The cream always rises to the top, but that takes time and a shortened season (smaller sample size) allows more teams to remain with the cream before settling at the bottom.
If you asked a professional athlete to run a 1/2 marathon verses a full marathon their odds of performing better in a shorter race would be increased, despite all the other factors being the same for all runners. The eventual winner of the race is not the one necessarily leading at the mid point of the race, but the one crossing the finish line at the end.
One is a sprint and the other a marathon race as they say hockey season often is, and when watching these types of races its not the marathon runners competing against Usain Bolt for the 100m dashes, because much like good hockey teams their results are based on being good/successful over a longer period of time and not all smaller segments.
With all due respect to fellow Leaf fans, I think the logic is failed.....Your analogy is horrible Mess..as they are clearly two different animals....sprinters and marathon runners...you might as well be comparing rugby to NFL football. Nothing alike. Usain Bolt is no threat to win a marathon race but clearly the fastest man in the world. Every team starts in the same place with the same number of games being played. Teams, players, coaches all perform differently in different situations. Anybody here ever consider the Leafs fell apart when the games became more meaningful as the season carried on? Injuries to key players could have a huge impact on a bubble team's fate. I don't even consider the Leafs a bubble team but the don't have the depth to win without Kessel or even Phaneuf in the lineup. Factors that really are not impacted by a shortened season. Everything is equal...the games all mean a bit more coming out of the gate.
Last shortened NHL season was 48 games in 1994-1995....Here is a summary of that season..
1995 NHL season
Duration January 20 – June 24, 1995
Number of games 48
Number of teams 26
Regular season
Presidents' Trophy Detroit Red Wings
Season MVP Eric Lindros (Philadelphia)
Top scorer Jaromir Jagr (Pittsburgh)
Playoffs
Eastern champions New Jersey Devils
Eastern runners-up Philadelphia Flyers
Western champions Detroit Red Wings
Western runners-up Chicago Blackhawks
Playoffs MVP Claude Lemieux (New Jersey)
Stanley Cup
Stanley Cup champions New Jersey Devils
Runners-up Detroit Red Wings
Please tell me ..other than Claude Lemieux winning the Conn Smythe trophy..what was different here...what was the anomaly that was created by a shortened season? Nothing.