Value of: Brodin+Coyle to your team
- Thread starter Digitalbooya
- Start date
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
At this point, we don't really need Klefboms offense, and would prefer Brodin's defense, pending any kind of deals this summer that may shake up our defense.
Basically, Brodin for Klefbom doesn't really do anything for us at this point. It doesn't give us the forward we need, and it weakens our team defense.
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
Yeah for a serviceable third line C you can have a third round pick. Not a 40-50 point (potentially higher) winger.
Coyle is better than Strome. No question about it. I don't see the need for Strome as we want to develop one of Eriksson Ek/Kunin into a center role.
Makes sense. Just wanted to see if there was a deal to be made and there isnt.
DudeWhereIsMakar
Bergevin sent me an offer sheet
BigHabs
#11
- Aug 3, 2009
- 6,801
- 744
What is the asking price for them? The Habs could use a shakeup and add some talent.
I seen a blowup Minnesota roster thread already.
Looking to go younger? Or just re-tool?
I think if Montreal got a Brodin from Minnesota they could send back Mete in the deal whatever that may be.
Just Brodin would play top pair with Weber and well Reilly since being picked up from Minnesota was solid for the Habs down the stretch and had good chemistry with Petry. Alzner is here for awhile so the left side would be clogged with extras Benn and Schlemko.
So Mete + for Brodin. Don’t know about Coyle.
Brodin Weber
Reilly Petry
Alzner Juulsen
Schlemko Benn
I seen a blowup Minnesota roster thread already.
Looking to go younger? Or just re-tool?
I think if Montreal got a Brodin from Minnesota they could send back Mete in the deal whatever that may be.
Just Brodin would play top pair with Weber and well Reilly since being picked up from Minnesota was solid for the Habs down the stretch and had good chemistry with Petry. Alzner is here for awhile so the left side would be clogged with extras Benn and Schlemko.
So Mete + for Brodin. Don’t know about Coyle.
Brodin Weber
Reilly Petry
Alzner Juulsen
Schlemko Benn
La Cosa Nostra
Caporegime
- Jun 25, 2009
- 14,111
- 2,379
Nope doesnt work like that. Its why the Sabres could only sign ror to a 7 year deal after trading for him.
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
2Pair
Registered User
- Oct 8, 2017
- 12,633
- 5,103
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
Yeah, if you'd be okay with him coming back as a 0 value piece. Wild aren't interested in receiving a less valuable main piece due to Mete being included. We're not looking for multiple parts that have a value equal to Brodin combined.
Quite frankly I'm not even sure I'd want anyone from Montreal enough to trade one of our main trade chips. Scherbak and Lehkonen don't do anything for me. My interest in Galchenyuk is waning fast. Pacioretty is too old for what we're looking for. I don't even know who else you have.
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
Both vastly overrated players at this point. No better than Coyle, Nino, or Zucker. Worse, in fact, in some cases.
I'm not necessarily gung-ho about him, but I have a hard time believing Galchenyuk wouldn't do better with a change of scenery. I'd consider trading Coyle for him.
The same probably goes for Drouin, but the optics of trading him would be so bad that Bergevin would have to be let go first.
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
Coyle would really be the only one of the main pieces I'd consider trading for Galchenyuk. I don't think Galchenyuk would have a career renaissance with us or any other team, but he is a more "skilled" player in the way he plays, which could spark something. And that would be assuming we can't get a better deal involving Coyle.
I'd much prefer to make a move packaging players for an upgrade, or taking a risk on a high potential prospect (Fiala), but if all else fails, Coyle for Galchenyuk straight up wouldn't be terrible. I certainly wouldn't add to Coyle though.
- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,549
- 18,895
If we're packaging Brodin and Coyle, it's because we're aiming for a much better piece than Galchenyuk. There is nothing you could offer or add for Brodin AND Coyle that would entice me to move them both to Montreal.
