Player Discussion Brad Marchand X- Return of the Rat
- Thread starter EverettMike
- Start date
Dr Quincy
Registered User
- Jun 19, 2005
- 29,392
- 11,752
Lowbridging a guy's knees seconds after he gives you a clean hit isn't "interference maybe"... it was a dirty cheap play. If you want to argue the length of this current suspension, that's one thing. But please... the apologists for a guy who went out and TRIED to injure someone and succeeded is a little bit much. It's not tough old school hockey, it's a gutless, coward's play. He didn't like getting a clean hit so he intentionally went into a guy's knees.
BTW here's the DPS well explained video for this with the definition of the actual penalty and the context why it wasn't a 2 minute penalty.
RussellmaniaKW
Registered User
- Sep 15, 2004
- 19,729
- 21,853
I will forever defend this play because he clearly hits him above the knees. Literally anybody else does that and it's called a "beauty of a hip check". Sneaky, dirty play? Yes. Illegal check? No and it never should have been punished.
Keith Ballard used to do shit like this all the time and was praised for it:
Listen to the HNIC guys gushing over Ballard doing it to McGinn here
Another Ballard hip check for good measure that I believe went unpunished despite injuring Perry.
Honestly I could post more but there's too many to post b/c Ballard made a career out of it.
Only difference compared to what Marchand did is the patches on the front & back of the jerseys IMO.
The National
Registered User
thanks for coming here and explaining to us how DOPS got it right. I guess I was wrong questioning the decision making of the DOPS leadership.
BTW, we know you dislike Marchand so I'm not really sure your giving us an unbiased opinion.
CharasLazyWrister
Registered User
Yeah, I can’t disagree with your point on this play. It’s a cheap as shit play, but Keith Ballard was doing it virtually nightly and getting praised. Some of Ballard’s hits were so ridiculous, it was laughable. He “hip checked” Malkin by almost laying down on the ice.
CharasLazyWrister
Registered User
Complaining about an organization like DoPS is a given no matter how they handle things. It’s like complaining about referees. It doesn’t prove anything other than fans dislike authority and store in their minds all the perceived injustices most of which are heavily tainted by bias.
The league has whipped through I don’t know how many heads of the DoPS and they’ve all been equally hated.
Disappointed but not surprised.
Nor am I. Still doesn't mean that Bettman isn't a sackless weasel who is scared to hold DOPS accountable
Knox Harrington
Registered User
- May 28, 2021
- 544
- 614
my issue is that it's always been a previous nhl player. clearly they bring historical bias based on the way they played. many times suspending players they played against. the optics are terrible. I simply feel a good first step would be to remove any perceived bias from the so called judges.
Bruinaura
Resident Cookie Monster
- Mar 29, 2014
- 47,210
- 92,937
Okay, please tell us more about some other "unenviable records" around the league
Like Subban
Crosby
Oh wait....
And no, I'm not denying Marchand's history because he has done some stupid crap. But this wasn't worth six games.
As I said in the other thread, there was no way Bettman was going to undermine DOPS by reducing the suspension.
Bruinaura
Resident Cookie Monster
- Mar 29, 2014
- 47,210
- 92,937
The National
Registered User
Not surprised I guess, it is what it is. It seemed a few games too many to me but don’t feel bad for him at all that it isn’t.
22Brad Park
Registered User
Saxon Eric
Registered User
- Dec 18, 2005
- 20,767
- 29,037
The National
Registered User
I mean if this is true and you chirp as much as Marchand does how can your skin be this thin when guys give it back?
Bruinaura
Resident Cookie Monster
- Mar 29, 2014
- 47,210
- 92,937
Bruinaura
Resident Cookie Monster
- Mar 29, 2014
- 47,210
- 92,937
Marchand testified to it, so if it's not true he's willing to let people believe it is...
