
Obviously they are good players, the argument is comparing the #1 pick with the rest of the draft, and the fact is that most of the time the #1 pick is the best player in the draft.
Sadly you're wrong. Which is why I listed Giroux (#22) vs Erik Johnson (#1).
Since 1990:
Owen Nolan vs Jaromir Jagr/Martin Brodeur (wrong)
Eric Lindros vs Scott Niedermayer/Peter Forsberg (wrong)
Roman Hamrlik vs Alexei Yashin/Sergei Gonachar (wrong)
Alexandre Daigle vs Chris Pronger/Paul Kariya/Sauku Koivu (wrong)
Ed Jovanovski vs Mattias Ohlund/Daniel Alfredsson (wrong)
Bryan Berard vs Shane Doan/Jarome Iginla (wrong)
Chris Phillips vs Danny Briere (wrong)
Joe Thornton vs Roberto Luongo/Marian Hossa (right)
Vincent Lecavalier vs Brad Richards (wrong)
Patrik Stefan vs Sedins/Havlat (wrong)
DiPietro vs Heatley/Gaborik/Hartnell (wrong)
Kovalchuk vs Spezza/Hemsky (right)
Nash vs Semin/Ward/Keith (wrong)
Fleury vs Staal/Parise/Perry/Weber (wrong)
Ovechkin vs Malkin (wrong)
Crosby vs Kopitar (right)
Johnson vs Giroux (wrong)
Kane vs Couture (right)
Stamkos vs Karlsson/Eberle (right)
Tavares vs Duchene (right)
Hall vs Seguin/Skinner (wrong)
Too early to tell for 2011 or 2012. So we're looking at 6 cases where #1 was better vs 15 where he wasn't.