Confirmed Signing with Link: [CBJ] F Sean Monahan signs with the Blue Jackets (5 years, $5.5M AAV)
- Thread starter amnesiac
- Start date
- Apr 27, 2005
- 35,400
- 34,146
He's already earned like $40M in his career, I think he's got enough security.
thepuckbunniesband
Registered User
I was referring to the term. Deciding how much money someone needs is not my thing.
Fro
Cheatin on CBJ w TBL
Kimota
ROY DU NORD!!!
This ain’t it.
If Columbus is going to add to an already crowded top 9, they needs to make some moves. But most likely they’re just going to tank their young players values and sell them off for peanuts or let them walk.
They already did that on defense with Boqvist and Bean. Now it’s going to happen to some combination of Sillinger/Johnson/Voronkov/Marchenko/Chinakhov.
If Columbus is going to add to an already crowded top 9, they needs to make some moves. But most likely they’re just going to tank their young players values and sell them off for peanuts or let them walk.
They already did that on defense with Boqvist and Bean. Now it’s going to happen to some combination of Sillinger/Johnson/Voronkov/Marchenko/Chinakhov.
ReimanSum1908
Registered User
29 year old UFA centerman who scored 25 goals and sixty points last year?
The only surprise is that he didn't get seven years at that price given the nature of free agency,
Not nearly as bad a deal as people are making it out to be in that light.
The only surprise is that he didn't get seven years at that price given the nature of free agency,
Not nearly as bad a deal as people are making it out to be in that light.
Their C corps isnt crowded. His competition are 3 kids (Fantilli, Voronkov and Sillinger), Boone Jenner and Kuraly.
I am not exposed
Registered User
CanMerc
#FIRECHEVY
- Dec 7, 2023
- 609
- 818
Not a big fan of the term, but it's going to be negligible in years 4 and 5 when the cap is much higher. He'll end up being a veteran 3C by the end of his deal. I'd imagine his contract will either be moveable or will just be bought out towards the end of the deal.
As a player, though, I think this is a great move to bridge the gap between now and when Lindstrom makes the leap to the big club. Might even make Sillinger expendable in a trade to acquire a defenseman now.
As a player, though, I think this is a great move to bridge the gap between now and when Lindstrom makes the leap to the big club. Might even make Sillinger expendable in a trade to acquire a defenseman now.
If he didn't have that injury history you'd be seeing him make $7m x 7, so the history is mostly priced in on the deal he got.
Short term, $5.5m for a guy who just scored 59 pts is a solid deal. I was hoping for a 3 year term for Monahan but in retrospect that is harder to imagine on a day like this.
I find this contract more in keeping with the general craziness of the day, and not the worst. It's an overpay in term and not cap. Monahan's injury history makes it hard to forecast the long term. If, by chance, he's permanently over his hip/groin/wrist issues, then this would be one of the better deals of the day.
Short term, $5.5m for a guy who just scored 59 pts is a solid deal. I was hoping for a 3 year term for Monahan but in retrospect that is harder to imagine on a day like this.
I find this contract more in keeping with the general craziness of the day, and not the worst. It's an overpay in term and not cap. Monahan's injury history makes it hard to forecast the long term. If, by chance, he's permanently over his hip/groin/wrist issues, then this would be one of the better deals of the day.
Fight4yourRight
“Chuck’s my guy”
- Dec 18, 2017
- 3,933
- 8,242
CBJ showing why they are a disastrously run organization.
Gordian Knot
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2016
- 1,217
- 1,553
Take one million and one year away from that and it is still awful contract.
Columbus just buried their franchise for good.
Columbus just buried their franchise for good.
Xoggz22
Registered User
The fans? We're thinking we've been devoid of any top 6 centers pretty much our entire existence and to have one that is great at faceoffs, should be expected to score 60 points, help mentor the young centers coming up.. the fans should feel pretty good. His projected contract was around $4.6MM/yr. It's UFA so every team over pays. The deal is fine for the CBJ. The risk is the injuries return. If not and he plays at the level he has in the past, this deal is just fine - at least for 3 years.
Personally, I would have liked 4 years max, but it seems every UFA deal is about 1-2 years too long. It's the price you pay. I see a lot of comments about this being the worst deal of the day. Far from it when you factor in team need and what he can bring. Not saying it's a good deal at $5.5 per, but it's far from the worst and a major need for the CBJ
A little dramatic are we? CBJ desperately needs centers. Monahan had a good comeback from injuries. It's a gamble, but it could pay off.
AD1066
Registered User
- Sep 30, 2011
- 7,731
- 4,233
CBJ is one of those franchises I'd love to see succeed, but does stuff like this instead.
zar
Bleed Blue
If you are satisfied with it, then that’s fine.
I will say it this way then..
To all of the Blue Jacket fans who hate this contract, I feel for you, you deserve better. To those of you who like it, congrats!
That's kind of my point, unless Columbus doesn't think Sillinger and Voronkov are more than 3rd/4th line centers.
Zirakzigil
Global Moderator
Happy for him he’s a warrior. If he stays healthy that’s a good deal.
Xoggz22
Registered User
I do think the idea is that Sillinger is likely a 3C+ and Voronkov could slot as 4C or, more likely, a wing. For the coming year, Jenner is expected to be moved back to wing and Kuraly is in the last year of his deal and I would imagine moved at the deadline so having Monahan fills a need even with the young players being added to the lineup.
The first 3 years of this deal have little to no impact on the young players. For the coming year, Sillinger stays at 2C or 3C depending on if they put Fantilli in the middle next year. Voronkov can play 2C or 3C (If Fantilli stays more at wing) and Kuraly 4C. Lindstrom likely has two more years in Juniors and maybe a year in the AHL based on what we hear about Waddell's approach is to allow prospects to develop.
The problem for Columbus is the lack of experienced top 6 centers and having Monahan for the next 3 years at a minimum should be very helpful. Granted he needs to stay healthy so that is a risk. But the 5 years is manageable based on the current youth and timelines. If they push it faster...great.
