After the first few days here are my short notes of every player at camp that is playing (excluding most tryouts). I will also include some projections for them in the future. Hopefully this helps people who weren't able to go to the prospect camp this year. I will just be going in order based on number.
Team MaCinnis:
Vadim Zherenko (1): The only goalie who has really stood out and show NHL potential. He has NHL size but his positioning needs a little work. He plays too far back in the net and could be a bit more aggressive. I think he is still a long way away but he is clearly the Blues best goalie prospect outside of Hofer.
Projection: Backup Goalie
Colton Huard (67): At first I thought he was a forward because he joined the rush so much but it turns out he's a dman. He shows a lot of speed and a good shot. I could see him coming back next year and being even better. He is only 22 and has put up 2 good years at the University of New Hampshire.
Colton Huard at eliteprospects.com
Projection: AHL dman
Otto Stenberg (70): The Blues most likely got a steal in Stenberg. Blues fans have a lot to be excited about him. I think he has the highest awareness on the ice and has that 6th sense ability that you dream of in a hockey player. He has good speed, a hard shot, and high end passing. He is also a puck hound and never far from the action. He does need to bulk up a little as he can get pushed off the puck at times. He can also force passes or expect teammates to think to his level (and most can't) but that will improve as he matures.
Projection: Top 6 winger
Andre Heim (74): I was excited to see Heim play but he has been disappointing. For a 25 year old you would expect him to dominate and he just blends in most times. He does seem to be good around the net and has good size but I don't think there is much NHL upside especially because he is the type of player who wouldn't play hard enough in the bottom 6 for the Blues.
Projection: AHL/back overseas
Theo Lindstein (77): As advertised, Lindstein has great defensive awareness and positioning. He uses his stick well to attack rushers and is rarely out of position. Pretty much everything defensively looks great. The problem is his offense is lacking to me. He struggles with puck control and decision making and often just passes it off to his defensive partner. His best weapon offensively is his shot but he doesn't use it enough. He looks like a player that just needs to gain confidence and then he could become a real weapon as a 2 way player instead of just a defensive dman.
Projection: 2nd pair dman
Tanner Dickinson (78): For a guy coming off a broken leg Dickinson has looked amazing. He's fast, smart, and consistently makes the right decision with the puck. Before his injury he was projecting with some serious playmaking upside. I think if he can stay healthy and get a full year in the AHL he could get back on track and reach that ceiling.
Projection: Top 9 winger
Simon Robertsson (80): One of the more improved players from last year in my mind, Robertsson is constantly flying around the ice and making plays everywhere. He's probably our fastest prospect and has good hands to go along with the speed. He still looks a long way away but I liked the improvement I saw. A lot of the time he is so close to finishing a good play but just can't do it. Maybe as he adds weight and strength he will be able to complete those plays.
Projection: Fringe NHLer
Jeremie Biakabutuka (82): One of the best tryouts in my mind, Biakabutuka is constantly joining the rush and doing his best to get a contract. He has a good shot and for being as big as he is, he's pretty fast.
Projection: AHL dman
Hunter Skinner (83): Basically the Blues only right handed defensive prospect (he might be the only one correct me if I'm wrong), Skinner has good height and a solid stride. He looks like he needs to add strength but that will come over the next few years. He also has a good shot and isn't afraid to shoot a one timer. For a guy we got as a throw in in the Tarasenko trade he actually looks solid and with how few right handed d the blues have I could see him cracking the lineup in a few years.
Projection: Bottom Pair Dman
Marc-Andre Gaudet (87): Gaudet really has one big attribute and that is his shot. He is the best shooter of any of our defensive prospects and looks like he is holding back in camp (the one time he let a one timer go Zherenko got hurt). Other than that though he is pretty invisible and will need to get stronger in order to make the NHL. I'm excited to see what he does with a full year on his new team in the juniors.
Projection: AHL dman/Fringe NHLer
Juraj Pekarcik (88): WOW! The Blues got themselves a steal in Pekarcik. I know it's early but you can just tell he's going to be good. Think Torpo but with good hands and a stronger frame. For the youngest player in the draft he already has great size. On top of that he knows how to use that size and he loves to drive to the net. Great hands and he can pull off highlight real moves at high speeds. In a few years when he adds even more strength he could be the Blues best prospect. The ceiling is VERY high for Pekarcik.
Projection: Top 6 winger
Jakub Stancl (93): Stancl is a big kid for being 18. He's constantly chasing the puck and driving towards the net which you love to see. He also has a powerful shot.
Projection: Bottom 6 forward
Team Tkachuk:
Dalibor Dvorsky (54): Everything you would expect from the 10th overall pick. He is the best player on the ice on most of his shifts and just looks great. Amazing hands, hard shot, high awareness, the list goes on and on. On top of that he is one of the best back checkers and is constantly giving 100% effort which you love to see at a prospect camp. He does need to work on his speed a little but it was better than I thought it was going to be after reading scouting reports.
Projection: 1B Center
Ian Murphy (60): The best tryout in my mind, Murphy has great speed and is always flying around the ice trying to pull high end moves. He has pretty good hands as well. Only problem is he is already 24 and is loses the puck a lot (he does get it back a lot too but still) so I don't see him getting a contract.
Projection: Fringe AHLer
Michael Buchinger (62): Hasn't played much this camp but I think he is criminally underrated. He truly is the best defensive prospect we have and looks a lot like a smaller version of Dunn when he was a prospect here. He makes high end passes and just has such a high level of awareness. The Blues love to make offensive minded dmen try to become defensive dmen so we'll see if Buchinger reaches his ceiling here. I also worry with the backload of left d if he will have a roster spot to compete for in a few years.
Projection: Top 4 puck moving dman
Aleksanteri Kaskimaki (65): Good speed and hands but he has pretty much no wiggle to his game and is standing up straight a lot. I have moments where I am really impressed and then moments where I want more (expected for a 19 year old prospect).
Projection: Fringe NHLer
Noah Beck (68): Beck just stands out as big to me. He's big and fast and makes average passes to his defensive partner but that's about it. He doesn't play very physical for being that big either which is a slight concern.
Projection: AHL dman
Dylan Peterson (71): Peterson has every raw ability you want in a hockey player. He's huge, fast, and powerful. The problem is everything else is lacking. He has poor decision making, bad passes, horrible stick work, and an average shot. He could make it on raw talent alone as a good defensive fourth liner but he can barely hold on to the puck against tryout players I can't imagine him against NHL players.
Projection: AHL Center
Zach Bolduc (76): I will start off by saying Bolduc has improved a lot from last years camp in my mind. But that isn't saying a lot because he was pretty horrible in last years camp. He looks a lot faster and constantly is calling out plays or calling for the puck which you like to see. He also has bursts of high end play which you love to see. The problem is his overall lack of effort defensively. As a Blues prospect you will start off in the bottom 6 and work your way up and I just can't see Bolduc doing that. He is standing straight up most of the time and is constantly the last forward back on the rush. He knows that his defense is the reason he got sent down so quickly last year so you would like to see him working harder but he just isn't. I don't see him making the roster this year and by next year he could be passed up by prospects, Snuggerud, Dvorsky, Dean, and Stenberg for a roster spot.
Projection: Powerplay specialist
Jimmy Snuggerud (81): Snuggerud didn't show much and looked gassed a lot of time so he could be fighting an injury (he wasn't at practice too) and that would make sense. He seems to hold back his shot too so I'm not really concerned about the lack of goal scoring he probably just doesn't want to injure a teammate. Again all of this is hopeful stuff because he just hasn't been very impressive.
Projection: Top 6 winger
Ivan Vorobyov (86): You just have to love Blues scouting as we got Vorobyov in the 7th round and he looks like a steal. He has been arguably the best player at camp and just impresses me every time he is on the ice. He has silky smooth hands and a high hockey sense. He isn't a big shooter but has had a few good goals here and there. I wonder if he will sign to play in the AHL (hopefully) or if he will head back to russia where he will play in the KHL this year.
Projection: Top 9 winger
Paul Fischer (94): Fischer needs a lot of work to put it lightly. He has no identity to his game and it looks like he is unsure if he wants to play offensive or defensive. He has plenty of time to figure that out in college but he needs to decide because right now he is playing in the middle and it just isn't working he looks lost.
Projection: 7th dman
Matt Mayich (95): Last up is Mayich. For a big guy he can move quickly and was a lot better offensively then I thought he would be. He looks better than Tucker was as an 18 year old so that's a good sign and if he works hard I could easily see him in the NHL some day.
Projection: Bottom Pair dman.
Hopefully you enjoyed the read if you made it all the way through and I would love to hear if anyone has different opinions on these players. Thanks!