I get the feeling that Butch wasn`t despised or hated but rather he was viewed as a coach who wasn`t a terrific communicator. If he didn`t like a players game it feels like no conversations would occur and he`d simply plant that players ass to the bench or push him upstairs without a ton of communication
I don`t mind a hard ass coach, problem is the game is different now, that old school approach doesn`t work a great deal of times. I get the sense based on what we hear about the Bolts that Cooper is a very strong communicator and he`s also a coach who will allow his younger players to learn from mistakes whereas I always got the sense that Butch`s way of "teaching" is to not play someone. If Butch was a player favorite, do we see him behind the bench of another team right now? Not so sure we do, in this day and age, few secrets are safe, if he were as beloved by his players as he is by the many of the fans and media, we`d be hearing about it
I felt when he first took over for CJ it was like the room exhaled, he allowed the boys to play more free, allow their skill to take over with less rigid commitment to systems hockey. Over time, that changed, some of it isn`t on Butch as you can only play the style your troops are able to play but I have never really liked Butch`s in game ability to make on the fly adjustments, his adjustments were more often than not simply shifting personnel up and down the lineup but not changing to the flow or style of a game going on