CHL can now play NCAA - change everything !



Think he is the 61st O/A to commit. We are above the 1/3rd mark.

Can see between 80-90 O/A to commit by the end of the season.

Also the above X account is stating that Diego Buttazzoni will join Mass-Lowell this upcoming season. If true, he will represent the first CHL player to play college hockey before his junior eligibility has expired.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hockeyville USA


Think he is the 61st O/A to commit. We are above the 1/3rd mark.

Can see between 80-90 O/A to commit by the end of the season.

Also the above X account is stating that Diego Buttazzoni will join Mass-Lowell this upcoming season. If true, he will represent the first CHL player to play college hockey before his junior eligibility has expired.

Bruce McDonald is the most old school NASCAR name I've seen in awhile lmao
 
  • Like
Reactions: Corso
Austin Zemlak (2005, WHL, Tri City Americans) commits to Arizona State

Nice pick up...another 05 off the board to play college hockey next year. There will be a lot of sleepless nights for most CHL GMs are they try to figure out the O/A pool for next year.

Scratch that, looks like he will be returning to the Americans for his O/A season and going to Arizona for the 26-27 season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hockeyville USA
The O has always had the most elite offensive talent, the defense & goaltending can be non existent at times. Almost always recognized as the best of the 3 CHL leagues.

The Dub has historically been the most defensive, most physical, tighter structured, better goaltending league, but this is changing with the elite talent level increasing in Western Canada. The Dub is still a bit behind the O but it has closed the talent gap significantly.

The Q has always been known for the no defense high scoring style, and in recent years, the talent level has dropped off a cliff, as Quebec is the poorest province so many people can't put their kids in minor hockey as hockey & everything else has gotten more expensive. Even more haves and have nots in terms of individuals and teams in the Q. And before the rule change, you were seeing more and more Q territory guys bypassing the Q and going south to the NCAA, weakening the league further.
This is mostly correct except that Quebec probably isn't the poorest province. It is certainly true that the Q's territory in Canada is economically below Ontario and the western provinces.
 
Is it just me or are most of the CHL guys committing to the NCAA are guys who probably would have went the Usports route or lower than AHL route in NA or Europe?
It shouldn’t be surprising that high-profile CHL players who are central to the success of their team and have years of theoretical eligibility in the CHL left aren’t announcing in the middle of the season that they plan to leave the team. That would be awkward at best for the players. It makes sense why they would be waiting until the season ends to make their announcements even jf they already have an agreement with a college in principle. This has been alluded to with Michael Misa, for instance.
 
It shouldn’t be surprising that high-profile CHL players who are central to the success of their team and have years of theoretical eligibility in the CHL left aren’t announcing in the middle of the season that they plan to leave the team. That would be awkward at best for the players. It makes sense why they would be waiting until the season ends to make their announcements even jf they already have an agreement with a college in principle. This has been alluded to with Michael Misa, for instance.
Yes this might be so and my comment was an observation not a predictor or judgment of anything going forward and it will be very interesting to see how things unfold in the next several years.
 
Is it just me or are most of the CHL guys committing to the NCAA are guys who probably would have went the Usports route or lower than AHL route in NA or Europe?

Most high end (and high draft eligible) players have been approached by college programs. I have heard that there have been some "soft" commits by a few but those players are waiting to see where they are drafted and if they are offered an ELC before they make any decisions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hockeyville USA
Most high end (and high draft eligible) players have been approached by college programs. I have heard that there have been some "soft" commits by a few but those players are waiting to see where they are drafted and if they are offered an ELC before they make any decisions.
Hence why I think hockey turns into quasi baseball with how the MLB Draft works for HS guys: those high end HS guys have an NCAA commitment lined up as a fall back option in case they aren't drafted high/aren't offered the slot money they want, but most sign and bypass university, forcing the NCAA coaches to fill spots through JUCO/portal/other new recruits

In hockey, CHLers like Roger McQueen or Porter Martone could have "soft" commitments to Michigan, North Dakota, Denver, etc & then see what the NHL team wants for their development after the NHL Draft & then either go to the NCAA or bypass and sign their ELC. It'll depend on the CHL-NHL Agreement because NHL teams would rather have CHLers in the A or NCAA at 19 years old as opposed to stuck back in the CHL for extra years. Also not sure how NCAA coaches like Hastings, Pandolfo, Carle, Naurato would react to "soft" commits using them as leverage
 
Last edited:
Hence why I think hockey turns into quasi baseball with how the MLB Draft works for HS guys: those high end HS guys have an NCAA commitment lined up as a fall back option in case they aren't drafted high/aren't offered the slot money they want, but most sign and bypass university, forcing the NCAA coaches to fill spots through JUCO/portal/other new recruits
Would need to make all players immediately eligible for the AHL for this to make sense. HS baseball players move to the Minors when they sign, they don't just say stay playing high school. Without a direct Draft -> AHL path, it doesn't make a lot of sense that top Americans in particular will all of a sudden stop playing in the NCAA their D+1. I don't think the ELC + Slide is as appealing as it's been discussed, and think the NCAA season + sign at end of the year is a bit of an overlooked factor.

Other complication there is that very few teenagers are actually ready for the AHL anyways, generally only the high picks. Every AHL team is filled with fringe NHL types with fairly extensive (50+ games) NHL track records. College gives players a pretty logical step up to keep progressing once they've already established themselves as first line, top level players at a junior level, rather than do another year (or two) at the same level once already "conquered".
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad