Proposal: Cgy-wpg

[RasmusAndersson]

To WPG:
Dougie Hamilton
Morgan Klimchuk
conditional 2017 2nd (if Calgary advances to 2nd round of playoffs)

To CGY:
Jacob Trouba

Click to read more...

 

[Allan92]

Yikes , not a flames fan but I'd feel bad seeing them get fleeced like this

 

[Homesick]

To WPG:
Dougie Hamilton
Morgan Klimchuk
conditional 2017 2nd (if Calgary advances to 2nd round of playoffs)

To CGY:
Jacob Trouba

I hope the Flames do this ~ Oilers fan

 

[RedHot]

Hamilton himself is arguably more valuable than Trouba

 

[GoJetsGo55]

Can we please not trade Trouba until there is any validity to any of the rumors?

 

[BigRangy]

Hamilton himself is defintely more valuable than Trouba

Fix'd

Though Calgary is sort of wasting Hamilton on the second pairing. In a perfect world (and if they wanted to win now) I'd try to trade him for a top 6 winger and a decent #3 d-man like a Petry or similar.

 

[Skobel24]

Pass. I'd rather keep Hamilton.

 

[Georgetown Al*]

Trouba will sign long term with the Jets.

 

[rhinoshawarma]

Fix'd

Though Calgary is sort of wasting Hamilton on the second pairing. In a perfect world (and if they wanted to win now) I'd try to trade him for a top 6 winger and a decent #3 d-man like a Petry or similar.

Hamilton plays 3D but he's worth a 3D and a top 6 player? You can get a top 6 player for him and a small add, but not another D thats close to his value

 

[BigRangy]

Hamilton plays 3D but he's worth a 3D and a top 6 player? You can get a top 6 player for him and a small add, but not another D thats close to his value

Tough to play top pairing when you've got two of the top 15 defensemen in the league ahead of you on the depth chart.

 

[Maukkis]

Tough to play top pairing when you've got two of the top 15 defensemen in the league ahead of you on the depth chart.

It certainly doesn't help him. I just don't think it would be any different if Trouba was there instead of Hamilton - nor would it be any better for us to have Hamilton instead of Trouba. Unless Hamilton specifically loves playing on his offside...

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

To WPG:
Dougie Hamilton
Morgan Klimchuk
conditional 2017 2nd (if Calgary advances to 2nd round of playoffs)

To CGY:
Jacob Trouba

Winnipeg needs LHD not trading RHD for RHD and besides Trouba is a downgrade compared to Hamilton.

 

[Major Happy*]

Would rather just keep Hamilton. He played great after a rough first 20-25 games.

 

[Johnnybegood13]

LOL, No..just not even close.

Hamilton is only 7 months older than Trouba and outpoints him 2 to 1.

After a rough start getting use to a new team/linemates Hamilton ended the season trending up with a career high 12g/43pts, Trouba has trended down from his rookie season with only 6g/21pts last year.

You want a 23 year old 6'6/220lb great skating offensive defenseman it would take Trouba and a big +

 

[Huffer]

LOL, No..just not even close.

Hamilton is only 7 months older than Trouba and outpoints him 2 to 1.

After a rough start getting use to a new team/linemates Hamilton ended the season trending up with a career high 12g/43pts, Trouba has trended down from his rookie season with only 6g/21pts last year.

You want a 23 year old 6'6/220lb great skating offensive defenseman it would take Trouba and a big +

No worries, a Jets fan didn't start the thread, and I doubt the Jets are interested in trading Trouba for Hamilton anyway.

 

[Jeti]

Hamilton himself is arguably more valuable than Trouba

When did Hamilton learn how to play defense? He's older, overpaid and worse.

 

[Double Dion]

Why would the Flames do this? I could at least understand trading Hamilton for a top 6 winger + a middle pairing defenseman. To trade him and other assets for an inferior player makes no sense.

 

[Flames Fanatic]

No.

I like Trouba, I like his potential, but I'm not paying an arm and a leg to acquire him, and then potentially have to pay him the other arm and leg in dollars.

I also don't think he's as proven as Hamilton as this point.

 

[Skobel24]

When did Hamilton learn how to play defense? He's older, overpaid and worse.

Hamilton is not overpaid. His defensive game isn't as good as Trouba, but Hamilton also plays a much better offensive game.

While we're on the topic of overpaid, it will be interesting to see how much Trouba ends up getting.

 

[Flames Fanatic]

When did Hamilton learn how to play defense? He's older, overpaid and worse.

When did Trouba? Trouba is about to be overpaid, and is worse right now, and highly overrated. Hamilton is also a SINGLE year older.

It's easy to play that game.

http://public.tableau.com/shared/7QPM6MP2T?:display_count=yes

Advanced stats suggest Hamilton is better at Shot Suppression and a better possession player than Trouba, while producing better offensively.

The Flames are also one of the few teams that had worse goaltending than the Jets last season, so you can't even say that makes a difference in their numbers either.

 

[Paradise*]

No thanks. Hamilton is mentally fragile.

 

[RedHot]

No thanks. Hamilton is mentally fragile.

No thanks. Trouba is mentally fragile.

See how easy that is?

 

[Paradise*]

No thanks. Trouba is mentally fragile.

See how easy that is?

Whatever works for you.

There's actual backing behind my statement. Not some immature copy cat remark.

 

[Double Dion]

Whatever works for you.

There's actual backing behind my statement.

So a mentally fragile player is better than Trouba at everything except hitting? If that's the case I can't imagine why he wants 6 million +. Hamilton makes less than that, is mentally fragile and a much better hockey player.

Trouba is right up there with Seth Jones for most overrated defenseman in the league. His best year was his rookie year. He's gotten worse every year since. Reminds me a bit of a poor man's version of Phaneuf.

 

[RedHot]

Whatever works for you.

There's actual backing behind my statement. Not some immature copy cat remark.

Oh ok. Wrap it up, we can go home. Hamilton is mentally weak.