I'd just keep it the way it is right now...
Give them the point. It's still better than the tie.
I don't like the "bonus points" for a loss in overtime or a win in the shootout. It created an unbalanced ranking system. I think the system should be banalanced because any "Bonus point" makes a team appear stronger or weaker than they actually are in the standings.
If you argue for no ties, fine, but I don't think any team should get a "bonus" point for making it to overtime, nor should any team get a "bonus point" for the shootout. The weighing of regulation, overtime, and shootout wins need balance out shootout, overtime, and regulation losses--right now they don't. in the season series vs. Chicago and St. Louis last year, they appaered tied in points with 6, even though 2 of the Blues 3 wins came via the shootout while Chicago won their 2 wins in regulation.
IMHO 2 wins in regulation beats 1 win in regulation and 2 skills competition tiebreakers.