purpose of dismissing Celebrini's potential. You I can maybe understand, given the Chicago avatar, but your 'comrade' just seems like he's here to be a hater.

I personally think all three are going to be the new faces of the league in five years time. I'm really, really high on all of them. And certainly nobody knows what the long-term career outcomes of the three are gonna beyond pure speculation and conjecture, especially given the very impressive early resumes they've all put out (like, are you really so convinced Macklin is 100% a step behind given what he's accomplished already? Or are you just being contentious?). It's very possible that any one of them could be the best overall player, and any one of them could be the 'worst.' None of us frankly have any idea, just a small body of work to guess off of.
 

Sasso09

Registered User
Jan 2, 2009
12,700
2,225
Chicago
Bedard’s 2 most common defense teammates at 5v5 are Alex Vlasic and Seth Jones. It would blow my mind to have those two instead of Cody Ceci and Mario Ferraro, who are Celebrini’s most common defense teammates. So it cuts both ways, although I agree Celebrini has better support in general.
Valid point, but Walman has been great this year
 

dgibb10

Registered User
Feb 29, 2024
3,905
3,546
Both of those guys are good all around players and Alex is an excellent defender but neither one bring much offensively. Neither are capable PP1 QBs. They do put up half decent numbers due to having no one else but you are kidding yourself if you think they are helping Bedards production. Jones is actively hurting it. I’m hoping vlasic continues to progress offensively.
The hawks have brought in good defensive dmen with Martinez, brodie, vlasic, jones as a crop.

Now they just need to figure out some firepower around bedard
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad