Speculation: Armchair GM Thread III: Post Deadline, Now with more armchairing

Status
Not open for further replies.

Johnny Hoxville

The Return of a Legend
Jul 15, 2006
37,560
9,364
Calgary
Connor is only a year younger and doesn't match up against Ehlers in 90% of areas you can compare them in.

Nothing about Connor suggests he's on the verge of superstardom.

Everything except his game does. He’s bigger than Ehlers, a better skater (which is saying something) and has a much better shot. Jets fans also value Connor more.
 

FerklundCGY

Registered User
Jul 3, 2017
1,897
1,975
Everything except his game does. He’s bigger than Ehlers, a better skater (which is saying something) and has a much better shot. Jets fans also value Connor more.

1) He's 1" and 10lbs bigger. Big whoop. Not like he uses it to his advantage

2) Being a better skater than an already elite skater is great, but he doesn't translate that skating into extra scoring chances or offense, despite playing with the big guns.

3) his shot might be "much better", but yet Ehlers 5v5 G/60 (1.01) is higher than Connor's (.97) since he entered the NHL full time in 2017-18.

4) everybody knows that others fans favor certain players over others for whatever reasons despite there being no evidence to support their claims. Even with us Flames fans, people think the ones who view Tkachuk as our best forward over Gaudreau are crazy and vice-versa. Saying "x fans value x player more" is a terrible argument.
 

Johnny Hoxville

The Return of a Legend
Jul 15, 2006
37,560
9,364
Calgary
1) He's 1" and 10lbs bigger. Big whoop. Not like he uses it to his advantage

2) Being a better skater than an already elite skater is great, but he doesn't translate that skating into extra scoring chances or offense, despite playing with the big guns.

3) his shot might be "much better", but yet Ehlers 5v5 G/60 (1.01) is higher than Connor's (.97) since he entered the NHL full time in 2017-18.

4) everybody knows that others fans favor certain players over others for whatever reasons despite there being no evidence to support their claims. Even with us Flames fans, people think the ones who view Tkachuk as our best forward over Gaudreau are crazy and vice-versa. Saying "x fans value x player more" is a terrible argument.

Yeah Connor just has elite upside, Ehlers I don’t think does. I’ve watched the Jets lots especially last season, Connor stands out. Ehlers while he does dazzle at times by going end to end, is a great skater and puck handler, lacks finish and elite offensive upside that Connor has. I think Connor is a much better player and I’ll be happy to revisit this after this season ends.
 

Volica

Papa Shango
May 15, 2012
21,726
11,430
Hmmm James Neal -3 tonight in a 6-1 loss to the Canucks. I know, it's only pre-season but that doesn't look good on paper.

The Real Deal is what the Real Deal is.
Oil fans are in for a rude awakening when they thought they were getting an actual asset or player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boomstick

Rubi

Photographer
Sponsor
Jan 9, 2009
16,399
10,871
God's country just outside of Calgary
Hmmm James Neal -3 tonight in a 6-1 loss to the Canucks. I know, it's only pre-season but that doesn't look good on paper.
Didn't watch the game but Neal finished the night with the 3rd highest fwd TOI at 16:49 with a +/- of -3 with 1 SOG and 2 PIM and Zero goals and Zero assists.
The funny part is in their GDT how many HFOil fans are carrying on how great he looks, how great his shot is, and how they really put one over on the Flames (to paraphrase).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boomstick

JPeeper

Registered User
Jan 4, 2015
12,207
9,645
Neal looked like he did last year, skating around the ice. He is a better skater than Lucic, but at least Lucic looks like he is trying out there and wants to contribute.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boomstick

DFF

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
22,440
6,665
I expect we shall see a large number of cuts today.
Calgary has 53 players remaining at training camp (6x goalies, 16x defensemen, 31x forwards)


Probably no surprise...team has no real roster or cap space.

Up front Dube or Quinne may get a spot. Jankowski should be gone but he wont.
On defense, which of Kylington, Stone, MacDonald or Davidson gets the 6th and 7th spot?
On goalie, Gillies earned the number 1 spot....if we are tanking for Lafreniere/Byfield
 
  • Like
Reactions: super6646

Lunatik

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Oct 12, 2012
57,828
9,861
I expect we shall see a large number of cuts today.
Calgary has 53 players remaining at training camp (6x goalies, 16x defensemen, 31x forwards)
When does Stockton's camp start? Because most cuts will come maybe 2-3 days prior to that.
 

super6646

Registered User
Apr 16, 2018
18,279
16,432
Calgary
Probably no surprise...team has no real roster or cap space.

Up front Dube or Quinne may get a spot. Jankowski should be gone but he wont.
On defense, which of Kylington, Stone, MacDonald or Davidson gets the 6th and 7th spot?
On goalie, Gillies earned the number 1 spot....yeah right.

Sure he has... in the ECHL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DFF

Rubi

Photographer
Sponsor
Jan 9, 2009
16,399
10,871
God's country just outside of Calgary
Wouldn't surprise me to see the goalies cut to 2 today in order to give Talbot and Rittich as much work as possible to get ready for the regular season. Playing anyone else would be foolish and if you're not going to play them why keep them.
 

Lunatik

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Oct 12, 2012
57,828
9,861
First preseason game is in 6 days so I expect training camp to be up and running by Monday if it isn't already.
They only play 2 preseason games
So yeah the big cuts could be happening. They always only play 2 preseason games as most players have had camps with NHL teams.

Anything lower than ECHL? Not sure that its fair that Nick Schneider loses his #1 spot to Gillies.
Gillies is not eligible to be sent to the ECHL because he's not on an ELC, if you are going to be continually negative about him, at least say things that makes sense.
 

Rubi

Photographer
Sponsor
Jan 9, 2009
16,399
10,871
God's country just outside of Calgary
So yeah the big cuts could be happening. They always only play 2 preseason games as most players have had camps with NHL teams.

Gillies is not eligible to be sent to the ECHL because he's not on an ELC, if you are going to be continually negative about him, at least say things that makes sense.
I was making a joke.... sheesh. Lighten up okay?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad