You said 50% while adding. And now suddenly you forgot the 50% to call him an anchor... Also, it's 5 years. Not 6.
Yorue correct. Sorry about the 6. I dont love capwages little red arrow.
50% is a dream, but that is rare to see that type of retention for more than a one year rental, so I am assuming its more like 10-20% and maybe with a third team helping. So yes, I think we need to assume massively different values if youre trading for a 32yo Zib at $4.25M or $6M or $8.5M.
Ill try for shits quick even though I have no interest in him on the Avs because he wont see PP1 time on the half wall since MacKinnon gets that and obviously Makar is the top guy.
Zib at $8.5M
Girard, Wood, Necas (extended to 8x$whatever) for Zib, Lafreniere, Miller, Schneider
- A lot more going on, but Id want to be paid for taking Zibs full contract and the Avs are trying to win now vs take on picks/prospects. Also needed some money going both ways to even it out. I assume Necas will be very welcomed in the deal, but want to improve our D as well here. Avs can likely get a lot more for an extended Necas elsewhere, but trying to make this work here with NYR.
Zib at $6.5M (20-25% retention)
Girard, Wood for Zib, Miller
- Similarish to the OP, but dont want to move Girard only to have Toews/Makar and nothing else back there. Girard is a perfect middle pairing guy so want another coming back there. Again, NYR is essentially paying us a bit to offload Zib and were gambling he is a 2C that will win now and then whatever after that with his contract.
Zib at $4.25 (50% retention)
Girard, Wood, Colton, and rights to Nelson and Drouin for Zib
- Youre right. $4.25M and I love Zib now, even at 37yo or whatever when it ends. So Colton is the toss in who is signed to a solid deal for 2 more years. I like to think Nelson and Drouin rights, NYR can easily get one or even both to sign on if they have exclusive talking rights now. Signs Nelson to 4-5x$whatever and give Drouin a 1-2 year deal and hope he is healthy and then give him a big deal after that. Maybe some value in the rights to them both or maybe not.