It's not dumb at all. Give a player or a person due credit for what is NOW.It's a dumb metaphore and you know it.
Yes, let's dump him because he has been garbage for more than half his tenure here. We don't need to risk him going back to his norm once he gets the bag. Let someone else overpay for him. He will be 31 when his contract is up, and I am not going to give term to a player that age with his track record. You act like this guy is 25.