Bedard or Celebrini

[BuiumSaveUs]

Celebrini. Bigger, more complete. He controls the game as Rollie better than Bedard did last year in the games I watched both.

 

[HairyKneel]

Gonna go out on a limb and say this one isn't even close for me. Bedard 100%.

I'm not even sure Celebrini will end up as a #1 center.

Edit for clarification: has the potential to be, but still requires a lot of work to get there

Lmao...... good one.

 

[wetcoast]

Luke’s still pretty damn good though. Macklin’s brother might never be as good and still end up a stud too.

Yes Luke is good but sometimes some people just go crazy over the younger guy who is still a prospect and to be fair it was an overall general comment not directed at the poster but in general.

Celebrini was the first overall pick in the last draft had an elite college season and is a goal per game (sure small sample size) in the NHL so far, that's a really high bar.

Likewise with Luke as it's unlikely that he peaks or primes as high as Quinn IMO.

 

[HairyKneel]

Bedard, has a higher offensive ceiling, but doesn't play D so its tough.



Celebrini plays defense like Toews? lol. yeah, no.

He's 18. He does have a well rounded game though. Let's let the kid get a bit settled.

Toews was a very good two way player. Anze Kopitar is a great two way player.

 

[HeadLiceHatty]

He's 18. He does have a well rounded game though. Let's let the kid get a bit settled.

Toews was a very good two way player. Anze Kopitar is a great two way player.

Sure, but I'm responding to someone who said he has a Toews like game with offense, I don't agree, he doesn't play on the other side of the puck anything like Toews lol

 

[HairyKneel]

Sure, but I'm responding to someone who said he has a Toews like game with offense, I don't agree, he doesn't play on the other side of the puck anything like Toews lol

I'm doubtful Toews was either. Either way it's a moot point. I will be happy when they both come back to the best province in this country and playing for their favorite team growing up. 2030 and 2031. Quinn should have some decent hockey left in him still. Peter as well.