I am a huge EJ fan, but even I have to admit he has been pretty average this season. That said "huge disappointment" and "robbed us" is pretty Pejorative Slured. I honestly don't know how anybody could rate this trade after 2 seasons (1 full season, ½ on Avs, and ½ Lockout), except you're judging it on HFboard terminology and looking at stats.
I liked Stewart, but the guy is streaky as hell and would still be one of our main trade pieces if he was on our team currently. I do agree that losing Shattenkirk sucked, though I would like to see what Elliott and Barrie have before judging the whole thing.