Was my feedback 20 years ago....
Two separate places would be great.
Well I wasn't making such calls THAT long ago but maybe 3 years ago or so we considered it.
I ended up on the against it side though.
It would be a dead board for months out of the year. Serious rumors of deals don't happen with enough frequency to sustain it. Only in the silly seasons like the TDL draft and free agency would it really be active.
The way it is now both crowds see both threads which increases posting. I suspect most of the serious interest only crowd isn't completely turned away cause while the trade board can be silly AF where else ya gonna go? Facebook? Reddit? All are sillier.
So what you'd have is two boards less active than before cumulatively instead of 1 really active but imperfect one.
At least that's my read. I'd say for every 1 serious thread the board is kept active by at LEAST 50 specluative ones.