Proposal: Canes and Jets

[McDLT]

Because losing their #1 D PPQB wouldn't hurt right?

Trouba can't hold Faulk's jock, and Aho looks to be at the very least a Brian Little....
Don't sit here and tell me Brian frikken Little makes that big of an impact

Aho is a great young player, but there is a strong chance that he will never be as good as Bryan Little.

Edit: im still not saying that either side should agree to the trade. There is too much uncertainty being traded here (both Comrie and Aho could be elite)

 

[10Ducky10]

Trouba, Lowry and Petan for Staal and Bean...

 

[Evil Little]

Trouba, Lowry and Petan for Staal and Bean...

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Really dumb, should be Trouba for Hanifin straight up. Even then it's not fair value, but far better for both sides.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

Really dumb, should be Trouba for Hanifin straight up. Even then it's not fair value, but far better for both sides.

Not fair value for who?

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Not fair value for who?

Not fair for Jets now, and not fair for Carolina in future. But a lot more fair than other proposals.

 

[Gabe Kupari]

Trouba for Hanifin is fair.

Trouba for Slavin Plus is probably fair also. The plus would have to be pretty decent tho.

 

[SaskCanesFan]

Trouba for Hanifin is fair.

Trouba for Slavin Plus is probably fair also. The plus would have to be pretty decent tho.

Swing and a miss.

 

[zar]

Not fair for Jets now, and not fair for Carolina in future. But a lot more fair than other proposals.

Not fair for the Hurricanes in the future?... you mean as soon as the trade is completed... and I am not even factoring in compensation and Expansion Draft impact.

 

[Carolinas Identity*]

to the op

no

#no

that is ****ing disgusting

not even trying to be rude

but it is ****ing disgusting

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Not fair for the Hurricanes in the future?... you mean as soon as the trade is completed... and I am not even factoring in compensation and Expansion Draft impact.

Um currently Trouba is the better Dman, of course that can change as easily as next year. But when I say now I mean NOW.

 

[thedoughboy]

Swing and a miss.

Agreed.




Also isn't Faulk a RHD? I doubt winny wants another 3 great RD and no LD scenario

 

[Chan790]

Um currently Trouba is the better Dman, of course that can change as easily as next year. But when I say now I mean NOW.

Hanifin is on an ELC and his potential is much higher than becoming Trouba. He's also Exp. Draft exempt, which is huge for the Canes.

Trouba OTOH is unsigned, unhappy and supposedly wants a good deal of money/term.

Winnipeg adds to Trouba to get Hanifin...I'd be wary to do Trouba for Slavin straight across because he's also draft-exempt, but would usually consider it.

 

[GoldiFox]

Hanifin is on an ELC and his potential is much higher than becoming Trouba. He's also Exp. Draft exempt, which is huge for the Canes.

Trouba OTOH is unsigned, unhappy and supposedly wants a good deal of money/term.

Winnipeg adds to Trouba to get Hanifin...I'd be wary to do Trouba for Slavin straight across because he's also draft-exempt, but would usually consider it.

Hanifin being expansion exempt isn't really "huge" for the Canes. It means they can protect someone like Ryan Murphy or Trevor Carrick. Not really that meaningful.

Hanifin for Trouba isn't happening. Slavin for Trouba definitely isn't happening. Canes don't need to move their current 1st pairing LD who is performing extremely well for a 2nd pairing RD.

 

[10Ducky10]

Get
Eric Comrie G
Trouba D
Burmi F
2nd/Little


Faulk D
Aho F

Hurricanes needs Goaltending bad and there no better piece than Comrie for the future to be had at this time. He's now the toop guy on the Moose, Helly was the top guy last year but now he's the Jets starter. Comrie should be ready next year or even a backup this year for the Canes.

Rest of the pieces need no introduction.

Faulk no...

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Get
Eric Comrie G
Trouba D
Burmi F
2nd/Little


Faulk D
Aho F

Hurricanes needs Goaltending bad and there no better piece than Comrie for the future to be had at this time. He's now the toop guy on the Moose, Helly was the top guy last year but now he's the Jets starter. Comrie should be ready next year or even a backup this year for the Canes.

Rest of the pieces need no introduction.

Faulk is a RHD you will have a similar situation as Trouba, Chevy is seeking a LHD not RHD. And Faulk is tons better then Trouba right now.

 

[Chan790]

Hanifin being expansion exempt isn't really "huge" for the Canes. It means they can protect someone like Ryan Murphy or Trevor Carrick. Not really that meaningful.

Hanifin for Trouba isn't happening. Slavin for Trouba definitely isn't happening. Canes don't need to move their current 1st pairing LD who is performing extremely well for a 2nd pairing RD.

I did not think of it in that way...I just think Trouba is a better Dman than I think Slavin will be.