Toggle sidebar

C/W Gabe Perreault - Boston College, NCAA (2023, 23rd, NYR)

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
Sendhelplease said:
GP is a great prospect and I would be ecstatic to have him in my team's minor league system, that being said if Mike Grier called Chris Drury and offered him Will Smith for Gabe Perreault Drury would quickly accept the offer. If you polled the 32 GMs of the NHL on who they would rather have in their system all 32 would take Will Smith.
Click to expand...

First of all we'll see. Second of all I didn't say he wasn't. He's not 10+ draft spots better. Gabe has now outscored him two seasons in a row albeit not by much.
 
SnowblindNYR said:
First of all we'll see. Second of all I didn't say he wasn't. He's not 10+ draft spots better. Gabe has now outscored him two seasons in a row albeit not by much.
Click to expand...
Perreault had more points last year but a lower PPG due to doing it in more games. If you consider that outscoring then isn't Will Smith outscoring Perreault this season?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Patty Ice and Sendhelplease
LilLeeroy said:
Perreault had more points last year but a lower PPG due to doing it in more games. If you consider that outscoring then isn't Will Smith outscoring Perreault this season?
Click to expand...

I actually didn't realize he played more games. They have very similar production. They're not 10+ spots apart. It's ridiculous.
 
SnowblindNYR said:
Gabe has now outscored him two seasons in a row albeit not by much.
Click to expand...

With the margins as slim as they are between those two, scoring isn’t a real factor when determining who is more valuable.

Having said that, this thread and the blind/religious love for GP by some of you has to stop.

Get your facts straight: last season, GP had more Points than WS, but WS had the better PPG. This season, it’s the other way around.

Yet you claim GP outscored WS in Both season‘s. WTF

Stop overcompensating and be happy that you got a damn fine prospect at 23 (had him ranked 10th).

Edit: late to the party
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rangersfansince08
CaptainShark said:
With the margins as slim as they are between those two, scoring isn’t a real factor when determining who is more valuable.

Having said that, this thread and the blind/religious love for GP by some of you has to stop.

Get your facts straight: last season, GP had more Points than WS, but WS had the better PPG. This season, it’s the other way around.

Yet you claim GP outscored WS in Both season‘s. WTF

Stop overcompensating and be happy that you got a damn fine prospect at 23 (had him ranked 10th).

Edit: late to the party
Click to expand...

I didn't realize that WS played fewer games, relax. Are Sharks fans super insecure that a prospect that was drafted at 23 might be better than their #4 overall when all is said and done? My only gripe is not that Will Smith is seen as a better prospect. My gripe is that Perrault is somehow not seen as top 13 whereas Will Smith is listed is at #4 for many. Similar production both years in the last two years. It's absurd. They're not 10 spots in the same draft apart.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Grinner and Patty Ice
Sendhelplease said:
GP is a great prospect and I would be ecstatic to have him in my team's minor league system, that being said if Mike Grier called Chris Drury and offered him Will Smith for Gabe Perreault Drury would quickly accept the offer. If you polled the 32 GMs of the NHL on who they would rather have in their system all 32 would take Will Smith.
Click to expand...
Highly doubtful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Crypto Guy and SnowblindNYR
person5000 said:
Clearly still skates with concrete feet tho. Great scorer but he needs to change something with his skating. Some fourth liners on these college teams that skate way better than him.
Click to expand...
Lmao just admit you dont watch him at all. His skating is completey fine. Maybe watch a few of his breakaway goals recently when he pulls away from defenders.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: WhiskeyYerTheDevils
SnowblindNYR said:
I didn't realize that WS played fewer games, relax. Are Sharks fans super insecure that a prospect that was drafted at 23 might be better than their #4 overall when all is said and done? My only gripe is not that Will Smith is seen as a better prospect. My gripe is that Perrault is somehow not seen as top 13 whereas Will Smith is listed is at #4 for many. Similar production both years in the last two years. It's absurd. They're not 10 spots in the same draft apart.
Click to expand...

Sharks fans are the ones „insecure“? I don’t see them post in the Will Smith every time he hits the urinal while peeing and calling him the greatest thing since bread came sliced. It’s been really quite in there and that’s ok, cause he won’t be one iota better because of that.

But if you feel the need to praise GB every turn and compare him to WS (as if that matters), at least get your facts right. That’s where I came from.

Most of you sound like you are personally offended that GP dropped to 23. But why? Be happy about it and enjoy the ride.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoeGarelli and Patty Ice
CaptainShark said:
Sharks fans are the ones „insecure“? I don’t see them post in the Will Smith every time he hits the urinal while peeing and calling him the greatest thing since bread came sliced. It’s been really quite in there and that’s ok, cause he won’t be one iota better because of that.

But if you feel the need to praise GB every turn and compare him to WS (as if that matters), at least get your facts right. That’s where I came from.

Most of you sound like you are personally offended that GP dropped to 23. But why? Be happy about it and enjoy the ride.
Click to expand...

To be fair, the same could be said of Sharks fans constantly posting in this thread about Smith. They are both very good players.

@SnowblindNYR has made a good point: Anyone thinking Gabe is still a product of his linemates and/or 10+ draft selections worse than Smith is probably not being serious. But it's fine to say Smith and Gabe are very good prospects, and appear to be very close in skill at this stage. Which is not an indictment on Smith, but should be viewed as a huge plus for Gabe given their draft positions a year ago.


Edit: Thank you, moderator, for the clarification, and apologies for the error.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SnowblindNYR and The Crypto Guy
CaptainShark said:
Sharks fans are the ones „insecure“? I don’t see them post in the Will Smith every time he hits the urinal while peeing and calling him the greatest thing since bread came sliced. It’s been really quite in there and that’s ok, cause he won’t be one iota better because of that.

But if you feel the need to praise GB every turn and compare him to WS (as if that matters), at least get your facts right. That’s where I came from.

Most of you sound like you are personally offended that GP dropped to 23. But why? Be happy about it and enjoy the ride.
Click to expand...
Don’t you know getting the most hype is as important as being a good player?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: thefutures and CaptainShark
UnSandvich said:
gotta say i feel bad for Smith. if the rumors of him going pro after this season are true, he's gonna be stuck with David Quinn's coaching.

Thank god we don't have to worry about Quinn ruining Perreault anymore.
Click to expand...
Knowing Quinn, Smith will make a nice move to set up a scoring chance and get benched for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UnSandvich
WhiskeyYerTheDevils said:
But that's not true.

Last year, he had more points that Smith yet a slightly worse PPG

This year, he has less points and a lower PPG.
Click to expand...
Think this has been covered a couple times now but small correction. This year he has a slightly higher PPG 1.74 to 1.72. Basically the seasons mirror each other.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom