Post-Game Talk: Bear (Preseason edition)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Shesterkybomb

Registered User
Dec 30, 2016
16,532
17,743
The other things I noticed:
His skating concerns are overblown, he gets to where he needs to be regularly
He has very good hockey sense. The puck kind of follows him around and he consistently finds himself in soft spots or good spots for his teammates to find him. That's a skill that is hard to teach
Been saying this all along, he skates well enough to get to where he needs to be, some players are buzz saws but don't know where or when to go somewhere. He catches people with hits so it's not like he's plodding along, he's not Hagelin but he's not Maroon either.
 

GoAwayPanarin

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
May 27, 2008
44,168
57,107
In High Altitoad
Theres no space for Mancini at the moment and getting top pair+ST minutes in Hartford are going to be 1000000x better for him than getting 8-10 with the Rangers.

Also important to note that he stood out against mostly the level of competition that he's going to be facing this year. It's not a bad thing and its obviously better to look good than to suck but these are things to consider.

But theres something there for sure though and he has the size that the FO covets. Might be someone who ends up sliding into the lineup next year after Trouba is moved.

Wish we had a LD version to push Lindgren but that guy is going to have to come from outside of the organization.
 

eco's bones

Registered User
Jul 21, 2005
26,793
13,731
Elmira NY
I made this same comparison for Mancini a week or two ago too. The Skjei one is really interesting. I think there may be more offense available for a good skating d-man who can get pucks to the net effectively at the NHL level over college.

When Mancini started in Hartford I was expecting he'd do fairly well on the things that were his strengths in college because he was a top notch defender with a lot of size and who skated well. For a defenseman just having those specific elements in your game is enough to become an NHL player. I wasn't expecting him really to put up any offense and the 3 assists in 7 regular season games and 3 more assists in 10 playoff games was more that I would have thought.

Sometimes just playing with better players makes a player a significantly better player.

As for his chances to break camp with the Rangers I think it's still too early to tell....not just for him but for Edstrom, Othmann, Berard as well. It's one game---if he continues to stand out when he plays he'll make it hard to send him down. I'd note what Rod Brind'amour said about Seth Jarvis when he first made the Canes. That they were expecting to send him back to the CHL but his play kept him hanging around and eventually he beat out his competition and won a job. The same could happen anywhere....and there are guys I think that most people have pencilled in that could be moved for other assets if someone like a Mancini or a Berard pushes them out.
 

romba

Registered User
Aug 2, 2005
6,795
4,662
New Jersey
Yes... but also.. this scares me:



Watch #58 on the Bruins. If this wasn't pre-season, Chytil may have had a rough time there.
Yes #58 held up a bit but Chytil was also aware of his presence and got rid of the puck and turned away from so it likely would not have been too bad for him. Even a weaker hit though might cause Chytil issues- the one last year seemed benign but sent him off for months. It is what it is though he can't be a perimeter player and put up points, and unlike Mika Z, Chytil is still hoping for a big(ger) payday- the key is that he skated with his head up which is what he needs to do whenever he heads towards the middle of the ice to try to minimize a big hit.
 

KirkAlbuquerque

#WeNeverGetAGoodCoach
Mar 12, 2014
36,191
43,161
New York
people are really doing the thing where they're ready to conclude kakko is going to be horrible this season and needs to be replaced now? in the first preseason game of the season??

laf looked pretty rough the entire preseason last year and i'm guessing the same people were saying the same things. panarin looked awful in the preseason too...both had pretty good years i'd say. quick looked pretty bad in the preseason...worked out ok.

you can't use 1 game to draw conclusions about people. you absolutely cannot use a damn preseason game. the same applies to chytil or mancini in a positive sense. they were fantastic, and certainly you'd rather see players look great. it means nothing in terms of how they'll play this season though. the mindset and motivation of players during preseason has massive difference...you have a bunch of guys trying to earn spots going all out and trying to make an impression. there's a lot of non-nhl players than can get exposed by talent. there's vets the game is meaningless for and they're just out there to get a sweat in and get some situation reps at game pace. there's vets who have specific things they worked on they're primarily focused on executing in a game environment etc.
Well one conclusion we can draw is that Kakko is still slower than a monkeys grandma, and I don’t think that’s going to change once the regular season starts.
 

Machinehead

HFNYR MVP
Jan 21, 2011
147,859
126,515
NYC
people are really doing the thing where they're ready to conclude kakko is going to be horrible this season and needs to be replaced now? in the first preseason game of the season??

laf looked pretty rough the entire preseason last year and i'm guessing the same people were saying the same things. panarin looked awful in the preseason too...both had pretty good years i'd say. quick looked pretty bad in the preseason...worked out ok.

you can't use 1 game to draw conclusions about people. you absolutely cannot use a damn preseason game. the same applies to chytil or mancini in a positive sense. they were fantastic, and certainly you'd rather see players look great. it means nothing in terms of how they'll play this season though. the mindset and motivation of players during preseason has massive difference...you have a bunch of guys trying to earn spots going all out and trying to make an impression. there's a lot of non-nhl players than can get exposed by talent. there's vets the game is meaningless for and they're just out there to get a sweat in and get some situation reps at game pace. there's vets who have specific things they worked on they're primarily focused on executing in a game environment etc.
I've concluded Kakko is horrible based on the last five regular seasons and a handful of playoffs in there as well.
 

bhamill

Registered User
Sponsor
Apr 16, 2012
4,709
5,859
If Othmann is going to make the NHL this season (doesn't look like it), he will have to be better in his own zone and stop taking dumb penalties.
Only penalty Othmann took last night was a matching major and he drew an additional minor on the fight… but in general you’re right. He has to be drawing dumb penalties, not taking them.
 

TGWL

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jul 28, 2011
16,063
10,771
Only penalty Othmann took last night was a matching major and he drew an additional minor on the fight… but in general you’re right. He has to be drawing dumb penalties, not taking them.
And he got away with 1 or 2. That won't always be the case, they will get called eventually and he will be benched. He would have a longer leash if his play away from the puck was better. Right now it's going to be very short.
 

bhamill

Registered User
Sponsor
Apr 16, 2012
4,709
5,859
And he got away with 1 or 2. That won't always be the case, they will get called eventually and he will be benched.
Just about every player gets away with a couple a game, especially physical players, though I saw nothing blatant that should have been called. He’s an aggressive player. Management wants him that way and penalties come with that. It would be a huge mistake to neuter his game. The important thing is drawing more than you take and not taking any at inopportune times.
 

bl02

Registered User
Jan 13, 2014
33,145
23,590
Yes... but also.. this scares me:



Watch #58 on the Bruins. If this wasn't pre-season, Chytil may have had a rough time there.
Yep I hear you. I was pretty nervous several times that game regarding Chytil and taking some spills.
He even went down hard into the boards.
Considering how he got hurt last time (Practice and against Fast I believe) it doesn't necessarily have to be a hard hit that hurts him.
I know nothing new but he has to play like he did last night to be effective and help the team.
 

kovazub94

Enigmatic
Aug 5, 2010
13,312
8,991
Exactly, I compare the two only stylistically, in no way am I saying he'll turn out like Miller, but again, Miller wasn't supposed to turn into Miller either.
The only similarity between Miller and Othman is that both were selected by the Rangers in the middle of the first round. There's almost nothing stylistically similar between them.
First, JTM even in his early days showed plenty of glimpses of offensive creativity and playmaking - Othmann has very little of this. Second, or adjacent Miller showed pretty good puck-handling and soft hands - again this is not Othmann I've seen. Lastly, Miller hasn't really been an agitating type which is a pretty noticeable trait from Othmann.

P.S. it's not even a style but when JT Miller joined the organization he was already fully physically ready for the grind of the NHL.
 

kovazub94

Enigmatic
Aug 5, 2010
13,312
8,991
.....
Also important to note that he stood out against mostly the level of competition that he's going to be facing this year. It's not a bad thing and its obviously better to look good than to suck but these are things to consider.
....
I don't want to post a "wet blanket" post so I'm to reply in agreement with this part of your post - this was an NHL game only in the name. Mancini played well against largely the same level of competition that he already had a good showing at the end of last season through Pack's playoff run.

Of course it's better than having a bad showing but this should in no way taken as immediate NHL readiness. More generally, relative good performance in these games (or better as compared to other players) does not automatically means that said performance merits a place in the line-up instead of going to Hartford, for example.
 

Clark Kellogg

NYU Film Student
Sponsor
Aug 2, 2013
7,544
9,854
Vermont, USA
Theres no space for Mancini at the moment and getting top pair+ST minutes in Hartford are going to be 1000000x better for him than getting 8-10 with the Rangers.

Also important to note that he stood out against mostly the level of competition that he's going to be facing this year. It's not a bad thing and its obviously better to look good than to suck but these are things to consider.

But theres something there for sure though and he has the size that the FO covets. Might be someone who ends up sliding into the lineup next year after Trouba is moved.

Wish we had a LD version to push Lindgren but that guy is going to have to come from outside of the organization.
Scanlin is a sound hockey player. Could be the perfect stay-at-home partner for Adam Fox.
 

bernmeister

Registered User
Jun 11, 2010
28,614
4,189
Da Big Apple
Scanlin is a sound hockey player. Could be the perfect stay-at-home partner for Adam Fox.
while bold is not a given, it is a reasonable expectation
we should sell high on Lindy now

I am shocked Robertson playing well w/Mancini
roll w/that

try to carry extra D competition betw Scanlin + Harpur will push until Fortescue and our first from this year is ready

growing pains, yes but worth it
take medicine now, everyone ready for POs
 

Shesterkybomb

Registered User
Dec 30, 2016
16,532
17,743
The only similarity between Miller and Othman is that both were selected by the Rangers in the middle of the first round. There's almost nothing stylistically similar between them.
First, JTM even in his early days showed plenty of glimpses of offensive creativity and playmaking - Othmann has very little of this. Second, or adjacent Miller showed pretty good puck-handling and soft hands - again this is not Othmann I've seen. Lastly, Miller hasn't really been an agitating type which is a pretty noticeable trait from Othmann.

P.S. it's not even a style but when JT Miller joined the organization he was already fully physically ready for the grind of the NHL.

Have you ever watched Othmann? I can't even with these takes, it's like Othmann came out of junior b and nobody has ever watch him play until he came to Hartford. He hasn't even entered his "early days" with regards to nhl. Did you watch miller when he came in the league? This also is a weird take, Miller wasn't anywhere near the player he was then, no thought of it ever happening, he was more of a Dubinsky style player than he was the current version. Like it's OK if people never watched Othmann play hockey until last year but don't make that one year paint a very successful career thus far and even then the guy had 50 points in 67 games in Hartford.
 
Last edited:

kovazub94

Enigmatic
Aug 5, 2010
13,312
8,991
Have you ever watched Othmann? I can't even with these takes, it's like Othmann came out of junior b and nobody has ever watch him play until he came to Hartford. He hasn't even entered his "early days" with regards to nhl. Did you watch miller when he came in the league? This also is a weird take, Miller wasn't anywhere near the player he was then, no thought of it ever happening, he was more of a Dubinsky style player than he was the current version. Like it's OK if people never watched Othmann play hockey until last year but don't make that one year paint a very successful career thus far.
Is this what kids call gaslighting?

Yes, I watched Othmann play when he was in juniors and last year in Hartford. Similarly, I had with Miller when he was up and coming prospect. In no way I want to disparage Othmann but there are a lot stylistically closer comparables then these too.
 

NickyFotiu

NYR 2024 Cup Champs!
Sep 29, 2011
15,785
7,527
I'm pretty sure the core of the problem is Kakko believes he's the 9th best player on the ice and then ensures it with play.
This is probably silly but I would like to see KK play with and against almost all prospects. I would like to see if he would step up and try to make things happen.
 

Shesterkybomb

Registered User
Dec 30, 2016
16,532
17,743
Is this what kids call gaslighting?

Yes, I watched Othmann play when he was in juniors and last year in Hartford. Similarly, I had with Miller when he was up and coming prospect. In no way I want to disparage Othmann but there are a lot stylistically closer comparables then these too.
No gaslighting, just confused with peoples opinions on a good player and probably downloaded it all on you but the way people talk about Othmann youd swear he was tanner glass. You should go look at miller's stats and refresh your memory, at this point Othmann is ahead of him in point production. Miller had a ton of starts and stops getting on to our roster, I think most people forget about that.
 

RangersFan1994

Registered User
Aug 20, 2019
17,924
14,622
Othmann needs to play with Chytil next game, Kakko had his chances. Put him on the 4th line to send a message. That scratch should have been a message years ago but it wasn’t. Marcel Hossa 2.0. Mancini looks like a player
 

effen

Registered User
Feb 3, 2018
9,779
9,193
This is probably silly but I would like to see KK play with and against almost all prospects. I would like to see if he would step up and try to make things happen.
It's not - the game yesterday against total scrubs you could see guys like Jimmy Vesey take positioning liberties and be MUCH riskier than they are normally because they're way above those guys. Cuylle looked like a man playing with boys.

Kakko played like he was playing equals, not guys far below his level.

If you can't gear up to dangle on a guy named after a utensil when there's no stakes, I dunno what you're doing professionally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickyFotiu

NickyFotiu

NYR 2024 Cup Champs!
Sep 29, 2011
15,785
7,527
It's not - the game yesterday against total scrubs you could see guys like Jimmy Vesey take positioning liberties and be MUCH riskier than they are normally because they're way above those guys. Cuylle looked like a man playing with boys.

Kakko played like he was playing equals, not guys far below his level.

If you can't gear up to dangle on a guy named after a utensil when there's no stakes, I dunno what you're doing professionally.
I didn't see yesterdays game but that is disappointing to hear. I giew KK as one of a half dozen ways this team can improve. I really hope he comes in to this season with some urgency to raise his career.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad