Player Discussion Brandon Carlo III

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
I don't know what the end game is keep him around for 20 years at a sizeable cap hit and rotate the blue line around to make up for his lack of offense or toughness?

We got good mileage from him it's time to get a forward in a trade middle roster guys like this aren't supposed to stay on one team for 10+ years.

You need a PP capable RD it might spur McAvoy to improve on the man up and you can flip them between units. Peeke skates well and has size and is fine as defense first 2D. Even good Carlo isn't a great fit. Zadarov add gives us the big guy with reach wed lose.

Sweeney sucks for letting things get to this point.
Peeke is terrible and Carlo is absolutely worth the AAV differential and I wanted Carlo gone for Kesselring earlier in the season.
 
Peeke is terrible and Carlo is absolutely worth the AAV differential and I wanted Carlo gone for Kesselring earlier in the season.
it's a toss up which one is worse. You've never liked Peeke. I've been down on Carlo except for last year, where he appeared to have his head removed from his butt. It's back in.

Still B's D should be better than it's showed, all year.

Any team that acquires Carlo will eventually be disappointed with how soft he is.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Colt.45Orr
Coyle and Carlo for him and Vatrano. Throw in something else.

Perfect deal for us.
Big goal asks you nicely stay away from those Cannabis shops.:DD

I said this in another thread I think Carlo is dealing with post concussion issues again. IMO it is the best explanation for his play falling off a cliff like this after a fairly good season last year.
I hope you are wrong but would not be surprised if you were right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BMC
You have to wonder about taking a puck even under the eye if it may be causing concussion-related problems. He hasn’t had one in a while, but at some point you have to live the rest of your life.
 
Gotta laugh at the pearl clutching articles about Carlo being traded. “Oh my, whatever will we do for a top four stay at home dman”

Comical.

This guy is severely overrated; has been for years. Fire this guy into the Sun, as EVM would say.
Admit I have not watched much this year, but when I have it appears he has regressed.
There was a preseason game this year where some nobody blew by him. I thought it was just preseason, but
when I watch he seems to make mistakes he didn't in the past. He is one I would trade .
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigGoalBrad
the best time to trade this guy would've been at the 2024 draft when guys like brett pesce and matt roy were available as UFAs.
i still doubt sweeney ever moves on from carlo.
If the B's have a remote chance of making the PO's, I doubt Sweeney will trade anyone of consequence.
Myself, the significant players I'd dangle are : Carlo, Frederick, Coyle, and Zacha. At the trade deadline I think you can get quite a bit more than they are worth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigGoalBrad
it's a toss up which one is worse. You've never liked Peeke. I've been down on Carlo except for last year, where he appeared to have his head removed from his butt. It's back in.

Still B's D should be better than it's showed, all year.

Any team that acquires Carlo will eventually be disappointed with how soft he is.

Right, because I guess they've never seen him play.
 
Gotta laugh at the pearl clutching articles about Carlo being traded. “Oh my, whatever will we do for a top four stay at home dman”

Comical.

This guy is severely overrated; has been for years. Fire this guy into the Sun, as EVM would say.
Considering how trash he's been all season, Carlo should be on the 3rd pair, and off the PK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigGoalBrad

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad