Yeah, that'd be a real tough question. Palmieri COULD have developed into a real workhorse, Ponikarovsky sorta player with average skill all around and above average physical game.
Whitney, I'm not really sure he could replicate his AHL numbers in the NHL. I just don't see his offense being good enough to outweigh the knocks on his game. When you're pretty much a replacement-level player from a physicality standpoint, your other attributes have to be through the roof to be successful. In the end, I think that's why Tedenby still has a (slight) chance and Whitney is more likely to spend most of his career in the A. I'd certainly give him a chance though, and if he keeps playing well, he'll make his own chance.
Whitney, I'm not really sure he could replicate his AHL numbers in the NHL. I just don't see his offense being good enough to outweigh the knocks on his game. When you're pretty much a replacement-level player from a physicality standpoint, your other attributes have to be through the roof to be successful. In the end, I think that's why Tedenby still has a (slight) chance and Whitney is more likely to spend most of his career in the A. I'd certainly give him a chance though, and if he keeps playing well, he'll make his own chance.