Value of: Charlie McAvoy

[AvroArrow]

Why would Boston even consider trading him ? Elite young 1D, he's gonna carry their blue line for another 10 years.

 

[LemonSauceD]

[

Canucks fans are weird about McAvoy. He has always been rated higher than Hughes until this season. Is that why the two low ball valuations in this thread are from Canucks fans? Or is there some other history I am
not aware of?

Obvious bait is obvious.

 

[kilowatt]

Pierre-Luc Dubois is in fact available. No low-ball offers, I know what I’ve got

 

[bernmeister]

Easily.

Easily min OP asked for and then some.

McAvoy for Draisaitl

Not with a year left on his deal but it's the kind of target that would work for both teams but instantly the Bruins d becomes thin

First go at this, not fully developed:
Drai, extends 2 yrs close to max, to BOS
Shesterkin to EDM
McAvoy to NYR

correct realistic +s as needed

somethin like dat...

Pierre-Luc Dubois is in fact available. No low-ball offers, I know what I’ve got

Desi: Lucy, you just so ridiculous!!!



ps, Merry Christmas, go see my thread at Rangers board if you are celebrating

 

[SnS]

Easily min OP asked for and then some.





First go at this, not fully developed:
Drai, extends 2 yrs close to max, to BOS
Shesterkin to EDM
McAvoy to NYR

correct realistic +s as needed

somethin like dat...



Desi: Lucy, you just so ridiculous!!!



ps, Merry Christmas, go see my thread at Rangers board if you are celebrating

Goalies don’t have that type of value.

 

[bernmeister]

Goalies don’t have that type of value.

 

[bernmeister]

Goalies don’t have that type of value.

Disagree.
Generically yes.
But superior/elite Gs command more
recent Vez guys are top of the list

this is on top of regular law of supply and demand;
right now, there is a scarcity of top Gs league wide, and Rs only CONSIDER this b'c they have vintage Quick and Garand available to inherit


that ups Shesty value

 

[wintersej]

The only thing that would make sense is if before July 1st when McAvoy’s NMC kicks in; that EDM finds out Drai won’t stick around. Maybe other pieces from both sides go back and forth (like a goalie from Boston) as part of a bigger deal.

 

[Hunter368]

Goalies don’t have that type of value.

Agreed

Plus Shersterkin has a 10 team NMC........what are the changes Edmonton Oilers are on it?

- Cold, Canadian team, 27th OA team in the NHL.......yeh he's not waiving to go there IMO

 

[kcunac]

Canucks fan saying he’s being undervalued. He’s a top 10 D in the league who also shoots right who is signed long term at a reasonable cap. He’s worth Pettersson (not saying we would make that trade). Only caution is potential injury risk. He’s worth more, and is better than, Dobson.

 

[PWJunior]

Canucks fan saying he’s being undervalued. He’s a top 10 D in the league who also shoots right who is signed long term at a reasonable cap. He’s worth Pettersson (not saying we would make that trade). Only caution is potential injury risk. He’s worth more, and is better than, Dobson.

It's a good thing that McAvoy may potentially be available because Dobson is not.

 

[bernmeister]

Agreed

Plus Shersterkin has a 10 team NMC........what are the changes Edmonton Oilers are on it?

- Cold, Canadian team, 27th OA team in the NHL.......yeh he's not waiving to go there IMO

disagree on da bold,
but
concur w/ya on the nmc

 

[The don godfather]

Pld plus plus for McAvoy. Dont know what the plus plus would be?

 

[I am Bettman]

Pld plus plus for McAvoy. Dont know what the plus plus would be?

Don’t want to touch PLD, something wrong with that situation that we don’t know about. All of the physical tools and potential, but not really any long term results.

 

[Gonzothe7thDman]

Pld plus plus for McAvoy. Dont know what the plus plus would be?

Why would the bruins takes on a cap dump when moving Mac?

Makes no sense Don

 

[HockeyVirus]

As a Bruins fan watching every game I feel MacAvoy is highly overrated by basically everyone. Great person, but not a great number one. Everyone seems high on him and now would be the time. I’m not sure if you’ve seen any bruins games this year but it’s basically Pastrnak, and the goalies. The defense would be just as bad without MacAvoy.

Agreed he is heavily over rated on HFboards due to the team he has been on. He's a hit or miss player and awful in the playoffs. I could see a Hanifin type deal being realistic but a lot of people are out to lunch on him

 

[nbwingsfan]

Agreed he is heavily over rated on HFboards due to the team he has been on. He's a hit or miss player and awful in the playoffs. I could see a Hanifin type deal being realistic but a lot of people are out to lunch on him

He led his team to game 7 of the SCF as their 1D Im not sure that’s “awful” by any stretch of the imagination

 

[HockeyVirus]

He led his team to game 7 of the SCF as their 1D Im not sure that’s “awful” by any stretch of the imagination

"lead" lol. He was the least important part of that run

 

[BostonBob]

Agreed he is heavily over rated on HFboards due to the team he has been on.

Quite a comment coming from a guy that has Matthews as his avatar.

 

[GhostfaceWu]

Agreed

Plus Shersterkin has a 10 team NMC........what are the changes Edmonton Oilers are on it?

- Cold, Canadian team, 27th OA team in the NHL.......yeh he's not waiving to go there IMO

Lol let's check back in March something tells me McDavid is gonna make that 27th comment look foolish.

 

[The don godfather]

Why would the bruins takes on a cap dump when moving Mac?

Makes no sense Don

Pld is solid only 26 and the plus plus could be the icing on the cake. Get their top 2 prospects or something like that. It has to be a overpayment for Charlie.

 

[BergyWho37]

As a Bruins fan watching every game I feel MacAvoy is highly overrated by basically everyone. Great person, but not a great number one. Everyone seems high on him and now would be the time. I’m not sure if you’ve seen any bruins games this year but it’s basically Pastrnak, and the goalies. The defense would be just as bad without MacAvoy.
Just think trade him whilst everyone is so high on him.


Thanks professor. I really need to check that auto correct.
I should put in the title no delusional broons fans opinions wanted.
Keep your biased bullshit to yourself

Yeah I’m bias cause I said it would take a special type of offer for Bruins to even consider trading and I don‘t see it happening.
Yet your the one telling me you watch all the games and can’t spell his last name correctly and seem to forget he was basically a point per game until he got suspended on OEL head shot since then he’s been playing a bit paranoid that he’ll cross the line again and now what played 2 games after being on the IR.
But please continue telling me how trading McAvoy makes us better ignoring the fact he’s top 10 probably top 6 defender in the league heck if you consider he’s RD which are even harder to get with his talent for some reason and just about to enter his prime signed long term.. hmm

Signed Sincerely

1 Delusional Broons fan

 

[Gonzothe7thDman]

Pld is solid only 26 and the plus plus could be the icing on the cake. Get their top 2 prospects or something like that. It has to be a overpayment for Charlie.

Dubois

Its time for his own thread. Is he playing injured? He may be the worst player on the team on a nightly basis. Moverare came in and has made more of an impact. The contract isnt going to play out well. Maybe trade him while they can for another recent acquisition that hasnt panned out like Meier...

forums.hfboards.com

not worth the risk Don especially when you are moving your franchise Dman in this hypothetical

 

[The don godfather]

Dubois

Its time for his own thread. Is he playing injured? He may be the worst player on the team on a nightly basis. Moverare came in and has made more of an impact. The contract isnt going to play out well. Maybe trade him while they can for another recent acquisition that hasnt panned out like Meier...

forums.hfboards.com

not worth the risk Don especially when you are moving your franchise Dman in this hypothetical

Maybe that dman brandt Clarke young blue chip prospect might entice you. Kid could be a stud. Everyone has a price gonzo.

 

[TheImpatientPanther]

Not worth a top 10 C but debate on top 10-20 C for sure.
As a Panthers fan, definitely not giving up Barkov for him