OK before this thread gets closed just one last case to be made for Fox over Provorov.
Here's a visualization that compares them. It uses xWAR, which is a stat that measures how many wins a player is expected to provide over a season compared to a replacement-level player, and accounts for teammates, competition, etc. It has no relation to goaltending (uses expected goals instead of goals against).
Adam Fox had a truly remarkable season this year. He was significantly better offensively, one of the best defensive defencemen in the league, and productive as well. And keep in mind that these stats aren't rates, they're totals, so Fox did far more in 19 minutes a night than Provorov did in that plus six extra minutes.
The only case for Provorov over Fox is ice time. That's it.
One last thing, since people are grousing about Quality of Competition.
Provorov's most frequent linemates:
- Matt Niskanen
- Sean Couturier
- Claude Giroux
- Travis Konecny
- James van Riemsdyk
Fox's most frequent linemates:
- Ryan Lindgren
- Artemi Panarin
- Jesper Fast
- Pavel Buchnevich
- Ryan Strome
I would be very curious whether Flyers fans would prefer to have the second group of players than the first?