GDT: - Brad Treliving End of Season Presser Thursday @ 10am | Page 11 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

GDT: Brad Treliving End of Season Presser Thursday @ 10am

Trading Matthews and bringing in McDavid is counter productive. Why wouldnt a McDavid, Matthews work?

If your not bringing back Marner. There is is plenty of cap space being added over the next couple of years to have both on team, including Nylander. Remember many players are coming off the books in 2026 off season.

Cap is set to be $104 million. Yes you will add players this off season re-up Tavares, Knies. But you can easily have about 15 million of cap space for that off season if McDavid chooses to try out the market. With that said the Leafs can go over the cap until the season starts. So many moves can make it happen if it gets to that point

A McDavid, Matthews, Tavares top 3 at center would be huge.
rielly/kampff/jarnkrok being off the team + cap rise next year probably gets enough cap space for him.
 
He signed his deal before he had any good seasons while playing on the PP with Drai/McDavid, and having some bad playoffs...

Not every deal that ages well is some sweetheart deal.

dude you should stop talking hockey you have no idea what hockey even means. you were dubas' biggest fan when dubas kept destroying the leaf and still have not said even one bad thing about him

P.S. RNH deal is 5.1 AAV effective 2021-2022 season and he could have gotten a lot more...

1748541036747.png
 
Brad used the word I have used multiple times when referring to this team..."DNA". They don't have it in sufficient quantities and I identified this as early as prior to the series against Columbus.

After the Montreal series it was so abundantly clear that one would be well supported in suggesting that this has been the worst managed team this decade. That had to be the most obvious barometer but perhaps some people just wanted to safely keep their jobs by doing just enough to give the Dumb & Dumber response "there's a chance".

For some time I suggested that Marner would never win a Cup in Toronto, though I firmly believe that Rielly should have been replaced even before Marner. A couple of nice guys. Sometimes Rielly even showed some passion. Both need a change of scenery and both the players and team would benefit.

My guess is that if the cap space spent on Marner and Rielly would have been allocated to other horses that this team would have had at least a Cup Final during this decade. Perhaps even this year...
 
Shanahan and Dubas the biggest culprits of the mess that we are in are GONE!

Treliving is GM for about 2 seasons, Berube is here for about 1 season so this management IMO is kinda new and have to deal with the repercussions of the trash that was shanahan and dubas. But good news.... marner and tavares are ufas if treliving brings both back then you can pin it on him.

Matthews is a franchise player comparable to others except McJesus but who the hell is comparable to McJesus anyway.... Matthews was also injured. IMO Matthews played bigger and better in the playoffs when his line-mates had intensity like Brown/Hyman and Domi/Bertuzzi. Matthews will be an impact player when 100% healthy IMO

Nylander has been a complete BEAST in the playoffs when it comes to producing offense since Montreal series.

We just need to fill the rest of the roster with competent pieces that would allows us to make the playoffs (doesn't matter 1st in division/conference or wildcard) and then in playoffs its a different ball-game altogether.

Treliving has the chance to inject in this roster competent pieces with the cap flexibility this season (hopefully he convinces Rielly to waive too); and reshape the roster.

I think we are on a right trajectory amd we have to maximize last 3 years of Matthews' contract. After that I think we are looking at another rebuild anyway....
I love how when Shanny & Dubas took over their entire MO was keeping the core 'safe and protected', they absolutely coddled these guys. Gave them all the money, whatever term they wanted, then you wonder why it failed? They never had to grow up, it's Peter Pan syndrome with our top guys.
 
dude you should stop talking hockey you have no idea what hockey even means. you were dubas' biggest fan when dubas kept destroying the leaf and still have not said even one bad thing about him

P.S. RNH deal is 5.1 AAV effective 2021-2022 season and he could have gotten a lot more...

View attachment 1043676

Ya, he was coming off a 35 point in 52 game season while get prime PP chances and 2 points in 4 games in the playoffs.

You should learn how a calendar works so you can check what his last season was before he signed.
 
rielly/kampff/jarnkrok being off the team + cap rise next year probably gets enough cap space for him.

Don't forget players like McMann, Reeves and Laughton who also will be free agents.

There is definite dollars to keep both Matthews and McDavid if that opportunity arises.
 
  • Like
Reactions: djdev
I love how when Shanny & Dubas took over their entire MO was keeping the core 'safe and protected', they absolutely coddled these guys. Gave them all the money, whatever term they wanted, then you wonder why it failed? They never had to grow up, it's Peter Pan syndrome with our top guys.

pretty much. I still do not understand how the F did the situation go from....

Shanahan quoted in the media saying "we expect our young leaders (implying 88, 16, 34) to give discounts so we could keep the team together and be competitive"

to the BULLSHIT overpayments and absolutely screwing the Leafs by dubas under shanahan's tutelage.
 
My guess is that if the cap space spent on Marner and Rielly would have been allocated to other horses that this team would have had at least a Cup Final during this decade. Perhaps even this year...

My guess is that had Dubas not been fired in 2023, he would have moved off the core before the NMC kicked in.

That doesn't mean we would have been better though - had he, for example, traded Marner to San Jose for Erik Karlsson like he did as soon as he got to Pittsburgh, would the Leafs have been better off? Unlikely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uncleben
he had 26pts 5v5 this year. thats 3 more points than jake maccabe. i think you can replace that production for less than 7.5m no?

Are we pretending playoffs don't exist?

17th in PPG this year with almost no PP time.

He's tied for 3rd in EVP currently.

2nd over the last 3 years in EVP in fewer games than most players.

And tied for 6th in PPG over the same 3 years (min 10 games).

thanks for reminding me why i ignore your posts

cheers!

No worries, continue posting nonsense.. RNH didn't take some insane deal, he didn't have great production and had a beneficial situation, sorry you don't follow the sport.
 
Are we pretending playoffs don't exist?

17th in PPG this year with almost no PP time.

He's tied for 3rd in EVP currently.

2nd over the last 3 years in EVP in fewer games than most players.

And tied for 6th in PPG over the same 3 years (min 10 games).



No worries, continue posting nonsense.. RNH didn't take some insane deal, he didn't have great production and had a beneficial situation, sorry you don't follow the sport.
hes no different than the other top players.
vs ottawa: 1st 3 games (3 points +2) last 3 games(0 points - 3)
vs fla: 1st 3 games (4 points +2) last 4 games(0 points - 2)

not to mention he literally lost us game 3 single handedly, and was the worst player on the ice in game 7.

you might be a fan of his play, i am not.
 
hes no different than the other top players.
vs ottawa: 1st 3 games (3 points +2) last 3 games(0 points - 3)
vs fla: 1st 3 games (4 points +2) last 4 games(0 points - 2)

not to mention he literally lost us game 3 single handedly, and was the worst player on the ice in game 7.

you might be a fan of his play, i am not.

Goalposts have been moved I see.

Anyway, trade everyone then, the D and goaltending folded, no one scored, Knies has the worst stats of anyone in the last games of the series so may as well sell him while he is young.

What is your point? Should they only keep Domi?
 
Shanahan and Dubas the biggest culprits of the mess that we are in are GONE!

Treliving is GM for about 2 seasons, Berube is here for about 1 season so this management IMO is kinda new and have to deal with the repercussions of the trash that was shanahan and dubas. But good news.... marner and tavares are ufas if treliving brings both back then you can pin it on him.

Matthews is a franchise player comparable to others except McJesus but who the hell is comparable to McJesus anyway.... Matthews was also injured. IMO Matthews played bigger and better in the playoffs when his line-mates had intensity like Brown/Hyman and Domi/Bertuzzi. Matthews will be an impact player when 100% healthy IMO

Nylander has been a complete BEAST in the playoffs when it comes to producing offense since Montreal series.

We just need to fill the rest of the roster with competent pieces that would allows us to make the playoffs (doesn't matter 1st in division/conference or wildcard) and then in playoffs its a different ball-game altogether.

Treliving has the chance to inject in this roster competent pieces with the cap flexibility this season (hopefully he convinces Rielly to waive too); and reshape the roster.

I think we are on a right trajectory amd we have to maximize last 3 years of Matthews' contract. After that I think we are looking at another rebuild anyway....
Okay, but for myself, I don't think Treliving is any better.

Slow aging Dcore and likely to try to fix most of the problems up front with bloated, terrible contracts up front, and now he's talking about the "DNA." Yeah, signing Bennett isn't going to change the DNA.

The DNA is also the system and style that allows you to get bullied on home ice and get out-chanced 21-0 in the most important game of the year, and that's him and Berube, not KD and Shanny now.

How does Tanev get hit 107 times? Maybe it's because the defence is too slow and the coach still thinks he has Pietrangelo, Boumeester, and Parayko, and sets the teams out the same way with this McCabe-Tanev stuff?

Is that part of the DNA going to change? Because I think it should.

The DNA analogy is stupid anyway, and pretty naive to think that he hasn't put his stamp on the team over the past 2 years.
 
My guess is that had Dubas not been fired in 2023, he would have moved off the core before the NMC kicked in.

That doesn't mean we would have been better though - had he, for example, traded Marner to San Jose for Erik Karlsson like he did as soon as he got to Pittsburgh, would the Leafs have been better off? Unlikely.
I was quite animated on here that we NOT try to get Karlsson. When it was reported that he had tried to trade for him but the deal fell through I was relieved.

Brad, Craig and Leafs upper management/ownership seem to be forging a close bond. I think this is critical at this juncture.

I am also glad that Brad is taking his time to take stock.
For me, I see a two year horizon in which to win a Cup. Picking Carlo was fantastic. Laughton showed he can bring it. This is a once in a lifetime opportunity with big salaries coming off the books.

If I am the Leafs I focus on re-signing Knies and Lorentz. They are more important than JT at this point IMO.

Then look at options in UFA, trades for players who may be out of favor but who are the right types. If he can work out a deal for Marner sign and trade eight years, perhaps get a Gamer in return for the team shedding cap (and obviously far less a salary than Marner), that would be a big win. If not, a little win would be a sign and trade for ANYTHING.

Give Benoit some growth as a puck carrier. Let Carlo shoot a little more if he sneaks in to the point. Get some muscle on McMann to prepare for heavy hockey.

They don't need to handcuff themselves again by burning all of the cap space. There is a UFA crop next year too and cap space will be king.

Pick only who you want and need. Make prudent trades. Change the DNA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TorMapleJays
Is there a relationship between paying lots of money and winning playoff games? Here are the top 10 money earners this year. Only McDavid is still playing and realistically he is the only one that can carry a team, a city, a country on his back. I believe an intelligent and even distribution of funds among 20 players will serve you much better. And, the Leafs have 3 in the top 10 with very little to show for it. How do you think the best way is to manage the cap space?

  • Maple Leafs C Auston Matthews: $13.25 million
  • Avalanche C Nathan MacKinnon: $12.6 million
  • Oilers C Connor McDavid $12.5 million
  • Rangers LW Artemi Panarin: $11.64 million
  • Canucks C Elias Pettersson: $11.6 million
  • Penguins D Erik Karlsson: $11.5 million
  • Maple Leafs C/RW William Nylander: $11.5 million
  • Bruins RW David Pastrnak: $11.25 million
  • Kings D Drew Doughty: $11 million
  • Maple Leafs C John Tavares: $11 million
 
  • Like
Reactions: Punch Drunk Loov
My guess is that had Dubas not been fired in 2023, he would have moved off the core before the NMC kicked in.

That doesn't mean we would have been better though - had he, for example, traded Marner to San Jose for Erik Karlsson like he did as soon as he got to Pittsburgh, would the Leafs have been better off? Unlikely.
Dunno. EK have had one of the best playoff runs of this century and he’s something the Leafs desperately needs - an offensive d man that provides tons of offense and can QB that PP. Cant say the same about Marner
 
He signed his deal before he had any good seasons while playing on the PP with Drai/McDavid, and having some bad playoffs...

Not every deal that ages well is some sweetheart deal.

So we're acting like a 68 point pace in the 3 seasons leading up to the extension isn't good? He also had 10 points in 8 playoff games

And he's taking advantage of his golden opportunity of playing PP with the two stars. If he wasn't any good, he'd be off the PP...
 
I think the one thing Shanahan did well was being able to convince good and respected execs to come around. Not that it helped the end process but I wonder how that affects future execs/scout hires moving forward. We'll see how he does but the last exec hired by Shanahan was Mark Leach, who was the head scout for Dallas, which is very promising.

I kinda felt like as time went on and the Shanaplan regime was more set in its ways it didn’t really hire the same quality of management executives, like the brain trust has closed down. I recall the days when we had Lamoriello, Hunter, Dubas and still went after McCrimmon.

Functionally I guess there’s a limit to how many head chefs you can put in one kitchen.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad