Who didn't see this coming for the Caps? Every year it's the same story for that team. I went to grad school in D.C. and it was funny seeing my classmates who were Caps fans getting their hopes up in 2010, only to get eliminated in the first round against Montreal.
The Caps have finished 1st in their Conference six different times with two Presidents' Trophies, and in every single one of those seasons have not advanced past the second round. The last time the Capitals even reached the Conference Finals was in '98, when they got swept by Detroit in the Cup Final.
This is when you really start to question the leadership on that team. They're on their third coach since Boudreau left (Dale Hunter, Adam Oates, Barry Trotz). That team seems to be built on only having regular season success and that's it. They never get hot during the playoffs, they save their hot streaks for the regular season.