They're as real as the 2018-19 Blue Jackets were, if that makes sense. That Torts team had the exact same record through 27 games (15-10-2) and a similar talent profile. More talent than people give them credit for, not enough to actually contend for anything.
Which is to say, they're a try-hard team. They pressure and hit and block like crazy—and chase to do those things. They score mostly in straight-line transition, the second they gain possession the forwards flee the zone for a pass. And they have the right guys for that.
Konecny has 47 goals over the 87 games he's played since the start of last season. He's a real-deal NHL star these days. Then Farabee, Foerster, Tippett, Brink, and (quickly-aging) Atkinson are all dudes who can thrive on the 2-on-1s they create. They have like 5 2nd line wingers on the roster right now.
In terms of possession, they're remedial. Most of their in-zone time is spent digging pucks off the boards and then ringing it back around. They aren't dazzling the defenses with cross-zone passes. The only really competent setup guys on the team are Brink, Frost, and Couturier—basically every other forward is a shooter, and despite all those good wings their center depth is really weak: Couturier, Frost, Poehling, Laughton (Cates is on IR).
Their D is pretty patchwork but overachieving like crazy. Sanheim has been devouring minutes and, while still making mistakes, lugging the puck up ice and shooting with confidence. He's not a perfect 1D, but he sure as hell takes the role more seriously than Provorov ever did. York is a very capable and promising youngster showing signs of similar progress. Seeler-Walker has been one of the best pairings in the league this year, somehow, some way.
So, playing that grinding + quick strike game means they need great goaltending, and they've got it. Hart's a legit top-10 starter. And after 2 rough starts at the beginning of the season, young backup Ersson is 5-1-0 with a .930 over his last 6 starts.
Their PP is ass and their PK is unreal. At 4 v. 5, they're -1 on the season. Only 8 goals allowed, 7 shorthanded goals scored (because their aggressive forward play applies on the PK too).
Is it sustainable? Perhaps for a regular season or two. If they're wise, they should probably ditch some of the overachievers—like Walker—now that Torts has their value as high as it will ever be. Seeing the orange team win games again is fun, but they still need to put themselves in position to draft or trade for/sign high-end C and D talent. Because, while it's fun to win games and maybe pull a first round upset like the 2018-19 Blue Jackets did, it's not fun to be the 2023-24 Blue Jackets, and that's the last thing most of us want to see.