Value of: Actual realistic offers for Chychrun from other fanbases
- Thread starter Bjornar Moxnes
- Start date
What did you guys pay for him? I'd imagine if you cut that into quarters and then pick one of the quarters that would be about the right price.
Hobnobs
Pinko
- Nov 29, 2011
- 9,286
- 2,651
His value is very low right now. Maybe a late first but I doubt it unless a contender becomes desperate. I think you are looking at something like a 2nd + a B/C-prospect as the return.
Jacob582
Registered User
- Oct 16, 2012
- 10,151
- 3,772
Sanderson is our top pairing LD while Klevin is project to play bottom pairing LD next year. That leaves us with Chabot or Chychrun as our 2nd pairing. One has to go.
Not true. But the Sens need to move on from either Chabot or Chychrun.
Empoleon8771
Registered User
Smith, Poulin and one of the Penguins 2nds (44 or 46) for Chychrun.
The Devilish Buffoon
Registered User
- Dec 24, 2018
- 12,708
- 11,499
Chychrun, since coming to Ottawa, has seen his “value” change in the following ways:
+: played a full 82, able to stay healthy
+: continued to display very good goal scoring ability and ability to eat a decent amount of minutes
-: cannot be relied on as a shutdown option
-: cannot be relied on for physicality
-: struggles on his offside
-: struggles to drive/create his own offense
-: mediocre outlet
-: needs a certain type of partner to succeed
-: impending UFA due for raise
-: terrible body language
+: played a full 82, able to stay healthy
+: continued to display very good goal scoring ability and ability to eat a decent amount of minutes
-: cannot be relied on as a shutdown option
-: cannot be relied on for physicality
-: struggles on his offside
-: struggles to drive/create his own offense
-: mediocre outlet
-: needs a certain type of partner to succeed
-: impending UFA due for raise
-: terrible body language
The Devilish Buffoon
Registered User
- Dec 24, 2018
- 12,708
- 11,499
For Ottawa to even consider adding Smith, the offseason would need to be going extremely poorly. i.e no chance we add a player like that pre-draft.
If the deal fit our needs the value wouldnt be awful (very disappointing, but not unimaginavble)… but it doesnt. Find a way to make cap room elsewhere, replace Smith with a modest asset, and then you are probably not far off
Nope. Sens are looking for futures, a RD, a G or vet character forward this offseason.
Example of an acceptable deal would be
To Philly - Chychrun + Joseph
To Ottawa - Laughton + Florida 2024 1st.
- Sep 8, 2004
- 15,390
- 2,070
Sens paid a conditional 1st, a conditional 2nd and a 2nd ...expect the return to be about 40% less than that at a minimum.
i.e. a protected 1st, and a 3rd OR 2 2nds with one of the picks being conditional on resigning and/or making the ECF, then it would become a 1st
BagHead
Registered User
I don't want to trade Rossi, at all, but would maybe do it for Chychrun. Do Sens fans think the value of a Rossi+ deal can make it up to Chychrun's value? I wouldn't do Rossi+Yurov or something of that level, but I would consider Rossi+Haight/Bankier or something like that.
Is that what it would take, or not enough?
Is that what it would take, or not enough?
wintersej
Registered User
Not exactly true, but he gave a very tepid response on his future there.
Don't want it to happen but you have to give to get
Lamoureux, Hayton
4
Chychrun
Also I can see it be expanded
Lamoureux, Hayton
4
Chychrun
Also I can see it be expanded
Empoleon8771
Registered User
Why are you acting like Smith is a negative value asset? He has 1 year left at $5 million and had like 40 points in 75 games last year.
He’s included for cap reasons and probably has the value of like a 3rd on his own.
MN doesn't have the cap space to do that, and I am not on board with moving both Rossi and Bankier, two of our best young C prospects/players. Chychrun has had problems with both organizations he has been on so far, and the reviews on him on the Sens forum have hardly been glowing. Those are a red flag, to me. Maybe, if MN hadn't traded his childhood buddy and friend in Duhaime, who might've helped settle him down, but ...
BagHead
Registered User
I wasn't looking at cap space or making a formal trade offer (I can't do that anyway, I'm not Guerin), I just wondered what the value of Chychrun and Rossi are at relative to each other.
xVolchenkov
Registered User
BagHead
Registered User
The Devilish Buffoon
Registered User
- Dec 24, 2018
- 12,708
- 11,499
I’m not acting like that at all. But literally the last thing Ottawa needs is a $5m middle sixer winger, and they arent going to accept modest value while also needing to immediately flip a $5m middle six winger elsewhete.
He’s included for cap reasons… why not just trade him for a 3rd yourselves, then? You can talk about how easy it is to flip the player, but deals literally never happen that way. What happens a lot is that the team who needs to clear space does so themselves, which is all I suggested.
dirtydanglez
Registered User
- Oct 30, 2022
- 5,376
- 5,421
with one year left i wonder if a cup competitor would take a big swing. nyr has some space and could go all in next season.
I think they have about equal value, when all things are considered. Chychrun has had some very nice seasons, but also some that were less good, and Rossi's youth and contract status are a plus. I can't help but feel that Chychrun's development has been screwed up a bit by being on two dysfunctional, or at least unsettled, franchises.
I never thought Chychrun was vg defensively. Offensively, sure, and because he has nice size and reach he does ok against physicality, too.
I just don't think a LHD is going to move the needle much in MN. Faber has shown he can run the #1PP, Chisholm(LHD) the #2, Brodin and Middleton are solid as LHD, and I expect Hunt(LHD) to be up this year, also. Getting another LHD just doesn't seem to be a need, while Rossi, who had a good rookie season, could well be MN's #2C for years to come.
A team that needs a LHD and PPQB would probably value Chychrun more. If they had a RHD of equal value they could send back in return, I'm sure OTT would be interested.
