Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Brock Boeser for Dobson

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/

M2Beezy

Love ya Grubster
Sponsor
May 25, 2014
46,198
31,823
Brock Boesers days in Vancouver APPEAR to be coming to an end as his game is unforutnately really starting to round out. Skating has improved, defensive game is complete, great passer and legendary shot. Hes a former allstar who struggled after a cheapshot from Clutterbuck a few years ago but is back to speed. Many Canuck fans will NOT be happy to trade Brock Boeser but i feel it should happen and this deal works out for them despite losing him. The Canucks they are too thin on defense and have many top line forwards but this just does NOT work out

Dobson in New York hasnt lived up to the pre draft hype and will be a RFA at the end of season just like Brock Boeser. Seems like a natural trade off here and could be one of those win win trades. If the Canucks retain on the deal then NY is not over cap as well. Brock Boeser on Barzals wing for a decade could be one of the best duos in the league. Dobson paired with Hughes would be solid too

Because dmen are worth more than wingers Canucks would need to add former 2nd rounder Jet Woo is a bulldog and could anchor down a spot on the NY blueline for YEARS

To Vancity: Dobson, 2022 3rd round pick

To NYI: Brock Boeser (50% retain), Woo, Bailey, 2023 4th round pick
Click to read more...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nucks2477

Paddys Pub

Registered User
Jul 18, 2016
437
547
Port Coquitlam
Erub ot Ynligom said:
Brock Boesers days in Vancouver APPEAR to be coming to an end as his game is unforutnately really starting to round out. Skating has improved, defensive game is complete, great passer and legendary shot. Hes a former allstar who struggled after a cheapshot from Clutterbuck a few years ago but is back to speed. Many Canuck fans will NOT be happy to trade Brock Boeser but i feel it should happen and this deal works out for them despite losing him. The Canucks they are too thin on defense and have many top line forwards but this just does NOT work out

Dobson in New York hasnt lived up to the pre draft hype and will be a RFA at the end of season just like Brock Boeser. Seems like a natural trade off here and could be one of those win win trades. If the Canucks retain on the deal then NY is not over cap as well. Brock Boeser on Barzals wing for a decade could be one of the best duos in the league. Dobson paired with Hughes would be solid too

Because dmen are worth more than wingers Canucks would need to add former 2nd rounder Jet Woo is a bulldog and could anchor down a spot on the NY blueline for YEARS

To Vancity: Dobson, 2022 3rd round pick

To NYI: Brock Boeser (50% retain), Woo, Bailey, 2023 4th round pick
Click to expand...

Why does it appear his time is coming to an end? Also, where do you get all this 2023 4th round nonsense?
Dobson is more valuable. Why are they adding the higher pick?
what wait for next years draft for the 4th?

From a canucks fan, NYI decline
 
  • Like
Reactions: DingDongCharlie
Nucker101

Nucker101

Foundational Poster
Apr 2, 2013
21,772
17,726
Don’t do this to yourself m2b, I don’t wanna see you getting slandered
 

Canuck Luck

Registered User
Jun 15, 2008
5,594
1,995
Vancouver
idk why people think Boeser is going to end up with a 7.5M + cap hit. Yes his QO is 7.5M, doesn't mean he signs for that. Boeser is not a 7.5M player. If he and his agent want a long term deal, he's looking closer to 6-6.75M max. If he refuses, the Canucks would take him to arbitration. He likely is to get the minimum possible at that point which is 6.375M. So does he want a 1 yr 6.375M deal and bet he can go back to being a 60+ point pace player so he can make around 7.5M long term or avoid the risk he repeats his current season and drops his value below the 6.5M long term he prob gets offered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mratch19, Grumpy1 and lawrence
Osakahaus

Osakahaus

Chillin' on Fuji
May 28, 2021
8,340
4,064
Okay this is a hard no. Dobson isn't gonna get traded for Boeser, especially considering that Dobson is seen as one of their younger players and relatively is a defenseman they need for the future. You do have a case for Boeser but it just won't happen. Also Jett Woo is not the same as Dobson in terms of production and play
 
McJedi

McJedi

Registered User
Apr 21, 2020
10,651
7,575
Florida
Erub ot Ynligom said:
Brock Boesers days in Vancouver APPEAR to be coming to an end as his game is unforutnately really starting to round out. Skating has improved, defensive game is complete, great passer and legendary shot. Hes a former allstar who struggled after a cheapshot from Clutterbuck a few years ago but is back to speed. Many Canuck fans will NOT be happy to trade Brock Boeser but i feel it should happen and this deal works out for them despite losing him. The Canucks they are too thin on defense and have many top line forwards but this just does NOT work out

Dobson in New York hasnt lived up to the pre draft hype and will be a RFA at the end of season just like Brock Boeser. Seems like a natural trade off here and could be one of those win win trades. If the Canucks retain on the deal then NY is not over cap as well. Brock Boeser on Barzals wing for a decade could be one of the best duos in the league. Dobson paired with Hughes would be solid too

Because dmen are worth more than wingers Canucks would need to add former 2nd rounder Jet Woo is a bulldog and could anchor down a spot on the NY blueline for YEARS

To Vancity: Dobson, 2022 3rd round pick

To NYI: Brock Boeser (50% retain), Woo, Bailey, 2023 4th round pick
Click to expand...
You’re pretty over the top with your praise of Boeser. I don’t see it. Boeser was a more impressive player earlier in his career than he is now. His qualifying offer is also way too high.

Bad proposal. Weak attempt to justify why NYI do this. Boo this man!!!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DingDongCharlie

Mersss

Registered User
Jul 12, 2014
4,996
2,188
Ched Brosky said:
idk why people think Boeser is going to end up with a 7.5M + cap hit. Yes his QO is 7.5M, doesn't mean he signs for that. Boeser is not a 7.5M player. If he and his agent want a long term deal, he's looking closer to 6-6.75M max. If he refuses, the Canucks would take him to arbitration. He likely is to get the minimum possible at that point which is 6.375M. So does he want a 1 yr 6.375M deal and bet he can go back to being a 60+ point pace player so he can make around 7.5M long term or avoid the risk he repeats his current season and drops his value below the 6.5M long term he prob gets offered.
Click to expand...
Except in order to bring a guy to arbitration you need to qualify him 1st.

Ans Boeser would just sign his QO
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tmart335, DingDongCharlie, Smartguy and 1 other person

common12

Registered User
Sep 10, 2011
162
162
I dont get it.

Boeser by your praise has been awesome and Dobson hasn't lived up to his hype as per your words but you want him on your 1st pair? Having friends who are isles fans thats just not true.

The proposal also:
1. Doesn't think about the salary cap at all for the isles.
2. Doesn't consider the isles needs as they need defense way more than RW.
3. Is off pretty bad on value.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DingDongCharlie and Osakahaus
SI

SI

Registered User
Feb 16, 2013
7,869
4,078
Erub ot Ynligom said:
Brock Boesers days in Vancouver APPEAR to be coming to an end as his game is unforutnately really starting to round out. Skating has improved, defensive game is complete, great passer and legendary shot. Hes a former allstar who struggled after a cheapshot from Clutterbuck a few years ago but is back to speed. Many Canuck fans will NOT be happy to trade Brock Boeser but i feel it should happen and this deal works out for them despite losing him. The Canucks they are too thin on defense and have many top line forwards but this just does NOT work out

Dobson in New York hasnt lived up to the pre draft hype and will be a RFA at the end of season just like Brock Boeser. Seems like a natural trade off here and could be one of those win win trades. If the Canucks retain on the deal then NY is not over cap as well. Brock Boeser on Barzals wing for a decade could be one of the best duos in the league. Dobson paired with Hughes would be solid too

Because dmen are worth more than wingers Canucks would need to add former 2nd rounder Jet Woo is a bulldog and could anchor down a spot on the NY blueline for YEARS

To Vancity: Dobson, 2022 3rd round pick

To NYI: Brock Boeser (50% retain), Woo, Bailey, 2023 4th round pick
Click to expand...

Hell NO to this proposal.

And the bolded is way off. You need to do your homework.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThreeLeftSkates and DingDongCharlie
miscs75

miscs75

Registered User
Jul 2, 2014
6,205
5,854
Erub ot Ynligom said:
So if both fanbases dont like it, probably means its close to value
Click to expand...
So the Islanders are getting a top 6 winger (with retention), a B prospect and AHL player plus a pick for a defenseman who’s still under RFA status and has been playing like a top pairing guy since coming back from his Covid hiatus? Yeah, not even close to a fair deal for the Islanders.
 

BCNate

Registered User
Apr 3, 2016
3,346
3,347
Ched Brosky said:
idk why people think Boeser is going to end up with a 7.5M + cap hit. Yes his QO is 7.5M, doesn't mean he signs for that. Boeser is not a 7.5M player. If he and his agent want a long term deal, he's looking closer to 6-6.75M max. If he refuses, the Canucks would take him to arbitration. He likely is to get the minimum possible at that point which is 6.375M. So does he want a 1 yr 6.375M deal and bet he can go back to being a 60+ point pace player so he can make around 7.5M long term or avoid the risk he repeats his current season and drops his value below the 6.5M long term he prob gets offered.
Click to expand...

Thank you for this post. I hope everyone who refers to BB's QO read and understand this. He gets 7.5 for 1 season, then he gets what he gets long term. Nobody in their right mind is paying him 7.5+ long term. Do people also think Timo Meier is getting 10+ long term due to his QO?

But, No chance the Isles move Dobson for Boeser. Canucks would have to add for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DingDongCharlie
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom
X