Babe Ruth
Looks wise.. I'm a solid 8.5
- Feb 2, 2016
- 1,591
- 697
Absolutely no.
(Mahomes)has 1 MVP, 1 SB, 1 SB MVP. Plenty of QBs have more.
Are you saying Kurt Warner is a Top 5 all time QB?
Agreed.. Mahomes is already an accomplished QB, but not uniquely accomplished (as u show with a Warner comparison).
Even Mahomes' individual stats aren't in the category of unique greatness yet. Passers like Carson Palmer & Testaverde both threw for basically 30,000 more yards than Mahomes (so far). And I wouldn't even say that Palmer & Testaverde were all-time great QBs.
And by another common metric, compared to one's peers.. I'd actually say Brady, past his prime, has been better than Mahomes over the last few seasons. And I think in the next few years, both Josh Allen and Herbert will put up better stats than Mahomes, but I concede that's speculative..
Mahomes is one of the best of his generation.. but he hasn't (all-time Top 5) dominated his peers, or the record books yet.. He has a long way until he has the rings like Brady & Montana.. or league passing records that Tarkenton retired with.