Proposal: - CBJ/MIN | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Proposal: CBJ/MIN

thestonedkoala

Going Dark
Aug 27, 2004
28,326
1,856
To Minnesota:
Kirill Marchenko
Cole Sillinger

To Columbus:
Jesper Wallstedt
Marco Rossi
Liam Ohgren
David Spacek

Minnesota gets the best player in Marchenko but Rossi is close. Wallstedt had a rough year and Minnesota has a solid goaltender in Gus so moving him won't hurt the Wild. Sillinger still has potential and offers Minnesota a bigger center to replace Rossi.

Breakdown is Rossi + Ohgren + Spacek for Marchenko

Wallstedt for Sillinger
 
To Minnesota:
Kirill Marchenko
Cole Sillinger

To Columbus:
Jesper Wallstedt
Marco Rossi
Liam Ohgren
David Spacek

Minnesota gets the best player in Marchenko but Rossi is close. Wallstedt had a rough year and Minnesota has a solid goaltender in Gus so moving him won't hurt the Wild. Sillinger still has potential and offers Minnesota a bigger center to replace Rossi.

Breakdown is Rossi + Ohgren + Spacek for Marchenko

Wallstedt for Sillinger
Marchenko is 6’3” top line winger who played through a broken jaw last season and had 30 goals.

Why would Columbus move him to get smaller?
 
Minnesota says no.

Also, Columbus has Greaves now and Gardner coming in the next 5 years. Not sure they're desperate for a young high end prospect. I would see it being more likely that they target a good vet like John Gibson or Binnington as opposed to a Wallstedt Askarov type.
 
To Minnesota:
Kirill Marchenko
Cole Sillinger

To Columbus:
Jesper Wallstedt
Marco Rossi
Liam Ohgren
David Spacek

Minnesota gets the best player in Marchenko but Rossi is close. Wallstedt had a rough year and Minnesota has a solid goaltender in Gus so moving him won't hurt the Wild. Sillinger still has potential and offers Minnesota a bigger center to replace Rossi.

Breakdown is Rossi + Ohgren + Spacek for Marchenko

Wallstedt for Sillinger
uh...yeah... I'm gonna say no. Marchenko is way too important, cost effective and part of the core to be moved. He'll be a long term Jacket. Not saying the players offered are bad, but he's not one that will be moved.
 
Is Columbus building or retooling or what are they doing?
Columbus is out of the rebuild and retool stage. They are looking for pieces to augment the core and improve. The main focus is on the D and in goal (first), but also looking for another big top 9 piece - preferably one that plays higher in the lineup with experience.
 
To Minnesota:
Kirill Marchenko
Cole Sillinger

To Columbus:
Jesper Wallstedt
Marco Rossi
Liam Ohgren
David Spacek

Minnesota gets the best player in Marchenko but Rossi is close. Wallstedt had a rough year and Minnesota has a solid goaltender in Gus so moving him won't hurt the Wild. Sillinger still has potential and offers Minnesota a bigger center to replace Rossi.

Breakdown is Rossi + Ohgren + Spacek for Marchenko

Wallstedt for Sillinger
Why on earth would the Jackets trade away Marchenko... Even for this return it doesn't make any sense
 
1750291289348.gif
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad