Confirmed with Link: Canadiens Will Pick 5th (Hughes Presser in OP) NO POLITICS

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
That’s my point, though.

Smith is a top 5 talent, probably every team think he is why would the habs skip him lol.

If they prefer someone else...they should skip him.

One should not predict who they really like based on comments designed to put them all on the same level so that opponents can't read into our playbook. This is the only way to maximize the trade value of each pick and create options where there are none.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Estimated_Prophet
A Josh Anderson mixed with Kotkaniemi would be an elite player. Anderson's strengths are Kotkaniemi's weaknesses, and Kotkaniemi's strengths are Anderson's weaknesses.

Anderson's strengths are skating and shot, and his weaknesses are vision, playmaking, and IQ.
Kotkaniemi's strength are his vision, playmaking, and IQ, and his weaknesses are his skating and his shot.
They both handle the puck like a grenade in tight.
 
The Dach opportunity was so unique that it makes you wonder how in the world it could be replicated. Essentially, you had a complicit GM giving up on a recent top 3 pick with size and skill, aged 21 and playing a premium position for an 11th OA and spare parts in a weak draft. Where will we find another crazy man like that this summer?

At least, Hughes was first to the wire in securing Dach. A lot of teams were caught with their pants down.
Van will be interesting to watch, don’t see them rebuilding, but to push forward they need takers for some of their albatross multi year contracts Benning acquired / doled out last summer.

Would HuGo take on one of those multi-year contracts of Van were to provide their 11OA pick? Would Van even be open to doing so?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Runner77
I hope I'm wrong, but given Bedard and Fantilli are gone for sure, we might see:

Smith/Michkov go in some order 3/4 >> take Carlsson no question
Carlsson/Michkov go 3/4 >> take Smith no question
Carlsson/Smith go 3/4 >> maybe pass on Michkov and that brings Reinbacher, Benson, etc. into play

Hopefully HuGo don't outsmart themselves, take whichever of LC/WS/MM is sitting there at 5 and be done with it.
That’s how I feel. We’re in a great spot. Draft whoever is left. Very good chance it’ll be Mitch anyway.
 
That’s how I feel. We’re in a great spot. Draft whoever is left. Very good chance it’ll be Mitch anyway.
They better draft Michkov if he is available.

The team is loaded with D, next draft is loaded with D, a potential superstar drops to #5… and they pick a D.

Even if they trade down to get Reinbacher, that would be a boneheaded move. Michkov did say his dream is in the NHL… so dreams shouldn’t go away. He is an arena junkie: he lives and breaths for hockey. You just can’t pass that kinda of pick at #5.
 
They better draft Michkov if he is available.
Agreed.
The team is loaded with D, next draft is loaded with D, a potential superstar drops to #5… and they pick a D.
I have faith they won’t pick a D. If we do, I’ll scream at the team along with you.
Even if they trade down to get Reinbacher, that would be a boneheaded move. Michkov did say his dream is in the NHL… so dreams shouldn’t go away. He is an arena junkie: he lives and breaths for hockey. You just can’t pass that kinda of pick at #5.
Mitch or Smith… whoever is left. It’s win/win for us.
 
From the standpoint of the player’s upside, perhaps. However, who knows if Drury would be amenable and how flexible he might be.
Laf has gotten little opportunity and hasn’t produced. At a minimum his trade value is diminished.

I certainly can’t say they’d want to move him, but there may be an opportunity there. He’s definitely a talent that would be worth looking at.
 
Van will be interesting to watch, don’t see them rebuilding, but to push forward they need takers for some of their albatross multi year contracts Benning acquired / doled out last summer.

Would HuGo take on one of those multi-year contracts of Van were to provide their 11OA pick? Would Van even be open to doing so?

van is rebuilding, our company has season tickets, they have begged for renewals during this 'rebuilding phase' is what numbnuts Aquilini has stated several times to the ticket holders. I mean, when he isn't busy making shitty wine he makes time to treat the fans like total eltardos
 
Posted this elsewhere but should have been here, instead:

Scott Wheeler conducted a simple shits and giggles exercise based on which teams who are selecting in the top 10 this year, drafted and which teams completely avoided/ failed to draft Russians in last year’s draft.

There were 4 teams holding top 10 picks this year that did not draft Russians last year: Hawks, Habs, Sharks and Flyers.

That leaves 6 teams who have shown a willingness to draft Russians last year. The list includes the Ducks (who will in all likelihood draft Fantilli) and Columbus who have committed to drafting a center. If we remove the Ducks and Columbus, that would leave the following 4 teams as candidates open to drafting a Russian, who hold top 10 picks this year:

1. Chicago
2. Anaheim
3. Columbus
4. Sharks
5. Canadiens
6. Coyotes
7. Flyers
8. Capitals
9. Red Wings
10. Blues

Adding fuel to the equation would be the number of Russians in each of those 4 organizations. A potential suitor could certainly come from this lot, should Michkov fall to the Habs and should they consider moving the pick.


Why is there only a half strike mark on the Sharks? @WeThreeKings will explain. :sarcasm:
To be fair this looks more like Wheeler making something out of nothing as using a miniscule sample of 1 draft reeks of a bias confirmation exercise. Columbus has taken a Russian in 5 consecutive drafts prior to last season. Chicago with 3 in the last 5, Montreal with 4 consecutive and with Philadelphia and San Jose seemingly avoiding Russians but it is still too small of a sample to reach a definitive conclusion.

I am sure that some teams may have a serious aversion towards drafting Russians and Philadelphia is a team that has always had a questionable culture among management to say the least.

Last season was the first HuGo draft so that does render the four previous seasons picks as less indicative of current philosophy but almost the entire scouting staff remains intact as well as the fact that Martin Lapointe is the head scout. This was a silly attempt by Wheeler imo but we are all starved for new information that is pertinent to the Habs so I understand why we are entertaining this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabbyGuy and jrom
To be fair this looks more like Wheeler making something out of nothing as using a miniscule sample of 1 draft reeks of a bias confirmation exercise. Columbus has taken a Russian in 5 consecutive drafts prior to last season. Chicago with 3 in the last 5, Montreal with 4 consecutive and with Philadelphia and San Jose seemingly avoiding Russians but it is still too small of a sample to reach a definitive conclusion.

I am sure that some teams may have a serious aversion towards drafting Russians and Philadelphia is a team that has always had a questionable culture among management to say the least.

Last season was the first HuGo draft so that does render the four previous seasons picks as less indicative of current philosophy but almost the entire scouting staff remains intact as well as the fact that Martin Lapointe is the head scout. This was a silly attempt by Wheeler imo but we are all starved for new information that is pertinent to the Habs so I understand why we are entertaining this.
It’s just a subjective lay of the land pitch, which is why I presented it with a caveat.

I would not put too much emphasis on past drafts from several years ago as it appears to me that the point of the exercise was premised on the response to the Russian geopolitical situation by some teams even though several may have had a record of selecting Russians prior to the war.

Quite possibly some teams are observing a hiatus until the war resolves itself while some others are clearly not concerned with it. Nothing more beyond that IMHO.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Estimated_Prophet
I'm cooling down on Smith. I think we have a clear and sexy Top4 and then... not so much. Smith, Benson, et al. are certainly good prospects and have really beautiful aspects to their game but they're not Bedard, Fantilli, Carlsson, and Michkov.

It's a shame about Michkov, he will be tantalizingly out of reach for us.
Yeah I was stoked on Smith at first but nah.
Reinbacher 100%
 
Don’t know if this was posted already but FWIW, if reliable, we won’t need to be too concerned about Michkov falling to us:



Again, pre-draft comments always to be consumed responsibly.


Unbelievable, missing out on a prospect of this caliber by 1 spot just to win a few extra meaningless games.

What a f***ing joke of an organization.

"You can't lose in Montreal"

"gotta protect the winning culture"

Yeah, right.
 
That’s how I feel. We’re in a great spot. Draft whoever is left. Very good chance it’ll be Mitch anyway.
The decision making process of current ownership has been so dysfunctional sometimes that I believe that they’ll either blow it by not drafting Michkov if still available. And if by a miracle, they put their thinking cap for a whole second and draft Michkov, they’ll blow it too. For example, not giving him pointers to deal with Montreal media who’ll try to get quotes from him in Russia. Or some other f*** up. I just have a feeling of imminent doom about the whole thing. Lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: ReHabs
That’s how I feel. We’re in a great spot. Draft whoever is left. Very good chance it’ll be Mitch anyway.

Great spot? We're in the worst spot. Coming exactly 1 spot short of drafting a franchise player in Michkov, and instead getting a complete gamble of an enigma in Smith.
 
Unbelievable, missing out on a prospect of this caliber by 1 spot just to win a few extra meaningless games.

What a f***ing joke of an organization.

"You can't lose in Montreal"

"gotta protect the winning culture"

Yeah, right.
Last year we had 55 points, Chicago 68

This year we had 68 points, Chicago 59

Talk about bad timing

Great spot? We're in the worst spot. Coming exactly 1 spot short of drafting a franchise player in Michkov, and instead getting a complete gamble of an enigma in Smith.
When have the first 4 players drafted ever gone on to be the best 4 players in the draft? Its very likely someone drafting 2-4 is going to be disappointed 5-10 years down the line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Runner77
No way.

There’s no way we should give up a guy who’s been pacing at a top ten (close to 50 goal pace) already. Zero way I’d trade him for that.

Moving up? Sure. Want to trade some prospects to do it? Okay. But Caufield? No f***ing way. Esp since we’ll probably wind up with Mitch at 5th anyway.

Bud, I like him just as much as you, but Fantilli imo will be better and seriously the whole contract situation kinda soured me a bit. What if there's a standoff relating to the number of years. It doesn't bode well for the long term outlook.
 
Last year we had 55 points, Chicago 68

This year we had 68 points, Chicago 59

Talk about bad timing


When have the first 4 players drafted ever gone on to be the best 4 players in the draft? Its very likely someone drafting 2-4 is going to be disappointed 5-10 years down the line.
I don't care about Fantilli and Carlsson. I do, however, care a great deal about Michkov, which we would get the opportunity to STEAL if we had the 4th overall.

Complete disaster of a season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NORiculous
I don't care about Fantilli and Carlsson. I do, however, care a great deal about Michkov, which we would get the opportunity to STEAL if we had the 4th overall.

Complete disaster of a season.
It is what it is. We could have finished with 59 points like Chicago and had 2 lottery wins bump us to 5th place again. But by all means vent away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabbyGuy
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad