Ernie Russell, C/Rover/RW
- Born 1883
- 5'6, 160 lbs (5'10'' 200 lbs adjusted for era +4/40)
- Member of the HHOF (1965)
- Stanley Cup (1906, 1907, 1908, 1910)
-
ECAHA 1st All-Star Team (1907)
- ECAHA 2nd All-Star Team (1908)
-
Stanley Cup Scoring:
-
1906: 1st on Wanderers, T4th overall
-
1907: 1st on Wanderers, 1st overall
-
1908: 1st on Wanderers, 1st overall
-
1910: 1st on Wanderers, 6th overall (Wanderers played 1 game, Ottawa played 4)
- NHA PIM Leader (1912)
-
184 Goals, 368 PIM in 101 Top-Level Games (assists not recorded most of his career)
-
31 Goals, 51 PIM in 11 Stanley Cup Games
Retro Hart Trophy
(ECAHA) 1907
Retro Art Ross Trophy
(ECAHA) 1907
Retro Conn Smythe Trophy
(ECAHA) 1907 vs Kenora - 2 games - March 23 and 25 (Russell scored a team leading 5 goals, in the 12-8 win)
Retro Conn Smythe Trophy
(ECAHA) 1908 vs Ottawa - 2 games - January 9 and 13 (Russell scored an insane team leading 10 of 22 goals in the 22-4 drubbing. Next closest player had 4)
Retro Conn Smythe Trophy
(NHA) 1910 vs Berlin - 1 game March 12 (Russell scored 4 of 7 goals in single Cup challenge game)
REGULAR SEASON SCORING FINISHES - TEAM - LEAGUE
1905 (CAHL) - 1st On Montreal AAA's - 5th overall
1906 (ECAHA) - 1st On Wanderers - T4th overall (T4th is misleading considering he scored 21 goals in 6 games = 3.5. Whereas Joe Power had 21 in 10 and Bowie 30 in 9, both less per game. Frank McGee was best at 4 GPG)
1907 - 1st On Wanderers - 1st overall - 42 goals in 9 games (Arguably most dominant pre-consolidation year ever, considering he beat Bowie by 4 goals and in 1 fewer game + substantial playoff success)
1908 - 1st on Wanderers - 6th overall
1909 - Didn't player (retired)
1910 (NHA) - 1st on Wanderers - 2nd overall (2nd to Lalonde, surmise to say Russell could be argued as a 1st team if we split Lalonde and Russell between Rover and C. Otherwise he's a clear 2nd team C)
1911 - 1st on Wanderers - 8th overall (again misleading as he had 18 goals in 11 games. Pitre had 19 in 16 games. Lalonde 19 in 16. Cleghorn 20 in 16. Ridpath 23 in 16. Only Kerr and Walsh averaged better GPG than Russell of anyone in top 10 scoring)
1912 - 1st on Wanderers - T2nd overall (Pitre also had 27 in 18 games. considering Pitre was a W, you again could argue that Russell was worthy of at least a 2nd Team AS. Joe Malone was next closest C in scoring at 21 goals in 18 games.)
Notice that Russell was easily the most important offensive player on every team he played on between 1905 and 1912. He was 1st in scoring every year other than 1909 when he retired. Coincidentally the ONLY year the Wanderers failed to win the SC between 1906 and 1910 was the year he didn't play.
1907 was easily one of the most dominant pre consolidation season ever, top to bottom. He was awarded a retro Hart, Art Ross, Rocket Richard, and likely Conn Smythe when you consider he led all scorers in the playoffs for the SC winning Wanderers. You'd be hard pressed to find more than a handful of seasons in NHL/Hockey history that were so dominant.
1910, as shown above should have netted him at least a 2nd team NHA all star nod. Led his team in scoring again, finished 2nd overall to the elite Lalonde, and won yet another SC championship.
1911, was a year he probably would have been an AS had he played 18 games as others did ahead of him in the scoring race. His GPG were better than all but 2 players.
1912, only Skene Ronan has a legitimate case for 1st Team AS nod at C, as he led the league in scoring with 35 goals. No other C was close to Russell in scoring from the C position
Basically, given all the research I've done, stats, and game reports read, I would say that Russell's AS nods would look like following in today's world (this is an educated hypothesis)
1st Team AS - ECHA 1907
2nd Team AS - ECHA 1908
2nd Team AS - NHA 1910 (possibly 1st if you put Lalonde at Rover, which is palatable)
2nd Team AS - NHA 1912 (behind Ronan and ahead of Joe Malone and Marty Walsh for example)
3rd Team AS - NHA 1911 (behind Walsh and Lalonde at C although one could possibly argue him being over Lalonde here as Russell scored 18 goals in just 11 games, whereas Newsy had 19 in 16.)
3rd Team AS - ECHA 1906 (behind Bowie and McGee, although on a per game basis Russell was a better scorer than Bowie)
5th Team AS - CAHL 1905
USING 2ND PLACE IN POINT TOTALS AS A BENCHMARK WE INVESTIGATE RUSSELL'S SCORING PROWESS.
1905 - 57.9 (19 goals is BM)
1906 - 75 (30 goals is BM)
*
1907 - 110 (38 goals in BM)
**
1908 - 75 (28 goals is BM)
1910 - 100 (Russell is BM)
1911 - 54.5 (33 goals is BM)
***
1912 - 100 (Russell and Pitre are BM)
*Russell's 75 in 1906 is misleading because he only played in 6 games vs 9 for Bowie who was the benchmark. Ernie Russell averaged 3.5 goals per game. He scored 21 in 6 contests, whereas Russell Bowie scored 30 in 9, which is 3.33 goals per game. Because seasons were so short, it's much easier to hypothesize a players few missed games production vs somebody over 70 or 80 games. At 9 games Russell would have likely scored at least 30 goals, given his per game average. Now, Frank McGee scored 28 in 7 games, so he was best in the league at 4 GPG. If we give him 2 more games he's at 36, give or take a goal. Harry Smith had 31 in 8 games, and giving him a 9th game puts him at 35.
So if you project 9 games for each of the top scorers, you have McGee leading the league at 36 goals. Smith at 35, Russell at 31 and Bowie at 30. Using Smith as the BM, Russell's score would improve to 88.6 for 1906
**1907 could be underrating the score of 110 for Russell. Bowie is 2nd in scoring with 38 goals, but the 3rd place player (Blair Russell) scored 25. 38 goals is probably too high of a BM here. Something around 31/32 seems more accurate, splitting the difference between 2nd and 3rd. Doing so puts Russell's score at 135.
***1911 again is misleading, just as 1906 was. Every other player in the top 10 scoring played 16 games. Russell played 11 and scored 18 goals at 1.63 per game average. Had he played another 5 games, he likely finishes with 26 goals, putting T3rd place behind Kerr and Walsh. His VsX score then moves up to 78.8
-As it stands on a per game basis the only season where Russell wasn't truly among the best, or best overall, was his first full pro season in 1905, in the CAHL and to a lesser degree 1908
BREAKDOWN OF POSITIONS PLAYED BY RUSSELL PER YEAR
1905 - Seemingly played rover for the Montreal AAA's. Some issues on game day are not available.
1906 - Found multiple game reports listing him as a right wing. Some game reports not available in archives. Predominantly a RW in 1906 by my estimation (likely all year).
1907 - Early part of the year played RW, then converting over to C full time when Lester Patrick moved to cover point full time as shown in quote below on March 26, 1907
1908+ - Almost exclusively at C as far as I can tell but more than a handful of game recaps are not available in google archives.
-So in his first full year with the AAA's in 1905, Russell played the rover spot, which basically went anywhere and everywhere on the ice. 1906, which saw Russell score 3.5 goals per game, seemingly came at RW, and he looked to have played there in December then transitioning over to C sometime in January. After that, he was a C as far as I can tell, full time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Trail Of the Stanley Cup, Vol. 1
Ernie Russell was a small man who probably did not weigh over 140 pounds (SIHR has him at 160)... his size was no problem on the ice. There are many of his ardent fans who compare him with the great Russell Bowie and certainly they had several attributes in common. Ernie was a fast skater and accomplished stickhandler, equally at home playing rover or centre (I found games where he was a LW too!) He was the only player of the era who seriously threatened Bowie as a goal scorer. Russell had the advantage of playing on much stronger teams than Bowie and in consequence was on four Stanley Cup Winners.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Players: The Ultimate A-Z Guide Of Everyone Who Has Ever Played in the NHL
Playing center or rover, Russell was a premier scorer in the early years of the 20th century... he was speedy and shifty...
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Renfrew Millionaires
An accomplished skater & stickhandler
Russell was the star of game 1 of the 1906 Finals when the Wanderers surprised the cocky Ottawas with a 9-1 pasting:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Patricks: Hockey's Royal Family
the defending champions were 2:1 betting favourites, but the Wanderers obviously weren't listening to the neighbourhood bookies. Their fans went wild as Ernie Russell got four goals, Pud Glass got three and Moose Johnson shared a pair with Patrick in the hometown 9-1 victory.
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Trail Of the Stanley Cup, Vol. 1
Ernie Russell figured prominently in the scoring.
Russell was huge against Ottawa in clinching the ECAHA Championship to retain the cup:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Trail Of the Stanley Cup, Vol. 1
Ottawa's hopes for a championship rested on defeating the Wanderers in their return match at the capital on March 2nd... there seemed little doubt as to the outcome after play got started. The smooth skating Patrick and Johnson were all over the Senators. Russell played a magnificent game, scoring five goals...
He was the only Wanderer who could score when Tommy Phillips' Thistles came to whisk away the cup. He scored both of their goals in a 4-2 defeat and then two goals in game 2, an 8-6 defeat:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Trail Of the Stanley Cup, Vol. 1
Patrick, Russell, and Johnson were the best for the Wanderers.
However, when it was time to take the cup back, Ernie delivered the goods and the team won this time, taking game one 7-2 on the strength of Russell's four goals, before losing game two 6-5 but still winning the series:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Trail Of the Stanley Cup, Vol. 1
The super sniper Ernie Russell scored four.
Russell was again the star in the 1908 cup defense against the Ottawa Vics, scoring 10 of the team's 22 goals over 2 games.:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Trail Of the Stanley Cup, Vol. 1
Art Ross and Ernie Russell starred for the Redbands.
Russell also spoiled the Renfrew Millionaires' anticipated debut in 1910:
Originally Posted by The Patricks: Hockey's Royal Family
They were bombed 7-2 as the Wandrers' big scoring machine, Ernie Russell, ripped four shots in, three of them in the game's opening minutes.
That Scappy Little Bugger...
I think Russell was a scrappy player with a good 4th line mentality. Thanks to there being very little detail about his play to validate this, I present to you a list of drafted forwards born within 4 years of Ernie Russell (1879-1887) - Ernie put up more PIMs per game than any of them. (Note that only Lalonde, Bowie, and Tommy Smith were top-5 in goals in their league more often among this generation! - Smith's totals include three times in slightly lesser leagues: OPHL and IHL.)
ONLY NEWSY LALONDE AND TOMMY SMITH FINISHED IN THE TOP 5 IN GOAL SCORING MORE TIMES THAN RUSSELL FOR PLAYERS BORN BETWEEN 1879 AND 1887. IT'S AN ELITE GROUP OF HOCKEY PLAYERS.
OF ANY PLAYER ON THE LIST BELOW WITH 100+ GAMES PLAYED, NOBODY HAS A HIGHER GOALS PER GAME AVERAGE THAN ERNIE RUSSELL AT 1.92
Name | DOB | GP | G | PIM | G/GP | PIM/GP | GP w/PIM* | Top-5s
Name | DOB | GP | G | PIM | G/GP | PIM/GP | GP w/PIM* |
Top-5s in Goals
Ernie Russell
| 1883 | 112 | 215 | 419 | 1.92 | 3.74 | |
6
Bruce Stuart | 1881 | 104 | 111 | 280 | 1.07 | 3.33 | 84 | 3
Harry Smith | 1883 | 65 | 150 | 211 | 2.31 | 3.25 | | 4
Newsy Lalonde | 1887 | 254 | 329 | 769 | 1.30 | 3.03 | | 11
Tommy Phillips | 1883 | 45 | 71 | 100 | 1.58 | 2.56 | 39 | 1
Marty Walsh | 1884 | 75 | 167 | 181 | 2.23 | 2.41 | | 4
Pud Glass | 1884 | 103 | 109 | 221 | 1.06 | 2.15 | | 0
Tom Dunderdale | 1887 | 289 | 226 | 527 | 0.78 | 1.82 | | 5
Didier Pitre | 1883 | 239 | 267 | 433 | 1.12 | 1.81 | | 6
Tommy Smith | 1886 | 175 | 274 | 288 | 1.57 | 1.65 | | 7
Cyclone Taylor | 1885 | 228 | 246 | 355 | 1.08 | 1.56 | | 4
Russell Bowie | 1880 | 82 | 249 | 43 | 3.04 | 1.39 | 31 | 10
Frank McGee | 1882 | 41 | 135 | 56 | 3.29 | 1.37 | | 4
Blair Russell | 1881 | 69 | 109 | 68 | 1.58 | 1.36 | 50 | 5
Herb Jordan | 1884 | 61 | 146 | 19 | 2.39 | 0.31 | | 4
* Some players had seasons where PIMs were not recorded; to avoid skewing results, their PIMs are divided only by the number of games they played in seasons where PIMs were recorded. This only counts top-level hockey: NHA, PCHA, St-Cup, ECAHA, ECHA, OPHL, CAHL, FAHL, IHL.
* It may be said that Ernie Russell's "generation" is truly the players born from 1879-1884, with Russell right on the tail end of that generation, but that would be too subjective and I decided to use an objective 9-year range with his birth year right in the middle to define his generation.
RUSSELL'S STANLEY CUP SCORING DOMINANCE
According to The Trail Of the Stanley Cup, here are the playoff and cup final goals leaders through 1926:
Name|GP|G
Frank McGee|22|63
Frank Foyston|47|37
Alf Smith|22|36
Ernie Russell
|
11
|
31
Newsy Lalonde|29|27
Tom Phillips|16|27
Harry Westwick|24|26
Marty Walsh|8|25
Ernie Johnson|21|23
Joe Malone|15|23
Pud Glass|16|23
Harry Smith|7|21
But, not all cup games are created equal. Some players played in easy Stanley Cup matches, including Russell. Let's look at the leaders as apples-to-apples, three different ways. First, here are these leaders with "easy" matches removed:
Name|GP|G
Frank Foyston|47|37
Newsy Lalonde|29|27
Frank McGee|14|26
Tom Phillips|14|23
Ernie Russell
|
8
|
18
Ernie Johnson|16|18
Alf Smith|14|14
Harry Smith|5|13
Pud Glass|11|13
Harry Westwick|16|11
Joe Malone|12|9
Marty Walsh|3|7
Russell is one of only three on this list who averaged over 2 GPG in the "legitimate" matches, the others being Harry Smith and Marty Walsh, who combined for 8 "legitimate" matches.
Now let's look at only the Wanderer forwards during the years in which they played cup games (1906-1910) since the core of the team stayed mostly the same:
Name|GP|G
Ernie Russell
|
11
|
31
Pud Glass|16|23
Ernie Johnson|16|19
Lester Patrick|8|11
***** *********|7|5
But of course, some of those were the easy, lopsided games. Let's look at these Wanderers forwards based on just the "legitimate" matches:
Name|GP|G
Ernie Russell
|
8
|
18
Pud Glass|11|13
Ernie Johnson|11|13
Lester Patrick|6|7
***** *********|5|4
So not only did Russell carry the offensive load for this dynasty, but he also relied very little on lopsided matches to boost his totals.
Ernie Russell evidence playing on wing (for most of 1906, early part of 2007)
Originally Posted by The Montreal Gazette: March 3, 1906:
Blatchford is not yet in shape to play, but Lester Patrick is, and he will be out in the rover position, Ernie Russell leaving centre for the wing.
Originally Posted by The Montreal Gazette: December 27, 1906:
Russell.....R. Wing
Lester Patrick and Russell were the most consistent players throughout, their work being evident in the first half as well as in the second.
New Glasgow was a man short when Russell moved into the limelight and scored goal three.
Lester Patrick moved down the ice in nice style and handed the puck to Russell, who slipped it past Morrison.
Originally Posted by The Montreal Gazette: February 15, 1906:
Wanderers win 6-2 over Montreal
Russell.......Right wing
Summary:--
2.....Wanderers....Russell.......3.00
5.....Wanderers....Russell.......2.00
Originally Posted by The Montreal Gazette: March 12. 1906
Russell......Right......
SUMMARY.
1. Wanderers....Russell....6.55
2. Wanderers....Russell....10.05
3. Wanderers....Russell....6.00
SECOND HALF.
6. Wanderers....Russell....4.55
8. Wanderers....Russell....2.32
13. Wanderers...Russell... .22
Russell Scores 4 Goals against Hugh Lehman in Stanley Cup Championship at RW
Originally Posted by Wikipedia
NHA league champions take over Stanley Cup[edit]
The Wanderers having won the O'Brien trophy won regular season championship of the NHA and took possession of the Cup from Ottawa. They had a challenge from Berlin, champions of the Ontario Professional Hockey League and easily defeated them. For 1910, there would be two Stanley Cup holders, Ottawa until March, and Montreal for the rest of the year.
§Wanderers vs. Berlin[edit]
March 12
Berlin 3 at Wanderers 7
Hugh Lehman, Capt. G William "Riley" Hern|
Albert Seibert 1 P Jack Marshall|
Harvey Corbeau 1 CP Ernie Johnson|
E. "Toad" Edmunds RO Frank "Pud" Glass, Capt.|
Roy Anderson C Harry Hyland 3|
Ezra Dumart
RW Ernie Russell 4|
Oren Frood 1 LW Jimmy Gardner|
How did Ernie Russell stack up to Russell Bowie once he made his entrance into the ECAHA from 1905-08?
1905-06:
Name|GP|G
Ernie Russell
|6|21
Russell Bowie|9|30
1906-07:
Name|GP|G
Ernie Russell
|9|43
Russell Bowie|10|39
Ernie Russell 2 year totals = 64 goals in 15 =
4.3 GPG
Russell Bowie 2 year totals = 69 goals in 19 =
3.6 GPG
1907-08:
Name|GP|G
Ernie Russell
|9|20
Russell Bowie|10|31
Ernie Russell 3 year totals = 84 Goals in 24 games =
3.5 GPG
Russell Bowie 3 year totals = 100 in 29 games =
3.44 GPG
So from a
goal scoring standpoint there is virtually no difference. The interesting thing to note is
Russell was producing at the same clip as Bowie even though he was aged 22-24 during this 3 year stretch when they shared the same league whereas Bowie was 25-27, a more experienced/established player in his prime years.
Ernie Russell outscores Russell Bowie 4 goals to 1 in head to head match up. February 6, 1908
http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19080206&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Russell outscores Bowie 2 goals to 1 in head to head match up. February 25, 1905 (as Rover which he played most of 1905)
http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19050228&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
How did Ernie Russell stack up against Newsy Lalonde in NHA goal scoring when their careers overlapped?
NHA career goals:
Name|GP|G
Ernie Russell
|69|89
Newsy Lalonde|104|150
Russell totals = 1.29 GPG
Lalonde totals = 1.44 GPG
Not a shabby comparison on total numbers, although if you break it down into 3 year peak goal scoring it tightens up some. Russell's career was winding down by his 3rd NHA season, while Lalonde was heating up.
Russell's best 3 year goal scoring totals = 80 in 42 = 1.9 GPG
Lalonde's best 3 year goal scoring totals = 90 in 44 = 2.05 GPG
BETWEEN THE 1905-06 AND 1911-12 SEASONS NOBODY SCORED MORE GOALS PER GAME THAN ERNIE RUSSELL IN THE ECHA/NHA/ETC. TOMMY SMITH SCORED 194 GOALS BETWEEN 1906-07 AND 1911-12 BUT DID SO IN 95 GAMES, IN LEAGUES LIKE THE IHL/WPHL/OPHL/MPHL.
Name|GP|G
Ernie Russell
|
66
|
164
Marty Walsh|62|141
Tommy Smith|95|194
Newsy Lalonde|81|176
*Walsh seasons between 1907-08 and 1911-12. He played 2 games in CHA in 1909, 5 total seasons.
**Smith seasons between 1906-07 and 1912-13. Played in IHL, WPHL, OPHL and MPHL, 6 total seasons.
***Lalonde between 1906 (IHL) and 1911-12 (PCHA) with seasons in the OPHL and NHA mixed in, 6 total seasons
FINAL THOUGHTS:
- If Bowie consistently goes in the top 250, why does Ernie Russell go in the 5 to 600's?
- Bowie played in leagues (as shown below with examples) that did not have the depth of talent the NHA did beyond 1910.
- Who was competing against Bowie in 1900-01-02 etc?[/B] Bruce Stuart? Blair Russel? Harry Westwick? ATD regulars but hardly elite competition in the grand scheme.
[*]In the NHA days you had Lalonde, Nighbor, Malone, Lester Patrick, Didier Pitre, Sprauge/Odie Cleghorn. Marty Walsh and Jack Darragh are similar drafted player to the CAHL players mentioned above. Goalies like Georges Vezina, Clint Benedict, Percy Leseaur and Riley Hern blow anything the CAHL had out of the water.
[*]Russell and Bowie overlapped together in the same leagues between 05-06 and 07-08, and Russell scored 84 goals in 24 games = 3.5 goals per game vs 3.45 goals per game by Bowie who scored 100 in 29 games.
[*]Consider the sheer dominance of Russell in the postseason for Montreal with 33 goals over 11 games and 27 in 9 Stanley Cup finals games. Russell was the offensive star and heavy lifter of the Wanderers that won the Stanley Cup in 1906, 1907, 1908, and 1910
[*]I wonder if we are underrating Ernie Russell by a decent margin
[*]How much value do we put on Bowie's dominance in the CAHL? I mean, once Ernie Russell showed up and they played in the same league (ECAHA) there clearly wasn't a gap by my estimation at least as goal scorers.
[*]How do we look at Russell's first 3 years of nearly 2 goals per game in the NHA (professional league) as his career was winding down into his late 20's relative to Bowie's 2.73 GPA at the turn of the century and very early 1900's in the CAHL against inferior (to some degree) competition.
[*]I think the moral of the story is that Bowie deserves to go somewhere in the mid to late 200's (give or take), based on his sheer dominance throughout his career, but we are greatly under rating players like Ernie Russell if they are being taken in the 5 or even 600's (like 2015 ATD). I simply don't see the massive gap when pointing out the numbers and accolades above. Also remember that you have to take into account Russell's sterling postseason record as a dominant scorer. Rarely was there a Stanley Cup game where Russell didn't completely own the competition.
NEWSPAPER CLIPPINGS AND STORIES OF IMPORTANCE:
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=CH8FAAAAIBAJ&pg=6575,5613445&hl=en
On the Wanderer side Ernie Russell rested and Cecil Blatchford took his place, playing right wing.
Ernie Russell was elected Captain for the 1908 season (which Montreal would again defend the SC crown)
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=HX8FAAAAIBAJ&pg=2459,4070101&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Oct 15 1907
RUSSELL CAPTAIN:
The annual general meeting of the Wanderer Hockey Club was held at the Windsor last night, but beyond the adoption of reports and the election of officers there was little or no buisness transacted and owing to the fact thet opening of the hockey season is still a long way off, there were no announcements of importance to be made. Ernie Russell, centre forward on the champion team, was elected captain.
Contemporary praise for Russell. Notice 3 of the 4 names are on the Pirates 2016 ATD team
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=XKgFAAAAIBAJ&pg=6915,1865184&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Jan 16 1934
Gardner still follows the game with keen enthusiasm. Of those he played against, rates, Ernie Russell, of the Wanderers, Russell Bowie, of Victorias, Frank McGee, of Ottawa's Silver Seven and Art Farrell, of Shamrocks among the best he ever saw. Georges Vezina he picks as the greatest goaltending of all time. Cyclone Taylor was the fastest player that ever donned skates.
Russell showing consistent effort and passing ability
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=CH8FAAAAIBAJ&pg=3587,5404865&hl=en
Montreal Gazette 27 1906
Lester Patrick and Ernie Russell were the most consistent players throughout, their work being evident in the first half as well as in the second.
Ernie Russell finally closed affairs by sailing along and trasferring the puck to Glass, the latter netting the disc after a scuffle.
Lester Patrick moved down the ice in nice style and handed the puck to Russell, who slipped it past Morrison.
Russell scoring, passing, fighting and defensive ability stealing puck
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19110303&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Mar 3 1911
Russell, who repeated his fine playing against Canadians, divided the forward line honors with Hyland, and led in the scoring with four shots in the cage.
Glass snapped one in from Russell when right up on the nets, but it was called back as the pass was regarded offside by Brenan.
...but it was not until Ridpath returned that they got one through Lesueur. Johnston and Russell did the trick on the nicest combination work, Russell taking the shot.
Ottawa were still a man shy when Russell got another on a pass from Smaill, who carried the puck up the side from half-way down the rink.
Lake was sent to the side for soaking Russell, who was boring in all the time on the Ottawa nets.
Wanderers opened the scoring in the third period. Russell stole the puck from Lake, who had just started a run, and scored with a short shot.
Russell and Currie were sent to the side for five minutes after they cracked each other with their sticks. Ottawa's left wing cross-checked the Wanderer man, and he tried to retaliate.
Russell starring vs Cyclone Taylors's Renfrew's team
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19110308&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Mar 8 1911
Taylor again did great work for the Renfrew team, while Ross and Russell starred for the visitors.
Russell combination work
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19130109&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Jan 9 1913
Both teams checked back after going up with the play, both indulging in perhaps more combination work that has been seen in any of the previous games here.
From the face off Russell and Hyland combined, Russell evening matters up again.
Clear evidence that Russell was a hard worker and after puck always.
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19050112&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Jan 12 1905
The Montreal forward line showed improvement since the opening game (cannot make out next 2 words) and the busiest worker of the lot was Russell, who was always after the puck.
Russell singled out for his play
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19050228&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Feb 28 1905
There was nothing flukey about the results, as Montreal certainly won on its merits. Their forwards out-skated and out played the Vic forwards at every point, and the defence was steadier (blank) better and blocked more effectively.
Montreal gave a nice exhibition of clean, fast hockey, Russell and Sargent in particular showing up well.
Fights and Russell being singled out for playing very well
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19050309&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Mar 9 1905
The feature which marked the final quarter was a carnival of rough work, which increased in intensity as the minutes went by, finally ending, a few seconds before the close of layer, with a scrap between Russell and Foulis. As Foulis went down the ice with the puck, Russell struck him across the shins. Foulis struck back and then Russell used his fists.
The suddenly aroused interest dropped when Russell made it five to three a minute before time expired.
The Montreal men won the contest on their merit, the forwards showing more cohesion in their play, out skating their opponents and outpointing them when it came to close work in on the nets. Russell in particular played a good game throughout.
Evidence of passing ability by Russell as well as hard work throughout game
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19070307&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Mar 7 1907
Relief came to the Irishmen when McCarthy got half way down the ice with the rubber, but Glass robbed him, and coming down, collided heavily with Mulcair, the latter having to retire for repairs, Patrick going off to even up matters.
On resumption, Russell secured and passing to Johnston, the latter flashed it past Currie.
Russell, who scored 8 goals during the match, was the only man in the Wanderer line-up who worked at all in this half, and seemed bent on running up a big total. Some of his combination runs with Blachford were quite worthy of their reputation
.
Great scouting report talking about Russell's ability to stick handle and shoot and an elite level
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19070326&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Mar 26 1907
The strength of Wanderers was vastly increased by the move; it gave the team the fastest defence in the league and at the same time allowed Russell to get back to his old position at centre, giving him the opportunities to score, which he has turned to such good account in all the intervening matches.
Ernie Russell, the centre, for all that he is the smallest player on the team, has come pretty close to triple honors in Canada's three great sports-lacrosse, hockey and football. His hockey prowess is an affair of today; in football he is a half-back on the Montreal team, which won the Quebec championship and slayed off the Dominion honors last autumn; in lacrosse he was a member of Montreal's senior twelve in 1905 and would have had a place last year had he cared to play. As it was, he kept out on account of th emuddle in the professional and amaetur question. Russell got his start with Sterling Juniors, a team with which a brother of his played this past season.
He is one of the great scorers of the game today; his manipulation of the disc is lightning fast, and his shots are accurate and baffling.
Stanley Cup Dominance
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=EZkFAAAAIBAJ&pg=6919,1424103&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Mar 10 1934
Glass played centre for Wanderers and in the famous ECHA title, when the local six beat the capital team 8-2, only to see the Ottawans tie up the round on home ice, Glass shared the honors with Ernie Russell by scoring three goals.
Stanley Cup Final Dominance
ECAHA Playoff
As the season produced a tie for the season championship, the defending champion Ottawas and Wanderers played a two-game playoff, with the winner being awarded the Stanley Cup. The series took place on March 14 in Montreal and March 17 in Ottawa. The Wanderers would win the series 9–1, 3–9 (12–10) in dramatic fashion..
Game one
Ottawa was installed as 2–1 betting favourites, but the Wanderers upset the bookies.[2] In the first game in Montreal, the Wanderers dominated Ottawa, as Ernie Russell got four goals, Frank Glass got three and Moose Johnson would get two for a 9–1 victory.
Evidence of Russell on the Wing
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19060314&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazettte Mar 14 1906
Unless a change is decided upon at the last moment, the Wanderers line-up will be the same as on Saturday last against Shamrocks, that is, Menard, Strachan and Kennedy on defencel Glass and Patrick in centre ice, and Johnson and Russell on the wings.
Stanley Cup dominance
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Stanley_Cup_challenge_games#1906.E2.80.9307
Although the Montreal Wanderers won the 1908 ECAHA title by finishing the season with an 8–2 record, they played in three Cup challenges that season. In January, they defeated the 1907 FAHL champion Ottawa Victorias, 22–4, in a two-game total goals series. Ernie Russell scored 10 goals as he led the Wanderers to 9–3 and 13–1 victories
Great bio on Russell. It compares him to Nels Stewart due to being the most feared goal scorer in the hockey world (along with Bowie). As you will see wit other newspaper clippings, it does seem that Russell started loafing more AFTER he came back out of retirement for the 1910 season. Seems like he drifted more from 1910 onward, but I found multiple papers stating he was a hard worker and very active player all over the ice prior to this time.
https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=Fr8DH2VBP9sC&dat=19340110&printsec=frontpage&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Jan 10 1934
Turning Back Hockey's Pages by D.A.L MacDonald
Russell played on all four of the Stanley Cup Wanderer teams and consistently figured among the leading scorers of the ECHA and its successor the NHA. In 1907, Russell led all scorers with 43 goals, beating out his great rival, Russell Bowie, of Victorias, by five points. In 1910, after a year in retirement, Russell finished second to Newsy Lalonde in the NHA scoring list with 32 goals.
Russell had a championship career. In 1904 he played with the Sterling juniors, the team which won the Dominion title by defeating Eddie Gerard's famous Lansdowne sextette. In 1905 he joined the Montreal AAA team and then followed his career with Wanderers, a team that captured the Stanley Cup three straight years and then regained the trophy in 1910. Russell retired in 1909 to devote all his time to business, but was finally coaxed out of retirement to return for one season.
It is significant that over a period of five seasons, the only year in which the Wanderers failed to annex the trophy, Russell was not with them.
Russell had the distinction once of scoring four goals in a Stanley Cup final. In 1907 when Winnipeg came east in search of the famous trophy, bolstered two great stars of the Ottawa Senators, Alf Smith and Rat Westwick, the Red Band won both games and Russell scored 4 times in one contest. In the famous series with Ottawa for the ECHA championship in 1906 Wanderers defeated the team from the capital, 9-1 and Russell got four goals.
Ernie Russell was one of the forerunners of the Nels Stewart style for no more accurate shot from close in ever was seen in hockey. He had an uncanny ability to loaf offsides, particularly in his later days, and along with Bowie was the most feared sniper in the major league. Ernie was a right handed shot.
Russell's championship career was not confined to hockey. In 1907 he played on the backfield of the Dominion championship MAAA football team.
Russell is a keen follower of present day hockey and is a regular patron at the Maroon games. However, he laments somewhat the passing of the old days of stickhandling, a feature of hockey that has all but disappeared.
More evidence that Russell was a very tough/aggressive player
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=QikDAAAAIBAJ&pg=4493,2611725&hl=en
Toronto World Mar 8 1912
While Wanderers are apparently the worst offenders, their superior position is very largely due to Ernie Russell, the redoubtable little centre.
He was also the only player in the league to reach the limit of five major fouls and as each new foul calls for a penalty of $5 heavier than the last he paid in for his major fouls the substantial sum of $75. His minor fouls cost him $35 more.
Russell aggressive tactics and support among fanbase
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AAIBAJ&sjid=1dgFAAAAIBAJ&pg=6569,563475&hl=en
Ottawa Citizen Jan 10 1908
Wanderers won on their merits, the speed of Ross, Hooper, Johnston, combined with the aggressive tactics of Russell, Glass and Smaill being to much for the Federal champions.
Supporters of the champions reserved a special amount of applause for Ernie Russell.
From a scramble behind the Vics nets Smaill snapped the rubber out to Russell who slammed in another.
Up and down play followed until Ryan returned. Hooper going off for cross checking Ross, Russell dodged in for the next giving Wanderers stock another boost.
Russell fighting and assisting/passing reference in legendary SC game vs Ottawa Silver Seven
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=A38FAAAAIBAJ&pg=4500,1464790&hl=en
Montreal Gazette Mar 19 1906
Ernie Russell was sent to the dungeon for mixing in with Smith.
Ottawa made some gailant efforts to drive back their rivals, now playing with more vim, but the other chaps had another taste of victory and were not to be denied. They swept Ottawa away in a snappy rush, the puck going to Kennedy to Russell to Patrick, and the latter notched another goal, making the score nine to three, and placing the Wanderer two to the good on the series.
Ernie Russell was such a threat that it took Frank AND Lester Patrick to shadow him. But he seemingly still played good hockey despite the added attention and this obviously would create space for others.
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AAIBAJ&sjid=N9kFAAAAIBAJ&pg=6398,371800&hl=en
Ottawa Citizen Feb 25 1910
Ernie Russell was so closely covered on the line that he did not get a goal, but at the same time he was there with the good work at all times, commanding the attention of Frank and Lester Patrick from beginning to end.
https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=YDsDAAAAIBAJ&pg=3722,4232857&hl=en
The Evening Telegram
How the Teams Line Up
r. wing..............Russell