Most of us like Schneider, except for the people who are advanced stats only in their analysis.
His analytics are kind of bad, but he’s almost always saddled with whoever is our 6D (and this is not a team with 6 NHL defensemen), so it’s kind of tough to judge him on that.
There’s nothing wrong with him. He’s just gotten put into a spot where there’s little opportunity to advance beyond our 5D (and really for any smart coach he would play less than 5D minutes because Fox should be taking minutes away from the 3rd pair RHD). Maybe it could’ve worked out that he takes 2RHD to start the season and we never trade for Borgen. Schneider earned it, but it didn’t work well with our pairs because Lindgren was injured, which kind of ruined everything. They stuck with the atrocious Miller-Trouba pairing mostly until Trouba got traded. Basically Trouba grifted off the injury to Lindgren in how the pairings were constructed, and when things blew up they traded Trouba, and then acquired Borgen very soon after.
Maybe Schneider could’ve taken the 2RHD to start when Borgen arrived, but he didn’t. I think most figured they’d kind of rotate for the rest of the season, maybe Borgen gets flipped at the deadline. It certainly wasn’t the biggest thing to worry about, as the team had way bigger problems. And then Borgen started playing great hockey. Has been our second best defensemen this season (and hasn’t even been here the whole season). His solid defense helped spring the team at the turn of the year. He kind of calmed down Miller’s pathetic play to start the season. Giving him an extension was something he earned.
It has put Schneider in a tough spot. Our first rounder from this past year is also a RHD, and RHD is never gonna be a big need for us, given we have Fox and can always just give him an extra five minutes, if it ever got bad with the other two, so it makes Schneider expendable (we also traded Mancini in the JT Miller trade, who looks like an NHL RHD). He’d probably do a perfectly fine job as a #4 right now.