Coaching is a serious problem.

Habs7631

Registered User
Feb 28, 2017
412
972
It’s all the for the best.

Tank commander Martin St. Louis will deliver us a top 4 pick this year (Hagens, Misa, Martone or Schaefer) and McKenna next year.

This team needs elite talent and Marty will get us that. He just doesn’t know it yet but he will.

An elite coach would extract more from this team and get us a mid pick (#10-#16). But that wouldn’t do anything in the long run...
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdk

Habby4Life

First pick overall goes to the Montreal Canadiens
Nov 12, 2008
4,519
4,361
It’s all the for the best.

Tank commander Martin St. Louis will deliver us a top 4 pick this year (Hagens, Misa, Martone or Schaefer) and McKenna next year.

This team needs elite talent and Marty will get us that. He just doesn’t know it yet but he will.

An elite coach would extract more from this team and get us a mid pick (#10-#16). But that wouldn’t do anything in the long run...
Yeah, losing badly every night is good for young guys development. Let’s just keep getting rolled for a few more years, that will fix everything.
 

RationalExpectations

Registered User
May 12, 2019
5,248
4,075
It’s all the for the best.

Tank commander Martin St. Louis will deliver us a top 4 pick this year (Hagens, Misa, Martone or Schaefer) and McKenna next year.

This team needs elite talent and Marty will get us that. He just doesn’t know it yet but he will.

An elite coach would extract more from this team and get us a mid pick (#10-#16). But that wouldn’t do anything in the long run...
And if Hagens / Misa / Martone need 5 years and they don't get McKenna (at most 25% chance), then what ? Let s have that product on the ice for 20 years ?
 

morhilane

Registered User
Feb 28, 2021
9,070
11,743
Why Dach played after his atrocious mistake on the equalizer? If you shoot from that angle from that far you need to hit the net, but he had no chance to score from about 40 feet with a wrister. He caught off guard three of his teamates movings toward the offensive zone. The right play was to softly dump the puck. Again, it shows no understanding of situational hockey. It seems coaches are not coaching, or Dach is just dumb, And to make things worst, Marty the genius, sent him on the ice at the end of overtime and we saw what happened. Way to go Marty!!!
Since the season started, only Slaf has been benched and truely demoted...and he as yet to play as attrociously as some other players on the team have. Also, he's "role" on the ice isn't maximizing his skills and talent (like where he's placed on the PP).

The way things are going, Slaf is either going to ask for a trade or MSL gets fired.
 

Hope Of Glory

Registered User
May 24, 2009
5,081
2,714
North Shore
The getting complety outshot almost every game after 20ish games is a pretty bad sign. Implementing a new system is certainly going to come with growing pains, which is why I abstained from criticizing Marty too much so far. But at some point some indicators have to point in the right direction, before the positive results can start to pile in. Sadly, I'm not seeing that right now and we're about a quarter into the season already.

Hopefully Kent can help because we lack talent too but it won't be easy as many teams are in the same boat as us, which will drive up the price of the few available players. Despite the lack of talent, there's no excuse to look that much worse than last year. This is puzzling.
 

MarkovsKnee

Global Moderator
Nov 21, 2007
55,457
70,504
Toronto
Since the season started, only Slaf has been benched and truely demoted...and he as yet to play as attrociously as some other players on the team have. Also, he's "role" on the ice isn't maximizing his skills and talent (like where he's placed on the PP).

The way things are going, Slaf is either going to ask for a trade or MSL gets fired.

Completely agree. Having Slafkovsky in front of the net on the PP is the dumbest move possible. It's not a place to pick up points. It's a position to simply screen the goalie, so other people pick up points. He was great on the RW wall last year, and that's where he needs to be.

But, that position has been given to Dach, who is doing nothing out there. Lol Dach got a one-time demotion to 4th line & has never been benched despite being our dumbest player by far.

Slafkovsky needs to be away from Dach, but MSL has Dach stuck to him like a parasitic twin.
 

le_sean

Registered User
Oct 21, 2006
42,064
45,294
Since the season started, only Slaf has been benched and truely demoted...and he as yet to play as attrociously as some other players on the team have. Also, he's "role" on the ice isn't maximizing his skills and talent (like where he's placed on the PP).

The way things are going, Slaf is either going to ask for a trade or MSL gets fired.
Why the coach hasn’t put back together the one line he knows works is beyond me. Let your three best forwards get going, juggle the rest to find chemistry. Instead he’s letting everyone flounder now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BLONG7 and Egresch

eklund the clown

Registered User
Dec 28, 2010
2,301
2,597
We missed the boat on Montgomery.
I wonder if they even talked to him or do they think that Marty is the one to take them to the promise land ?At this point it doesn't look like it .Looks like he doesn't have a clue.Looks like he has lost the dressing room.What good is having top 5 draft picks when you can't develop them?
 

BLONG7

Registered User
Oct 30, 2002
36,911
23,594
Nova Scotia
Visit site
The getting complety outshot almost every game after 20ish games is a pretty bad sign. Implementing a new system is certainly going to come with growing pains, which is why I abstained from criticizing Marty too much so far. But at some point some indicators have to point in the right direction, before the positive results can start to pile in. Sadly, I'm not seeing that right now and we're about a quarter into the season already.

Hopefully Kent can help because we lack talent too but it won't be easy as many teams are in the same boat as us, which will drive up the price of the few available players. Despite the lack of talent, there's no excuse to look that much worse than last year. This is puzzling.
There has to be some changes coming...............the boys upstairs wanted some improvement, and we are not seeing it from the team or the coaches....In the mix...............was the goal. Basically everyone pretty much has $hit the bed.
Expecatations have changed, but nothing else has..................accountability folks, there needs to be some at this point.

Can anyone see us ripping off a 4-5-6 game win streak? We look the same, or some nights worse than last year. MSL is the captain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hope Of Glory

Egresch

Registered User
Jul 10, 2022
1,075
1,509
Completely agree. Having Slafkovsky in front of the net on the PP is the dumbest move possible. It's not a place to pick up points. It's a position to simply screen the goalie, so other people pick up points. He was great on the RW wall last year, and that's where he needs to be.
I am OK with that part. Slaf is the best player in front of the net other than Gally (who is not part of long-term plan) and is a key reason why our PP is @21,4% (17,5% last season) even if he does not get points for his hard work. Within one year, Dach should be replaced by Demidov, Matheson by Hutson and Caufield might be replaced by Laine, but Slaf will still have his position there.
The only problem is, he cannot shoot from there therefore he lacks scoring chances and goals which led to this mental slump. MSL idiot decisions with constant line changes and sticking him with Dach only multiplied it.
 

Lafleurs Guy

Guuuuuuuy!
Jul 20, 2007
78,830
50,290
There has to be some changes coming...............the boys upstairs wanted some improvement, and we are not seeing it from the team or the coaches....In the mix...............was the goal. Basically everyone pretty much has $hit the bed.
Expecatations have changed, but nothing else has..................accountability folks, there needs to be some at this point.

Can anyone see us ripping off a 4-5-6 game win streak? We look the same, or some nights worse than last year. MSL is the captain.
We had a six or seven game stretch of improved play. Now we’ve followed it up with two clunkers. That’s not good. Already a six game losing streak into the year and we’re about a quarter in.

The question was whether or not that little streak was a trend or a blip and it’s looking like the latter. I was hoping we’d be able to salvage the rest of the year but I don’t see that happening now.
 

SnapVirus

Registered User
Jul 16, 2010
4,558
1,911
Mtl., QC.
Pp1:
Caufield - Gallagher (net) - Suzuki
Hutson - Xhekaj

A) Xhekaj has a +100mph shot. We NEED to use it. It will create more opportunities for our forwards if we have a point shot.

B) Gallagher is the only one on this team who can score garbage goals and who is willing to receive hits.

Pp2:
Dach - Roy (net presence) - Slafkovsky
Matheson - Guhle
 

morhilane

Registered User
Feb 28, 2021
9,070
11,743
Why the coach hasn’t put back together the one line he knows works is beyond me. Let your three best forwards get going, juggle the rest to find chemistry. Instead he’s letting everyone flounder now.
We saw it last year with Anderson, he was awful, low effort and kept getting opportunities in the top 6. Andy didn't improve shit over the season because Anderson wasn't playing "his" game last year...and it shouldn't have taken the whole year to fix that.

Slaf is Anderson from last season, except he's dumped into the doghouse. But Slaf is trying to play something that isn't his game, it's not just the screen thing, it start at zone exit. Slaf is aware that what he's trying to do isn't "his game" too. The puzzling thing is why it haven't been fixed yet. Especially with the 4 days and 5 days breaks the team had since the season started. He actually got worst after the last 5 days break...

Slaf's problem aren't "pet talks" to boost his confidence, someone is litterally trying to change how he play the game from last year... (and according to Slaf that's not MSL, but I suspect there is some MSL in there, see Andy of last season).
 

The Gr8 Dane

L'harceleur
Jan 19, 2018
13,771
27,362
Montréal
Yeah I'm ready to move on from the experiment , he is a good tank commander mais ya des limites. MSL's entire tenure has been showing 2 moves to caufield in practice in his first year lmao
It's obvious that Vincent is the next one.
Wouldn't be suprised one bit , clown organisation , joke league wide
 

Catanddogguitarrr

Registered User
Jul 3, 2016
8,332
6,350
Nowhere land
Monahan trade let to Michael Hage, so did Lehkonen. What about Kulak for Hutson? Is that good enough trade? Petry trade was excellent as well.
Yeah but it's not enough. Toffoli bring Heineman, nothing to compare. Habs traded a lot of veterans players for little in return. Hutson was a second round pick and it happened to be an hit. A bit of luck too. Hage will be good if he doesn't get injured or he doesn't stop jis progression. In 3 years Hage will come here to become what? A second center or a 3rd center? Who will be that center better than Suzuki? I don't see anyone in the prospects except maybe, maybe Hage.

Who will be the second center next year? Dach? Not Dvorak, he will be gone and he sucks anyway. Not Evans, or I hope not. So there will be only Suzuki as a good center for how many wingers? Caufield, Slaf, Laine and Demidov. Suzuki will double shift to be the center of all these wingers? He will be playing 40 minutes a game?
 

Whitesnake

If you rebuild, they will come.
Jan 5, 2003
90,798
39,823
In charge of the Montreal Canadiens organization, we have an agent and an ex-player that coached pee-wee. Supported by a guy who does have experience......at not winning. Also supported by Letowski, Robidas and Roger Grillo who had no coaching NHL experience. At scouting, also supported by Lapointe who had no idea how to do that before he came in. And Bobrov who does have experience.....at being average.

And yet, we are wondering why the hell we are not winning.

Does experience means everything? No...but maybe, just maybe...let say you want to build your house from scratch...what are you looking for when you search for a builder? I hope you look for 2 things...experience and look at their past jobs and how happy people are of what they've done.

We are not there. We are actually picked rookies everywhere but Gorton and Bobrov. And frankly, go back at New York and ask them how both guys did....
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Gr8 Dane

Egresch

Registered User
Jul 10, 2022
1,075
1,509
Slaf's problem aren't "pet talks" to boost his confidence, someone is litterally trying to change how he play the game from last year... (and according to Slaf that's not MSL, but I suspect there is some MSL in there, see Andy of last season).
Of course, he cannot say that publicly because he would be benched forever. It is MSL who put him in front of the net on PP1 and took away his scoring chances. It is MSL who split him from Caufield and Suzuki, because he wanted to spark 2nd line which put even more pressure on Slafkovsky.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad