Anthony Mauro
DraftBuzz Hockey
- Oct 3, 2004
- 6,859
- 5
This is where I, and probably Zenon, will disagree with you and thats fine. Size does matter to us. It isn't the only factor but it is a factor. The reason I bolded the above is because size is a factor with these players. It can't be used to call immediate busts but also cannot be ignored. I haven't seen Bjorkstrand or Baillie play this season but last season, Bjorkstrand was push off the puck too often for my liking.
But like I said, while size matters, it isn't the only thing. There is a reason why I loved Petan but not so much Bjorkstrand. In fact, Petan was smaller. I just found that he compensated his lack of size with other skills to balance out his game.
Conclude: agreed that lack of size does not mean automatic bust. But it is an obstacle that needs to be overcome nonetheless.
Is Point comparable to Petan?
This is contradictory. Does it matter or not? If you really are attending to the 'other skills' in a player's game, you will not be able to discern the difference in a few inches in physical stature.
Put a guy like Tkachev in play and he has to be the exception to the rule. There are only a few players who make it under 5'9'' so there is an art to figuring out who that will be. But discussing height on a guy that is 5'9 and up will lead to teams losing out on good pro players.