Lol you can’t be serious. Last year was his rookie season. You can’t say he is already one of the best dman.
Prospect Info: 6th Overall Pick Moritz Seider, Defence, DEL
- Thread starter LastWordArmy
- Start date
- Status
Realgud
Not good enough for SKA
- Nov 4, 2013
- 5,882
- 7,388
Heiskanen is a rookie too and he's already the best #4 to ever play in the NHL.
Syckle78
Registered User
Roomba With a Bauer
Registered User
- Sep 11, 2007
- 4,511
- 3,135
Filip Hronek just did that and will do it again this season and many more to come
I -think- Hronek is going to end up as a very good first/second pair tweener, which is about where I think Seider will end up. But, he isn't there yet.
The Wings will need to crack the top-four in the draft to get a true top-pair prospect. Hopefully that happens next season.
One of the best defenseman not known for offense I said. And ya I’m serious. Get to know the name
Electric Eric
#91 To the Rafters!
Unfortunately it's looking like next year's draft is very winger heavy at the top. Lots can change though, so who knows.
GBFP
Registered User
- Sep 24, 2009
- 4,737
- 438
Mo(ritz)-Town.
It's crazy to me to listen to that interview and then remember the kid is a young 18yo. Same with the Pistons pick of Sekou Doumbouya who has been playing professionally in France since he was 15yo and basically living on his own while doing so. I think we're too caught up in letting "boys be boys" and thinking they need to have their crazy teens or we're forcing them to miss out or something.
It's crazy to me to listen to that interview and then remember the kid is a young 18yo. Same with the Pistons pick of Sekou Doumbouya who has been playing professionally in France since he was 15yo and basically living on his own while doing so. I think we're too caught up in letting "boys be boys" and thinking they need to have their crazy teens or we're forcing them to miss out or something.
He is incredibly well spoken. Even without consideration for English not being his 1st language
ManwithNoIdentity
Registered User
HisNoodliness
Safe is death
Even if you don't love taking him at 6, you have to love Moritz Seider. He seems like such a nice dude. I haven't bought a jersey in a long time, but when Seider is a Wing I'll have to think about it.
ManwithNoIdentity
Registered User
Kudos to Stevie sticking to his guns and also shocking he NHL. Hes definitely got some big jewels.
lhsgolf19
Registered User
Via Khan
Moritz Seider, Albin Grewe among Red Wings prospects who impressed
Seider will train in his hometown of Mannheim, Germany, before returning for prospects tournament and training camp in Traverse City. The Red Wings will then decide where he should play in 2019-20.
“We have to figure out what’s best for myself,” Seider said. “Maybe it’s in the AHL with Grand Rapids but maybe also CHL (OHL Owen Sound owns his rights). But why stay in Mannheim? I think it’s one of the best organizations in Europe. We won a championship last season. We have to figure it out where I can get the most ice time.”
Moritz Seider, Albin Grewe among Red Wings prospects who impressed
Seider will train in his hometown of Mannheim, Germany, before returning for prospects tournament and training camp in Traverse City. The Red Wings will then decide where he should play in 2019-20.
“We have to figure out what’s best for myself,” Seider said. “Maybe it’s in the AHL with Grand Rapids but maybe also CHL (OHL Owen Sound owns his rights). But why stay in Mannheim? I think it’s one of the best organizations in Europe. We won a championship last season. We have to figure it out where I can get the most ice time.”
At this point I think we can conclude that this kid has an incredible amount of talent. His upside was without a doubt worthy of his draft slot. Definitely needs some fine tuning tho.
GBFP
Registered User
- Sep 24, 2009
- 4,737
- 438
I think the OHL would be out of the question, either AHL or another year in Europe.
I wouldn't count the OHL out. They might want him to work on his offensive game, for which the Owen Sound is likely the best option. If he goes back to Mannheim or comes to GR, he's not going to be on the #1 PP.
And it's not like the DEL is very far from the OHL, in terms of quality of play. The OHL is the best CHL league by quite a lot, and the DEL is maybe the 4th best European pro league? 5th, I guess, because the Czech Extraliga is pretty good too. And then there's the Swiss NLA, so maybe the DEL is 6th. Point is, the gap there is smaller than it seems, especially when we're talking skill level.
Last edited:
Gniwder
IN TODD WE TRUST
Interesting points but who's 1 PP defenseman in GR assuming Hronek is with the Wings? Can't find PP stats for GR, and Hicketts is the only D with any points.
Saarijarvi, if I had to guess. He's kinda gotten lost in the mix lately, but he's a very good PPQB at that level.
Edit: also apparently Charles-Eduard D'astous, although I've never seen him play. He's been one of the better offensive guys in the Q the last couple of years.
Last edited:
Gniwder
IN TODD WE TRUST
Looking at the roster, I don't see any reason why Seider couldn't get decent ice time including PP in GR.
FissionFire
Registered User
You severely underrate the DEL. I read a chat between Prasanth and a scout who rates the leagues relative to each other and the DEL was the 2nd best in Europe (not counting KHL) behind the SHL. There is a lot of talent in the German leagues plenty of former NHL players. The OHL would be a big step down in competition. The AHL is the next logical step.
D’Astous is most likely ECHL bound at the start of the season. He won’t be a Day 1 PPQB in GR.
The Griffins have lots of openings for D on the PP right now. Lashoff and McIlrath are under contract but neither is exactly a PP threat. Cholowski and Hronek may be in Detroit. Saarijarvi struggled put up points last year so it’s still questionable if he’s a legit AHL PPQB. Hicketts is a LHD so won’t be taking a spot on the right side. It looks like the only real RHD guys who could slot into the top PP are Hronek (Who should be in Detroit) and Saarijarvi (Who May not be good enough). The RHD PP1 slot is wide open for the Griffins right now.
Last edited:
ManwithNoIdentity
Registered User
His potential is unlimited as of right now and he’s definitely DRW material on a personality basis
newfy
Registered User
- Jul 28, 2010
- 15,293
- 9,407
I think I read somewhere that he was only playing about 12 mins a game in Mannheim last season. Without some serious guarantees of more ice time, I highly doubt the wings send him back there.
OHL does seem like a pretty big step down but its also a guarantee of 30 mins a game against the best competition in junior and big offensive mins likely. But I'm not sure the guaranteed offensive minutes are worth cutting out playing against men for a season. Seems like in Grand Rapids he would get to play against men but get some offensive minutes as well. It might not be 30 mins a game butt hat sounds like the best balance. Then he can always be called back up to Detroit if needed/he earns it with his play
HisNoodliness
Safe is death
It's a really tough call. I think without a doubt the best thing for him right now is to continue playing against men, either in the AHL or DEL. Lowering his competition isn't going to prepare him for the NHL sooner... But I can see some logic that going to the OHL might actually make the most sense for his long-term development. Stepping down a league and focusing his development on being as offensive as possible without the responsibilities of a pro league might be Seider's path to his highest upside. I think it certainly sets his development back a year, but he might never have another opportunity to purely develop his offense. I'm not sure what I would do, but Seider has a lot of good options.
If Seider plays in the OHL this year he can still go to the AHL next year right? Or will he now have to age out of juniors like everyone else? (someone please destroy that agreement)
- Status
