Sutter in 17-18 was a legitimately good hockey player, even marred as he was by injuries by that point, missing 21 games that season, after missing most of the 15-16 season. Sutter was overpaid by about 1.5m even then, but he was actually worth around a ~3m cap hit when he was healthy in his late 20's. Haven't seen anything from Dick this season to suggest he can hit Sutter's level.
Confirmed with Link: Canucks sign F Jason Dickinson to 3-Year, $7.95M Deal ($2.65M AAV)
- Thread starter Throwback
- Start date
-
Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
- Status
Hit the post
I have your gold medal Zippy!
I got that reaction from my dates.
Hoglander
I'm Höglander. I can do whatever I want.
Wasted cap space on a player that doesnt move the needle at all. He's a 4th liner that specializes in 5v5 defending, while sucking at the pk and dragging down the offense of whoever he plays with. We are overpaying him to make a whole line completely void of scoring.
f*** Benning, his parting gifts were an expensive 4th line scrub, an untradeable no-offense 7+mil dman with term, and a pint-sized winger that is already on the trade block. Only cost us a high 3rd and a top 10 pick, to f*** the cap with 2 useless pieces, and a midget.
We could do so much better with our cap space, than spendng it on OEL and Dick.
f*** Benning, his parting gifts were an expensive 4th line scrub, an untradeable no-offense 7+mil dman with term, and a pint-sized winger that is already on the trade block. Only cost us a high 3rd and a top 10 pick, to f*** the cap with 2 useless pieces, and a midget.
We could do so much better with our cap space, than spendng it on OEL and Dick.
Desperate moves by a GM who had to win now to keep his job. These moves are mostly on Aqua for letting Benning keep his job as long as he did and buying into the narrative that this team is competitive.
KingofSurrey
Registered User
Yes, exactly. Fredo agreeing to crap moves like signing Dickinson reminds me of this scene.... FAILED moves in a feeble attempt to hold on to power.... Fredo needed to change up and move Dim 3-4 year ago...
F.A's leadership the last few years.... loud at the time ... but ultimately doomed to fail.
{img]
Hilarious comp in hindsight given that Hartman has scored more points in 40 games this season than Dickinson may score over his entire contract.
I wonder if there was some bad analytics stuff done here.
Like, this article on Dickinson is insane :
Further analyzing Jason Dickinson’s game and how he’ll help the Canucks
A whole analytics-based article hyping Dickinson as an elite #3 defensive C that doesn't mention that Dickinson played mostly 2nd line wing (and not at all as a #3C) in 20-21. And that even though his advanced stats look great in isolation ... 5 of the top 12 forwards in the NHL in terms of defensive metrics played for Dallas, so clearly there was something going on over and above the raw numbers.
It's right up there with the Wiercioch takes from a few years earlier. I wonder if the team was suckered by the same stuff? Or if it was just old fashioned back pro scouting? Or both?
__________
That said, Dickinson would be a useful enough bottom-6 winger at like <$1.5 million. As usual, the asset was just destroyed by the contract it was given.
Melvin
21/12/05
i ripped that crappy article to shreds when it came out
Canucks Army hasn't offered anything of value since the Computer Boys left.
With respect to Dickinson, no one who had performed a reasonable evaluation of him should be surprised by this season. He's always been a zero-offence forward. For the majority of last season, he was a winger with better linemates and piggy-backed some points. Other than that, he's a pure shot suppressor. Which is what he's done here.
Completely in line with reasonable expectations. Was it a good addition? Not really. But he's more-or-less done what he should've been expected to do. You'd hope for more scoring, but if anyone was banking on Dickinson to score....uhh that's on them.
Wo Yorfat
dumb person
- Nov 7, 2016
- 2,962
- 3,925
Where do people rank Dickinson among Benning's farewell tour of failure? Or for the Benning faithful, please show me the light and explain how he was another bullseye tainted only by unfair criticism and blind hate.
The funny thing is that Dickinson's offense was actually trending down. He was on pace for more points the previous two seasons than last season.
Hit the post
I have your gold medal Zippy!
I'm impressed we actually gave up a (minor) asset to acquire Dickon. Jim "Don't need draft picks" Benning strikes again.
Nucker101
Foundational Poster
- Apr 2, 2013
- 22,538
- 19,187
He's basically a nice 4th liner. NHL is essentially at a point now where you need three lines that can produce offense at ES and this guy is an offensive black hole
Killer Orcas
Registered User
I wanna who they are so we can get them fired. Guy is a black hole offensively and does not do enough defensively for his salary.
Yeah, yikes. Somehow his profile as an above average fourth liner turns into an elite third line shutdown centre based on results from a noisy stat in a 50 game shortened season.
Hoglander
I'm Höglander. I can do whatever I want.
Dab
Registered User
- Apr 17, 2017
- 3,193
- 3,001
I think the analytics of this trade and signing took a backseat to this thought process:
“we’re receiving a ton of pressure from fans and ownership to ice a winner but our depth is so piss poor let’s just sign nhl players and to get them we’ll not only outbid everyone else we will blow their offers out of the water”.
“we’re receiving a ton of pressure from fans and ownership to ice a winner but our depth is so piss poor let’s just sign nhl players and to get them we’ll not only outbid everyone else we will blow their offers out of the water”.
Breakers
Make Mirrored Visors Legal Again
He was a solid defensive forward in Dallas with one of the worst underlying offensive numbers on their team
his production offensively shouldn’t be shocking
his production offensively shouldn’t be shocking
Last edited:
- Status
