Playoff hockey is the best (or was) because the violence ramped up to another level while the stakes ramped up as well. 5-4 or 1-0: I don't care as long as there are scoring chances and there is hitting and hatred.
We've basically lost the hatred in the regular season which is why it is such a big deal when we get a taste of what it used to be like. The Caps visiting NY after the Wilson/Panarin thing comes to mind. Am I or a lot of others tuning in to that game if it wasn't a powder keg to begin with? Absolutely not.
The combo of extreme skill and extreme violence set hockey apart from other sports: even football. Playing it and being a huge fan also set you apart, at least in many parts of the US, as it is much more of a foreign experience here than basketball, baseball etc.
I didn't miss a Sunday of NFL this season, including watching on my phone to my Wife's dismay while on a lounger on the sand in Cabo. Fantasy Football helps, sure, but football being less violent than "the old days" doesn't mean that it still doesn't deliver in that regard as every play involves five huge dudes on each side crashing into one another.
Subbing in Nick Shore for Rob Ray is not a win and I don't care if the former is a better hockey player: this is still the entertainment business. The NHL used to scratch every itch from the cerebral to the animalistic but that is mostly gone. We can talk about how much more skill there is now, but it doesn't impress me as much when there is far less worry about having your head taken off going across the middle or when any player in the league (except for anyone on the Kings) can easily stand in front of the net without losing a kidney.
@Herby I feel like the Zmolek mentioned was a direct shot at me. How dare you. You did list those playoff stats but didn't touch on the era when the Kings finally made the playoffs and then had the great three year run. While some of it has to do with the best era in Kings history, I do feel like there was a nice sweet spot there in the late 2000's through 2016 or so where you didn't have as many Rob Ray types--but you had more of them than now--but the game was still nastier than today and you didn't get so much clutch and grab. I mean, I think Brown got a diving minor when Mike Smith took the axe to the back of his leg. That's a match and a suspension today.