Confirmed Trade: [CAR/MIN] Nino Niederreiter for Victor Rask

Status
Not open for further replies.

Uncle Scrooge

Hockey Bettor
Nov 14, 2011
13,730
8,432
Helsinki
Caught couple Wild games since the trade and man does Rask look slow out there. No wonder he's struggling. He looks like Laine the way he moves.
 

Canes

Registered User
Oct 31, 2017
25,204
70,077
An Oblate Spheroid
Rask is more like a future NHL washout former Cane in 2-3 seasons rather than one of those former Canes who goes on to have a career resurgence on a new team. I've said it for a quite awhile now, he's seriously one of the worst players in the NHL now. Even if he goes back to Europe, he'll be in the Allsvenskan (or some other low tier league) sooner or later. Just a brutally bad hockey player who doesn't even seem to give a shit.
 

Stickpucker

Playmaka
Jan 18, 2014
16,231
39,418
I'm a fan of Rask. I hope he can turn it around...if not this season....hope he gets a good off-season and comes back strong next year. Would like to see a win/win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SaskCanesFan

rynryn

Reluctant Optimist. Permanently Déclassé.
May 29, 2008
33,526
3,547
Minny
it would have been great though if he pulled a Staal and suddenly looked awesome. then we got like three AHL defensemen to replace Dumba. Things are looking great.
 

rynryn

Reluctant Optimist. Permanently Déclassé.
May 29, 2008
33,526
3,547
Minny
is it a whiff or is it more like we got beaned in the junk by Carolina and our free base is $1.7m in cap space, with 2 batters out an no one on base in the 9th.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vorbis

Big Daddy Cane

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Feb 8, 2010
14,069
34,276
Western PA
What Niederreiter is doing in Carolina should be an irrelevant consideration for the Wild, particularly when he's in such a favorable situation (EV next to a center producing at a high end level + 1st PP minutes). Lindholm's performance in Calgary doesn't have meaning for my evaluation of the trade with Calgary. HF, which is obsessed with declaring winners and losers, will make a big deal out of it, but you have to be more pragmatic in evaluating the decision making behind these trades; it's not as if Waddell called up Fenton and talked him into it. The pertinent questions to answer are:

1. Are the Wild better off with Rask and the $1.25 mil in cap instead of Niederreiter?
2. It's clear that the league viewed Nino as a cap dump; could he have bounced back in Minnesota, thus opening the door for a better return at a point in the future?

That defines the Minneosta perspective on this one. Trades aren't zero-sum. If one team wins big, it doesn't mean that the other lost big.
 

rynryn

Reluctant Optimist. Permanently Déclassé.
May 29, 2008
33,526
3,547
Minny
What Niederreiter is doing in Carolina should be an irrelevant consideration for the Wild, particularly when he's in such a favorable situation (EV next to a center producing at a high end level + 1st PP minutes). Lindholm's performance in Calgary doesn't have meaning for my evaluation of the trade with Calgary. HF, which is obsessed with declaring winners and losers, will make a big deal out of it, but you have to be more pragmatic in evaluating the decision making behind these trades; it's not as if Waddell called up Fenton and talked him into it. The pertinent questions to answer are:

1. Are the Wild better off with Rask and the $1.25 mil in cap instead of Niederreiter?
2. It's clear that the league viewed Nino as a cap dump; could he have bounced back in Minnesota, thus opening the door for a better return at a point in the future?

That defines the Minneosta perspective on this one. Trades aren't zero-sum. If one team wins big, it doesn't mean that the other lost big.

most Wild fans knew WHY we did it and could agree it made sense even if it's pretty obvious which player was better despite both slumping. Had Rask looked better than Koivu, or Staal, or even Coyle (who is better at wing) it would be an easier pill to swallow but so far he doesn't look like he's capable of that, and as part of the rationale for the trade was getting a viable option at center in the system for when Staal and Koivu age out this trade looks worse. Nino's production is irrelevant, but the fact that he had a markedly better track record and a much greater chance of turning it around than Rask its safe to say the Wild didn't win at all on this one. We would have been better served trading him for draft picks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SaskCanesFan

Bazeek

Registered Lurker
Sponsor
Jul 26, 2011
17,928
11,285
Exiled in Madison
What Niederreiter is doing in Carolina should be an irrelevant consideration for the Wild, particularly when he's in such a favorable situation (EV next to a center producing at a high end level + 1st PP minutes). Lindholm's performance in Calgary doesn't have meaning for my evaluation of the trade with Calgary. HF, which is obsessed with declaring winners and losers, will make a big deal out of it, but you have to be more pragmatic in evaluating the decision making behind these trades; it's not as if Waddell called up Fenton and talked him into it. The pertinent questions to answer are:

1. Are the Wild better off with Rask and the $1.25 mil in cap instead of Niederreiter?
2. It's clear that the league viewed Nino as a cap dump; could he have bounced back in Minnesota, thus opening the door for a better return at a point in the future?

That defines the Minneosta perspective on this one. Trades aren't zero-sum. If one team wins big, it doesn't mean that the other lost big.
1.) No, unless Fenton turns that $1.25m into a unicorn.
2.) At the very least Fenton could have hung onto him until the summer, when cap considerations are looser if not irrelevant. At the very least Carolina still would have been game to make this trade then. There was nothing to lose by waiting except half a season of Victor Rask, which... yeah.

Rask doesn't need to score more or even be better overall than Nino for this to work out for Minnesota, but he does need to be more than a 4th line center making $4m to score 20 points.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SaskCanesFan
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad