Best player in the world: 2016

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates

Best player in the world: 2016

  • Kane

    Votes: 75 41.9%
  • Benn

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Crosby

    Votes: 62 34.6%
  • Thornton

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kopitar

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Ovechkin

    Votes: 5 2.8%
  • Malkin

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Doughty

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Karlsson

    Votes: 24 13.4%
  • Burns

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Letang

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Holtby

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Bishop

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Price

    Votes: 9 5.0%

  • Total voters
    179
  • Poll closed .

FrankSidebottom

Registered User
Mar 16, 2021
635
742
And here comes your second non-forward winner: Carey Price. Who is next in 2016 (15/16 season) ?

Previous polls:
1998 (62% 1 Hasek, 2 Jagr, 3 Forsberg)
1999 (48% 1 Jagr, 2 Hasek, 3 Forsberg)
2000 (72% 1 Jagr, 2 Pronger, 3 Bure)
2001 (33% 1 Lemieux, 2 Sakic, 3 Jagr)
2002 (36% 1 Iginla, 2 Lidstrom, 3 Lemieux)
2003 (52% 1 Forsberg, 2 Naslund, 3 Lemieux)
2004 (23% 1 Forsberg, 2 St. Louis, 3 Luongo)
2006 (31% 1 Thornton, 2 Jagr, 3 Crosby)
2007 (73% 1 Crosby, 2 Lidstrom, 3 Lecavalier/Luongo)
2008 (64% 1 Ovechkin, 2 Crosby, 3 Zetterberg)
2009 (44% 1 Ovechkin, 2 Malkin, 3 Crosby)
2010 (56% 1 Ovechkin, 2 Crosby, 3 H.Sedin)
2011 (58% 1 Crosby, 2 Thomas, 3 D. Sedin)
2012 (47% 1 Malkin, 2 Crosby, 3 Stamkos)
2013 (70% 1 Crosby, 2 Ovechkin, 3 Malkin)
2014 (80% 1 Crosby, 2 Malkin, 3 Price)
2015 (42% 1 Price, 2 Crosby, 3 Ovechkin)
 
Kane. I get choosing Karlsson though. Once again Crosby will get his reputation votes but I exhaustively made my point about the semantics argument last poll so it’s whatever. I guess he does have the conn smythe this year but even that was a pretty weak conn smythe performance and arguably undeserved.
 
Kane. I get choosing Karlsson though. Once again Crosby will get his reputation votes but I exhaustively made my point about the semantics argument last poll so it’s whatever. I guess he does have the conn smythe this year but even that was a pretty weak conn smythe performance and arguably undeserved.
2nd in hart and a Conn Smythe first team center. Pretty damn good season
 
You seem to have some trouble with maths. Explains most of your posts.

You seem to have trouble with just about everything. Explains most of your posts.

Spoiler alert from a season that ended over 7 years ago. Kane scored 106 points compared to Crosby’s 85, a difference of 21 points. 21/85 = 24.7%.

Oops, you really thought this was the season Benn beat Crosby for the first time, didn’t you? No, this was the following season where Crosby was drowning deep at sea while Kane was on a yacht laughing.
 
It’s a weird season. Kane had the best year but I think he was producing a bit above his head and was never actually the best player. Was crazy hot the first 1/4 of the season. Crosby was a bit better the rest of the year after a weak start under MJ. I think initial Sullivan era Crosby was better than Kane and that continued into the following year. Price was just as good as the year before before getting injured. Karlsson and Doughty we’re both very good but I’m not sure if quite best in the league. I mean it’s easy to default to Kane but I’m not convinced he was the best just as I don’t think Kucherov was better than McDavid in 18-19. Granted McDavid was closer in the actual season
 
Last edited:
You seem to have trouble with just about everything. Explains most of your posts.

Spoiler alert from a season that ended over 7 years ago. Kane scored 106 points compared to Crosby’s 85, a difference of 21 points. 21/85 = 24.7%.

Oops, you really thought this was the season Benn beat Crosby for the first time, didn’t you? No, this was the following season where Crosby was drowning deep at sea while Kane was on a yacht laughing.
Crosby did not even bother with a yacht. He just took the private jet with his cup and smythe
 
  • Like
Reactions: sanscosm
It’s a weird season. Kane had the best year but I think he was producing a bit above his head and was never actually the best player. Was crazy hot the first 1/4 of the season. Crosby was a bit better the rest of the year after a weak start under MJ. I think initial Sullivan era Crosby was better than Kane and that continued into the following year. Price was just as good as the year before before getting injured. Karlsson and Doughty we’re both very good but I’m not sure if quite best in the league. I mean it’s easy to default to Kane but I’m not convinced he was the best just as I don’t think Kucherov was better than McDavid in 18-19
But counting stats.........
 
  • Haha
Reactions: GreatGonzo
It’s a weird season. Kane had the best year but I think he was producing a bit above his head and was never actually the best player. Was crazy hot the first 1/4 of the season. Crosby was a bit better the rest of the year after a weak start under MJ. I think initial Sullivan era Crosby was better than Kane and that continued into the following year. Price was just as good as the year before before getting injured. Karlsson and Doughty we’re both very good but I’m not sure if quite best in the league. I mean it’s easy to default to Kane but I’m not convinced he was the best just as I don’t think Kucherov was better than McDavid in 18-19. Granted McDavid was closer in the actual season
Of course you’re not convinced. Either way, the guy walked away with the scoring title, Hart, and Lindsay. You can argue Crosby was better but at that point it’s just bias talk. Kane out scored Crosby by a huge margin and would follow it up with a 2nd and 3rd place finish over the next few years.

Funny thing is, I’m sure if they were flipped, you would still vote Crosby.
 
Cute attempt to rescue bambam. By the way, were you the stewardess on that private jet?
Part of your user name checks out but you got the affirmation you wanted right?

Kane is a fine player but at no point in their overlapping careers did anyone seriously say or think that Kane was a better player than Crosby.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sanscosm
Kane had the best season, but he was never the best player in the world at any point, it was still Carey Price.

Price was leaning toward another Vezina worthy season, then got injured and the Habs showed their true colors, as they instantly fell apart once Price went out for the season.
 
Of course you’re not convinced. Either way, the guy walked away with the scoring title, Hart, and Lindsay. You can argue Crosby was better but at that point it’s just bias talk. Kane out scored Crosby by a huge margin and would follow it up with a 2nd and 3rd place finish over the next few years.

Funny thing is, I’m sure if they were flipped, you would still vote Crosby.

Lol I love how the usual crowd with biases against Crosby just assume any argument they don’t agree with is due to a bias for him. I haven’t voted for Crosby here, or in any of the other seasons he hasn’t won, but have argued against the idea that simply the best season is the end goal here. But if your lack of reading comprehension leads to that conclusion, so be it.
 
Part of your user name checks out but you got the affirmation you wanted right?

Kane is a fine player but at no point in their overlapping careers did anyone seriously say or think that Kane was a better player than Crosby.

Ho hum, the third member of the Ghostly Trio has appeared.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Voight
If Price didn’t get injured he would have won Hart and Vezina again and had even better numbers lol
 
Kane had the best season, but he was never the best player in the world at any point, it was still Carey Price.

Price was leaning toward another Vezina worthy season, then got injured and the Habs showed their true colors, as they instantly fell apart once Price went out for the season.

I think it’d be tough to win a consecutive Hart as a goalie, but I could see him having a similar season again. He seemed dialed in before the injury.
 
Lol at people still voting for Crosby.

Part of your user name checks out but you got the affirmation you wanted right?

Kane is a fine player but at no point in their overlapping careers did anyone seriously say or think that Kane was a better player than Crosby.
So people were wrong? Cool.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad