Line Combos: CBJ Roster Discussion/Line Combos/Injury Report

Iron Balls McGinty

Registered User
Aug 5, 2005
9,170
7,265
I understand this question but I’m not going to answer it because I was just making (another) snarky comment about message board life.
Understood. I was mainly poking at those who would make fun of someone who is struggling with a mental issue if this is what it is right now and how their tunes might hopefully change if it was ever confirmed as such.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Double-Shift Lasse

Double-Shift Lasse

Just post better
Dec 22, 2004
34,677
15,904
Exurban Cbus
Understood. I was mainly poking at those who would make fun of someone who is struggling with a mental issue if this is what it is right now and how their tunes might hopefully change if it was ever confirmed as such.
I’m not sure confirmation of a mental health issue is in any way definitive or convincing for some folks, sadly.

That said, I see the word “hopefully” in your post and I share that.
 

CannonFire1

Registered User
Jun 22, 2023
191
265
We were spoiled by watching Bob all those years. I hope for the best with Elvis (personally and professionally) but my confidence level in CBJ goaltending hasn't been this low since the end of the Steve Mason era. As much as I liked and rooted for Mason, I didn't think he had the ability to take the team deep into the playoffs (or get them there in the first place). That is how I feel with Elvis now. If he can't get the team where they want to go then he is simply a placeholder.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thebus88

OilersFanatics505

Registered User
Aug 11, 2008
5,525
5,241
Understood. I was mainly poking at those who would make fun of someone who is struggling with a mental issue if this is what it is right now and how their tunes might hopefully change if it was ever confirmed as such.
They’ll change but only for fake internet points. Anyone willing to throw out and laugh at potential mental problems can go play in traffic
 

Cheddarcheese

Registered User
Oct 24, 2023
397
218
We were spoiled by watching Bob all those years. I hope for the best with Elvis (personally and professionally) but my confidence level in CBJ goaltending hasn't been this low since the end of the Steve Mason era. As much as I liked and rooted for Mason, I didn't think he had the ability to take the team deep into the playoffs (or get them there in the first place). That is how I feel with Elvis now. If he can't get the team where they want to go then he is simply a placeholder.
Cant even compare BOB and Elvis. Bob had a Stanley cup contender and Elvis has a bottom 5 team with 4 different coaches LMAO
 
  • Haha
Reactions: puckgoalnet

CannonFire1

Registered User
Jun 22, 2023
191
265
Cant even compare BOB and Elvis. Bob had a Stanley cup contender and Elvis has a bottom 5 team with 4 different coaches LMAO
The Jackets have never been a Stanley Cup contender. Bob's first 4 years in Columbus they failed to qualify for the playoffs 3 times. The year they got in they lost in the first round. You could maybe make an argument for 2019 (when they beat Tampa) but they've never made it past the 2nd round. For most of his tenure Bob made the rest of the team look better than they were. He frequently made highlight reel and clutch saves, and legitimately gave them a chance to win most nights. I can't say either of those things about Elvis.

The team and circumstances around Elvis the last few years have been bad, for sure. But he hasn't shown the ability to lift them to a higher level either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: puckgoalnet

cbjthrowaway

Registered User
Jul 4, 2020
2,297
4,047
The Jackets have never been a Stanley Cup contender.
they were absolutely contenders in 18-19. i'd say that they were contenders in 17-18 as well, but they choked in the first round that year to the eventual cup champs.

teams can be 'cup contenders' without actually making a cup run, and that is precisely what they were in bob's last two years here.

they've never been cup favorites but they were absolutely contenders during the two seasons when panarin was here.
 

Cheddarcheese

Registered User
Oct 24, 2023
397
218
The Jackets have never been a Stanley Cup contender. Bob's first 4 years in Columbus they failed to qualify for the playoffs 3 times. The year they got in they lost in the first round. You could maybe make an argument for 2019 (when they beat Tampa) but they've never made it past the 2nd round. For most of his tenure Bob made the rest of the team look better than they were. He frequently made highlight reel and clutch saves, and legitimately gave them a chance to win most nights. I can't say either of those things about Elvis.

The team and circumstances around Elvis the last few years have been bad, for sure. But he hasn't shown the ability to lift them to a higher level either.
2016-2019 they had the a really really good line up with a great coach and enough to be contenders
 

Cheddarcheese

Registered User
Oct 24, 2023
397
218
Maybe go check the roster for that 1st Vezina win to refresh your memory of reality. Bob sped the process up
better line up then Elvis ever had, you could argue Elvis could have won it in 2019 he had great numbers. other then that hes been with young rebuilding teams
 

stevo61

Registered User
Jul 5, 2011
11,861
13,450
Canada
better line up then Elvis ever had, you could argue Elvis could have won it in 2019 he had great numbers. other then that hes been with young rebuilding teams
Again, go compare the team Elvis had that good year on and Bob's 1st Vezina, especially the defense. I can promise you it was not a better lineup than Elvis had
 
  • Like
Reactions: thebus88

CannonFire1

Registered User
Jun 22, 2023
191
265
2016-2019 they had the a really really good line up with a great coach and enough to be contenders
I guess we have different definitions of "contender." None of that changes my view of Elvis. Bob inspired confidence and gave the team a chance to win most nights. Elvis does not.
 

thebus88

19/20 Columbus Blue Jackets: "It Is What It Is"
Sep 27, 2017
5,284
2,870
Michigan
Elvis sucks, IMO.

Tarasov isn’t much better, but, he’s better.

Greaves/Tarasov are vastly different goalies, IMO. But, similar in effectiveness.

IMO
 
  • Like
Reactions: ClevelandJacketFan

ViD

#CBJNeedHugs
Sponsor
Apr 21, 2007
31,709
22,390
Blue Jackets Area
Elvis sucks, IMO.

Tarasov isn’t much better, but, he’s better.

Greaves/Tarasov are vastly different goalies, IMO. But, similar in effectiveness.

IMO
Gotta do something about the goaltending

I’d trade Elvis for another overpaid goalie with a similar term just to freshen things up
 
  • Like
Reactions: thebus88

koteka

Registered User
Jan 1, 2017
4,468
4,827
Central Ohio

Dylan Tyrer interviewed Chinakhov about playing with Monahan. Chinakhov said that he, Marchenko, and Monahan speak in Spanish on the ice. (He was joking, but in a total deadpan kind of way.) He said that Monahan talks a lot and is very knowledgeable. Chinakhov is the second guy I have heard say that about Monahan on the radio.
 

majormajor

Registered User
Jun 23, 2018
26,774
32,936
Who do we like to move up to PP1 to take KJ's spot? Marchy or Fantilli?

We saw Marchy step up last night and I think he can be a really good half wall guy. Does his connection with Chinakhov help here? He isn't normally much of a static playmaker. And as a righty I'm not sure I like it. Great shot threat though.

Fantilli is also an elite shooter, and I like that he's a lefty there. But he's also not much of a static playmaker, maybe we can work on that? For his development I'd love to see him move up and we can get him in a role where he distributes more. That part of his game hasn't developed as much, partly because he plays so fast and shoots so well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThirdPeriodTurtle

Monk

Registered User
Feb 5, 2008
7,576
5,488

alone-hungry.gif


I know it says "likely to play" but can't help but feel this way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Viqsi

ThirdPeriodTurtle

Registered User
Sponsor
Jul 13, 2022
2,559
1,889
Finland
I’d trade Elvis for another overpaid goalie with a similar term just to freshen things up
Well, Pens fans would probably throw in some nice sweeteners if we take Tristan Jarry off of their hands, similar contract to Elvis just one year longer. Want that? :D

(Spoiler: No.)

Half the fanbases are currently trying to get rid of a goalie...
 
  • Like
Reactions: majormajor

tunnelvision

Registered User
Jul 31, 2021
2,940
3,266
Who do we like to move up to PP1 to take KJ's spot? Marchy or Fantilli?

We saw Marchy step up last night and I think he can be a really good half wall guy. Does his connection with Chinakhov help here? He isn't normally much of a static playmaker. And as a righty I'm not sure I like it. Great shot threat though.

Fantilli is also an elite shooter, and I like that he's a lefty there. But he's also not much of a static playmaker, maybe we can work on that? For his development I'd love to see him move up and we can get him in a role where he distributes more. That part of his game hasn't developed as much, partly because he plays so fast and shoots so well.
Probably Marchenko although I've always preferred him at the bumper. Static playmaking isn't one of his strengths per se but Chinakhov and Werenski aren't good at it either. They will likely create more chances by shifting spots and weaving around the perimeter. I think their handedness (both flanks having their sticks pointing to the wall) will force them to play that way anyway.

I see your point of having Fantilli in a position that is great for pass timing practice, but on the other hand, do we expect him to become a halfwall PP guy in the future, and is that experience going to help his development in even strength playmaking significantly?
 

majormajor

Registered User
Jun 23, 2018
26,774
32,936
I see your point of having Fantilli in a position that is great for pass timing practice, but on the other hand, do we expect him to become a halfwall PP guy in the future, and is that experience going to help his development in even strength playmaking significantly?

Fantilli I definitely see as a strong candidate long term to be a halfwall PP guy. It's the best spot for a shooter like him to unload, though the potential marginal benefit he has over other players might be highest in the bumper. For me he's a lot like Mackinnon, who is also a halfwall guy. Mackinnon was all wheels to start off his career and had to learn how to be more deceptive and more dangerous in static situations. I do think Fantilli would stand to benefit from learning how to play slow in all situations.

Of course Friedman doesn't mention Voronkov.

To be fair to Friedman, it's kind of like people in Columbus also forget about him. Porty devotes about 1/10 of the airtime to talking about Voronkov as he does to Cole Sillinger. For instance he wasn't even mentioned in a discussion listing our potential centers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tunnelvision

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad