Bennett hit on Stolarz (no supplemental discipline) MOD WARNING IN POST #621

[Trafalgar Sadge Law]

Florida getting preferential treatment from the league in terms of supplemental discipline? I'm shocked I tell you! Shocked! #JustGregoryCampbellThings

 

[snag]

Literally all I said was that hitting the back of your head is dangerous and you’re still arguing with me?

And you don't even need to hit your head to get a concussion.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Do you have a video of what you're referring to? The original one posted in the thread was the motion with the helmet afaik

Bottom video:

 

[Monsieur Miz]

The NHL got it right. The Bennett slandering has to stop.

 

[TheBeastCoast]

The NHL got it right. The Bennett slandering has to stop.

Oh the slander has just begun.

 

[Edmonton East]

Yes, it is. I read the study in its entirety. Do you have any way to refute this other than just repeatedly stating the same thing over and over?

Multiple people in this thread being blatantly unable to understand a scientific study isn't evidence that you're all right.

Since you are so sure you understand the study, can you explain to me what the 72% statistic in the study does represent? Since you keep claiming the dude on Twitter was manipulating it. OK, in that case, what is the true meaning of the statistic?

If you believe 72% of incidents where people shake their head like that after head contact or movement is indicative of a concussion, I can't help you. Best of luck. Still isn't what that study proves at all either.

As I said earlier, quick alert the media! Run the story right after the red wine makes you live longer segment. Then again 2 weeks later after the red wine kills you sooner segment to be safe. Gotta make the public aware! Get it? Fun with numbers and appeal to authority fallacy. Maybe look that up. Decades upon decades of actual research across civilizations.

 

[All Mod Cons]

Leafs need to move on. If they breath wrong on Bennett or Bob, you know it will be a suspension with both teams histories regarding the DOPS. Focus on the task at hand.

I can absolutely see Paccioretty getting a suspension this series.

Other possibilities are McCabe, Domi and Benoit.

 

[RedHawkDown]

If you believe 72% of incidents where people shake their head like that after head contact or movement is indicative of a concussion, I can't help you. Best of luck. Still isn't what that study proves at all either.

As I said earlier, quick alert the media! Run the story right after the red wine makes you live longer segment. Then again 2 weeks later after the red wine kills you sooner segment to be safe. Gotta make the public aware! Get it?

Right, so you have zero clue what the study is saying, and once again your only argument is just stating you are right. This is kind of embarrassing, I'm sorry I had to put you in the spotlight like this.

I didn't say that I believe 72% of all incidents where people shake their heads means they have a concussion, because I'm not going to make conclusions off a single small sample-size retrospective survey based study. At the same time, I recognize that the study did exactly prove that 72% statistic in their own cohort, and I can recognize that the study serves as a good basis for future work evaluating this SHAAKE phenomenon and that this might end up being an important symptom of concussion in the future.

Currently on your 10th iteration of blindly stating that's not what the study proves, without at all engaging with why that's the case. Are you capable whatsoever of engaging with the content and refuting anything using reasoning, instead of just repeating you are correct over and over?

The media sensationalizing research has nothing to do with the points we are discussing here. Why are you discussing irrelevant topics? Could it be because you actually have zero ability to read and understand a scientific study?

 

[Uber Coca]

Agreed on all account.

But I don't want the Leafs coming out of it feeling good either

100%. If the Leafs beat the Panthers, they do have a clear path to the Finals though. Quite the conundrum.

 

[Thallis]

Bottom video:

Thanks, I hadn't seen that. Even still, I would like to hear it from from an MD first before taking it as fact, but I'm much more open to it.

 

[bleedthenorth]

LOL Panthers are so lucky they have a tax advantage and Bettman in their pocket

 

[Sasha Orlov]

Because Sammy B splashes water at disabled senior citizens when he drives in the rain. It is a tough look. Also heard he hates puppies. Even practices his sneaky chicken wings on them sometimes. Why his CW/60 is so elite.

This is probably all true though

 

[mobilus]

I’m starting to understand why people struggle with what goaltending interference is.

Not surprising because the penalty is called interference. Or roughing, that’s another penalty in the books. Are you starting to understand what a goal crease is? It’s the thing with blue paint.

 

[Over the volcano]

The NHL got it right. The Bennett slandering has to stop.

I mean if you think about it he's the real victim here,

 

[RedHawkDown]

Thanks, I hadn't seen that. Even still, I would like to hear it from from an MD first before taking it as fact, but I'm much more open to it.

As an MD I can tell you we are no more qualified to make any statement on whether this is predictive of concussion than this guy is, given he is the one that has identified this as a potential marker of concussion. Future work could show that it's not predictive at all, but his is the only study that's even looked at it, so it's hard to say either way. It certainly is a promising thing to look at.

 

[Leonardo87]

Folks,

We are done here, league is not taking any supplemental discipline, plus the trolling and flaming has gotten out of hand. Feel free to use the Series thread above to discuss the series...

Series Talk: - ECSF: (A1) Toronto Maple Leafs vs (A3) Florida Panthers (TOR Leads 1-0)

Thank you.