DitchMarner
TheGlitchintheSwitch
He does, correct. 156 to be exact, and two trips to the finals and normally very effective in the playoffs (eg. even in 1993 during a sweep he had 9 assists!)
Propp follows him at 148.
Honestly, it is hard to find anyone with better postseasons and a better postseason resume than Oates, Propp and Briere at this moment. They have all the ingredients of this thread. They made the finals (5 times for Propp) did well in each long playoff run, have the career numbers, have plenty of good runs and no Cup to show for it. Not their fault.
If I could mention Dino as another guy. 73 goals, and he always scored in the playoffs. Only has the one big run as a rookie in 1981 but also made the final in 1995.
Not that plus/minus is the best stat ever, but I think it is worth mentioning that Ciccarelli was -41 in the playoffs in his career despite having good overall numbers (73 goals, 118 points in 141 games). He was a minus player in almost every single playoff run he had even though he usually produced. I don't know how relevant it is exactly, but it does make you wonder and think.