Blues @ Flames: Bring your parents and ridiculous stick saves!

Status
Not open for further replies.

GrandPapillon*

Guest
Only if you're anti-Backes...


More goals with less ice time, and less powerplay time. Plus, watching the games, he handles the puck better in the offensive zone and seems more confident.

Backes is doing a great job shutting down other teams' top lines and I am not saying that sarcastically. It's just that he is playing more like a 3rd line center than a 1st line center and captain.
 

bleedblue1223

Registered User
Jan 21, 2011
52,920
16,369
He has this season.

More goals with less ice time, and less powerplay time. Plus, watching the games, he handles the puck better in the offensive zone and seems more confident.

Backes is doing a great job shutting down other teams' top lines and I am not saying that sarcastically. It's just that he is playing more like a 3rd line center than a 1st line center and captain.

I'm not taking anything away from Sobotka, and I love him, but he had a great few games offensively. He hasn't been very productive outside of that short stretch.
 

GrandPapillon*

Guest
If you can't look at Backes objectively, don't get upset at people not looking at Perron objectively.


Perron: Producing points and playing above averagely defensively while creating chances in the offensive zone no matter who is on his line. He remains a very streaky player who is prone to making mental mistakes and taking terrible penalties. He tends to at times try to do too much in the offensive zone and pass up making a simple yet smart play for a tougher riskier play which sometimes blows up in his face. He is an important part of this team and the Blues future.

Backes: Doing a great job matching up against the top lines of other teams and playing a physical game. He doesn't usually make many mistakes and doesn't really have bad nights defensively. In the offensive zone, he has struggled mightily as he doesn't appear to have much confidence currently in his puck handling. His lack of goalscoring, especially when there is a goalie in the net, has been unacceptable given his icetime, powerplay time, and quality linemates he has played with this season. He is an important part of this team and the Blues future.

What part of this lacks objectivity?
 

bleedblue1223

Registered User
Jan 21, 2011
52,920
16,369
Backes is producing points, a 51 point pace for an 82 game average, higher than his career average, and just 4 points under his average for his past 4 seasons.

Do people expect him to be on a 70+ point pace or something?
 

BlueOil

"well-informed"
Apr 28, 2010
7,251
4,253
Perron: Producing points and playing above averagely defensively while creating chances in the offensive zone no matter who is on his line. He remains a very streaky player who is prone to making mental mistakes and taking terrible penalties. He tends to at times try to do too much in the offensive zone and pass up making a simple yet smart play for a tougher riskier play which sometimes blows up in his face. He is an important part of this team and the Blues future.

Backes: Doing a great job matching up against the top lines of other teams and playing a physical game. He doesn't usually make many mistakes and doesn't really have bad nights defensively. In the offensive zone, he has struggled mightily as he doesn't appear to have much confidence currently in his puck handling. His lack of goalscoring, especially when there is a goalie in the net, has been unacceptable given his icetime, powerplay time, and quality linemates he has played with this season. He is an important part of this team and the Blues future.

What part of this lacks objectivity?

Your assessment of Backes in the offensive zone.

Backes has only 3 goals and that really seems to be your only point in the entire argument. Backes has 16 assists and despite struggling to find the net so far, is playing on par for his career offensively.
 

GrandPapillon*

Guest
Backes is producing points, a 51 point pace for an 82 game average, higher than his career average, and just 4 points under his average for his past 4 seasons.

I did just check to and his shooting percentage is insanely low this season, under half his career average low. This could suggest that some of his lack of offense has to do with some bad luck. I would say that some of Backes' assists have been the result of secondary assists due to the talented players he plays with, but I have nothing to back that up or to see how many of Perron's assists are secondary ones so the point is moot. Still, he needs to score more than goals just like Perron needs to keep his ass out of the penalty box.


My problem can be summed up like this. When Perron has a bad period, the response by so many here is "trade him. He's lazy, selfish, and the team doesn't need him." When Backes has a bad period, "He must be fighting through an injury like a champ."
 

bleedblue1223

Registered User
Jan 21, 2011
52,920
16,369
I did just check to and his shooting percentage is insanely low this season, under half his career average low. This could suggest that some of his lack of offense has to do with some bad luck. I would say that some of Backes' assists have been the result of secondary assists due to the talented players he plays with, but I have nothing to back that up or to see how many of Perron's assists are secondary ones so the point is moot. Still, he needs to score more than goals just like Perron needs to keep his ass out of the penalty box.


My problem can be summed up like this. When Perron has a bad period, the response by so many here is "trade him. He's lazy, selfish, and the team doesn't need him." When Backes has a bad period, "He must be fighting through an injury like a champ."

This. No point arguing about something stupid. They both can improve.
 

bluemandan

Ya Ma Goo!
Mar 18, 2008
3,835
0
...

My problem can be summed up like this. When Perron has a bad period, the response by so many here is "trade him. He's lazy, selfish, and the team doesn't need him." When Backes has a bad period, "He must be fighting through an injury like a champ."

There are couple of reasons for that:

1.) Backes is a center, and Perron a winger. Blues are thin on center, and flush with wingers. Therefore centers are cut some extra slack on the Blues due to a lack of other options.

2.) Perron's issues are much easier corrected than Backes' issues. Getting a player to stop making a move at the blueline, or stop taking so many offensive zone penalties, or stop holding on to the puck too long is much easier than getting a player to score more goals.

3.) Perron's style of play doesn't exactly fit the stated playing style of the Blues. (He isn't the only one.)

4.) Perron's issues have been the same issues for a few seasons now. Backes is having a down year by the eye-test. (I'm aware of his point projection.) Backes doesn't seem to be playing as physical game-in and game-out like he usually does, and the goal scoring is lacking. But those aren't issues that have exsisted for years like with Perron.

5.) Perron "has a bad period" much more often than Backes "has a bad period." If Perron's bad period occurred at the same rate as Backes' over the past couple of seasons, I don't think people would be as hard on Perron. Perron is consistently inconsistent.
 

BlueOil

"well-informed"
Apr 28, 2010
7,251
4,253
Really think it's time to stop the 4 forward powerplay, it hasn't been successful lately.
 

Wiems35*

Guest
Knew they would score as soon as I saw the "Blues have killed off their last 10 penalties".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad