i’m higher on debrusk than most and i really like jared mccann but how does this even move the needle?
our farm system is depleted and we’re missing high end talent. werenski’s a ticking clock. how are they not better off long term just taking a haul for werenski at this point
We don't have the real prospect rankings until this board goes through voting in a couple months, but in lieu of that, here is how Scott Wheeler ranks the current CBJ prospects (17th as a group in the entire league):
1) Jackson Smith - going back to college for '26-'27
2) Pyotr Andreyanov - staying in Russia until...2030?
3) Cayden Lindstrom - going back to college for '26-'27 (you can see the Lindstrom thread for the bust or not debate)
4) Sergei Ivanov - not (?) coming to North America for '26-'27
5) Jordan Dumais - now 22 years old, has spent two full years in Cleveland now, putting up 11-18-29 over 65 games in the AHL. He may never be an NHLer (though I think Wheeler is higher on him than most analysts).
6) Luca Pinelli (hey, kid shares my birthday) - 3 NHL games in '25-'26, though he did look pretty good in Cleveland
7) Luca Del Bel Belluz - hasn't shown much in 30 career NHL games, but producing well in Cleveland. Turns 23 in November.
The top 4 prospects are all already guaranteed not to play in the NHL until late March at the earliest this season, depending on their situation. If you believe Porty's "Waddell wants to leave a forward spot open for guys to compete," you're talking about, probably, a 4th line spot for one of the Luca's.
Sure, there might be some top end talent there, but two of the four best prospects are goalies, one of whom is 4 years away. Your highest rated forward is a former 4th overall pick whose current ceiling is maybe bottom six NHLer, at best. There's basically no truly high end talent in the pipeline, except for hoping Andreyanov becomes the next Russian goalie star in the NHL in ~5 years.
They've also spent a bunch of draft capital on Conor Garland, 39 games of Mason Marchment, and unloading Laine.
And we think we're going to compete for a Cup in the next 2 years?