It isnt dumb. Theres some validity to it.
Hes not playing his powergame and making some lame decisions with the puck. Ive been a little down on him as well. The kid needs to be more consistent using his speed and size. Sure he's still learning to play in this league but i think even he will tell you theres another level he can hit, like how he was playing earlier in the year. He was a force and that hasnt been the case for a while now.
This team needs him to be that way to open space, especially if hes with Richards and St. Louis. Hes taking the body, but hes not driving through guys like he did earlier in the year. He needs to get back to that, because he's one of the few guys on the team that can and the Rangers will need that come playoff time.
He's willing and able to go to the net and thats good, but its his play away from the puck and his puck management that Ive been watching.
But hes not the problem. The big guys: St. Louis, Nash, Richards... need to step up.