Welcome!
Personally, I'm inclined to agree with
@SUX2BU -- Adam Lowry is the team captain, born in St. Louis, and very solid player. If he scored more and played in a bigger market he'd be a perennial Selke contender IMO.
That said, can't go wrong with either of Scheifele or Connor. I agree with TSN's analysis recently where they suggested Connor may be the most underrated player in the league and Bruce Boudreau said if he played in a market like New York, Chicago, LA, etc. he'd be considered a super star. He can always be counted on to score.
I'd be more inclined towards Scheifele though as the Jets' first ever draft pick and a guy who has truly committed to Winnipeg when I think many others of his calibre would have sought after the bigger markets.